Enemy of the State
Enemy of the State
A fast-paced thriller that, long before Snowden, shows how a person can be destroyed without a trial, even if it conveniently pins the blame on a single villain.
- Year
- 1998
- Country
- United States
- Genre
- Political thriller
- Running time
- 132 min
- Rating
- 12 (German FSK rating)
- Message of liberty
- Explicit
Ratings: IMDb 7.3/10 · Rotten Tomatoes 71% · Metacritic 67 · as of 11/2026
Where to watch: In Germany: Disney+ (subscription); rent or buy from Apple TV, Amazon Video, Sky Store, MagentaTV, and others · as of 11/2026
What it is about
Congress is about to vote on a bill that would give the intelligence agencies sweeping surveillance powers. A congressman who opposes it out of concern for civil liberties is murdered at the instigation of NSA official Thomas Reynolds (Jon Voight), and the killing is staged to look like an accident. A wildlife researcher happens to capture the murder on camera. While on the run, he secretly slips the footage to Washington lawyer Robert Clayton Dean (Will Smith), who knows nothing about any of it.
From then on, the whole apparatus turns against Dean. His clothes and his home are bugged, his accounts are frozen, and planted rumors about Mafia ties and an affair do the rest. Within a few days he loses his job, his reputation, and the support of his family, without even knowing who is after him. The only help he finds is Brill (Gene Hackman), a former NSA surveillance specialist who has lived for years in such a way that no data collection can find him anymore. Together the two try to turn the tables.
What the film says about liberty
What stands out is that surveillance here is not just a backdrop for chase scenes but the engine of the plot. Everything begins with a law meant to trade less liberty for more security, and with a man who dies because he refuses to go along. So the film raises the question of whom such powers should be entrusted to in its very first scene.
It is strongest where it shows, step by step, how an ordinary citizen’s life is destroyed. Dean is never charged, never questioned, and never brought before a judge. No verdict is needed when you can feed the right information to his bank, his employer, and his wife. The tracking device in his shoe and the suddenly worthless credit card make vivid what the rule of law is supposed to prevent: punishment without due process. The film also shows that data collected about uninvolved people is dangerous even before anyone misuses it, because in the wrong hands it instantly becomes a weapon. Next to this, George Orwell’s telescreen seems almost cozy, since at least you could see it hanging on the wall.
The film’s true champion of liberty is Brill. He knows the apparatus from the inside, has deliberately removed himself from it, and now turns his knowledge against it. A file with a photo of his younger self comes from Francis Ford Coppola’s The Conversation (1974), in which Hackman also played a surveillance specialist, and so links two generations of surveillance cinema.
That the film is more than entertainment became clear in 2013. After Edward Snowden’s revelations, many commentators pointed to it; New York Magazine spoke with screenwriter David Marconi, and in 2016 Business Insider reported on internal NSA emails indicating that many of the capabilities shown in the film had been confirmed by the Snowden documents. To prepare, Marconi had read James Bamford’s book The Puzzle Palace about the NSA and had hoped the film would spark a debate. The agency itself was less than thrilled: according to the emails, it had met with the director and producers in the hope of a favorable portrayal and was disappointed.
Where the film falls short
At its core, the villain is a single official. Reynolds acts on his own and for the sake of his career, the NSA leadership knows nothing, and in the end another agency sets things right. The Guardian criticized exactly this in 2013: in such films, it argued, a rogue agent always abuses a fundamentally benign system that itself appears morally neutral. The film leaves open whether the apparatus would be harmless without Reynolds, and anyone asking whether such sweeping power should exist at all gets only half an answer from it.
There is a certain irony in the fact that Dean and Brill end up fighting back with their opponent’s methods, bugging a congressman in a hotel room themselves. On top of that comes what several reviews point out: pace and action drown out the theme, and the technology is heavily exaggerated. The Lexikon des internationalen Films, Germany’s standard film reference, finds that after a strong start the film soon runs out of steam. Marconi himself says Oliver Stone would have put more emphasis on the themes, while Tony Scott turned it mainly into entertainment.
Who should watch it
If you are looking for a classic late-nineties Hollywood thriller with Will Smith at his best and a gruff Gene Hackman, this is the film for you. In Germany it is rated for ages 12 and up; it is loud and fast but without much graphic violence. It works well for a movie night with discussion, because it can be read against the reality after 2013: what seemed exaggerated back then is today more a question of scale. The theatrical cut runs 132 minutes.
Sources
- Der Staatsfeind Nr. 1 (Wikipedia, in German), https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Der_Staatsfeind_Nr._1
- Enemy of the State (film) (Wikipedia), https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enemy_of_the_State_(film)
- Der Staatsfeind Nr. 1 | Filmdienst (Lexikon des internationalen Films, in German), https://www.filmdienst.de/film/details/509972/der-staatsfeind-nr-1
- Der Staatsfeind Nr. 1 – Die Filmstarts-Kritik auf FILMSTARTS.de (in German), https://www.filmstarts.de/kritiken/16026/kritik.html
- Der Staatsfeind Nr. 1 – Film 1998 – FILMSTARTS.de (in German), https://www.filmstarts.de/kritiken/16026.html
- Enemy of the State | Rotten Tomatoes, https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/enemy_of_the_state
- Enemy of the State | Metacritic, https://www.metacritic.com/movie/enemy-of-the-state/
- Der Staatsfeind Nr. 1 – Stream: Jetzt Film online anschauen (JustWatch, in German), https://www.justwatch.com/de/Film/Der-Staatsfeind-Nr-1
- “Enemy of the State” Screenwriter David Marconi on the NSA (New York Magazine), https://nymag.com/news/frank-rich/enemy-of-the-state-2013-7/
- How Hollywood softened us up for NSA surveillance (The Guardian), https://www.theguardian.com/film/shortcuts/2013/jun/16/hollywood-softened-us-up-nsa-surveillance
- These emails show how upset NSA spies were with the ‘Enemy of the State’ film (Business Insider), https://www.businessinsider.com/nsa-enemy-of-the-state-2016-1
- Looking back at Tony Scott’s Enemy Of The State (Den of Geek), https://www.denofgeek.com/movies/looking-back-at-tony-scotts-enemy-of-the-state/
- Der Staatsfeind Nr. 1 – Trailer (YouTube Movies, in German), https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Al2rF_tZALI
- Enemy of the State (1998) Trailer #1 (Rotten Tomatoes Classic Trailers), https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZjogdKObxrI
