Skip to content Skip to footer

Hayek called competition a “discovery procedure”: only through rivalry does it become clear which solution really holds up. That is as true of ideas as it is of goods. On this page you will find a competition in which young authors can win prize money with good arguments, along with our own proposals for how the state can be limited again.

For young authors: the Hayek Essay Competition

Every year, the Friedrich A. von Hayek-Gesellschaft, a German classical liberal society, invites high school students, university students, and doctoral candidates up to the age of 30 to write an essay on a question concerning the order of a free society.

  • Prize: The three best essays receive the Dr. Edmund Radmacher Prize: €1,500, €1,000, and €500.
  • Hayek Days: The winners attend the society’s Hayek-Tage free of charge, including the gala evening.
  • Past topics: 2025 “Defending Liberty? Conscription from a Liberal Perspective,” 2026 “Paths to a Liberal Pension System” (our translations of the German titles).
  • Next call for entries: The call for 2027 has not been published yet, so it is worth keeping an eye on the Hayek-Gesellschaft’s website.

To prepare, we recommend our reading list and our biography of Hayek.

Where ideas are born: think tanks

We present pro-liberty think tanks and associations, from the Mises Institute to Students For Liberty, under Associations and think tanks.

Our ideas: How can the spiral of intervention be stopped?

Ludwig von Mises showed that every government intervention creates new problems that call for the next intervention. Hayek warned that this is the road to serfdom. The following proposals are meant to open the way back. They are offered for discussion.

1. The “Negative Parliament”

A second chamber that may only repeal: by simple majority, it can strike down any law and any regulation. It may not enact new rules, approve spending, or propose replacements.

  • Members: Citizens who demonstrably benefit little from the state, for example net taxpayers who have received no subsidies or government contracts in the past ten years, or selection by lot with strict rules against conflicts of interest.
  • Safeguard against chaos: A repeal takes effect only after two years. During that time, parliament can pass a replacement, but only if it repeals another rule of equal scope in return.
  • Small and lean: 50 to 100 members, no bureaucracy of its own, working with independent impact assessments.

Why it helps: The regular parliament is always under pressure to “do something.” For this chamber, doing nothing is not failure but success. Repealing is politically easier when you do not have to offer an alternative. This gives the state a built-in counterweight, and the system no longer grows automatically in just one direction.

Objections: Chaos? The waiting period ensures stability. Who selects the members? Transparent criteria, overseen by the constitutional court. Too radical? It can be introduced step by step, at first only for economic regulations.

2. Politicians are personally liable

Today, taxpayers foot the bill when laws cause harm. Our proposal for a constitutional article:

Members of parliament, ministers, and other officeholders are personally liable for damage they cause through intentional or grossly negligent breach of their official duties, in particular when they unnecessarily restrict competition or fundamental freedoms, adopt interventions without assessing their consequences, or set off a cascade of further interventions. Anyone who can show that they decided on a transparent basis of information and through an orderly procedure is protected (“Political Judgment Rule”). Those affected may also claim damages directly.

Why it helps: Those who are liable with their own assets will think twice about well-meant interventions. Power without accountability becomes accountable.

3. The state may do only what is expressly permitted

An exhaustive list of government functions in the constitution: anything not listed there is forbidden to the state. The U.S. Constitution follows this principle (Article I, Section 8). In The Classical Liberal Constitution, legal scholar Richard Epstein describes how strong protection of property and contract belongs with it. The limit: broad interpretations can water down such a list, so it needs courts that take it seriously.

4. Laws with an expiration date

Every regulatory law expires automatically after five to ten years unless parliament expressly renews it after a review. Before renewal, it must be shown that the benefits outweigh the harm and that there is no better market-based solution. Such “sunset clauses” already exist in some U.S. states. Why it helps: It is not repeal that has to be justified, but continued existence.

5. Automatic expiry when side effects appear

Every regulation gets measurable goals. If it misses them or causes significant harm, it ends on its own. This requires an independent review body that does not itself become a source of new interventions.

6. Hayek’s two-chamber model

In Law, Legislation and Liberty (Volume 3), Hayek proposed two chambers: one enacts only general rules of just conduct that apply equally to everyone, while the other may govern only within those rules. This makes targeted interventions in favor of particular groups much harder.

7. The people as a brake

In Switzerland, many costly or regulatory projects are voted down in popular referendums. On top of that, the federal constitution contains a debt brake: in the long run, spending may not exceed revenue.

Conclusion

Taming the state rarely succeeds through good intentions; it is more likely to succeed through smart rules. The most effective approach would probably be a combination: limited government functions and strong protection of property as the foundation, expiration dates for all new regulations, high hurdles or referendums for interventions, and the Negative Parliament as a permanent counterweight.

Your idea? Do you have a proposal of your own for how liberty can be secured for good? Write to us. We will feature the best ideas here.

Popular:

Tip: press / or Ctrl+K to open search from any page.