The Lives of Others
A haunting parable about surveillance and conscience, best seen as a fairy tale about a rare human being rather than as a report on the Stasi.
- Year
- 2006
- Country
- Germany
- Genre
- Drama, political thriller
- Running time
- 137 min
- Rating
- 12 (German FSK rating)
- Message of liberty
- Explicit
Ratings: IMDb 8.4/10 · Rotten Tomatoes 92% · Metacritic 89 · as of 11/2026
Where to watch: In Germany: streaming with an HBO Max subscription; rent or buy digitally from Amazon Video, Apple TV, MagentaTV, Rakuten TV, and others · as of 11/2026
What it is about
East Berlin, November 1984: Captain Gerd Wiesler (Ulrich Mühe) is an interrogation specialist with the Stasi, East Germany’s State Security Service, and teaches at the Stasi’s own college how to break suspects through sleep deprivation. His superior Grubitz (Ulrich Tukur) assigns him to the successful and so far loyal playwright Georg Dreyman (Sebastian Koch). The motive has less to do with reasons of state than the files would suggest: Culture Minister Hempf covets Dreyman’s partner, the actress Christa-Maria Sieland (Martina Gedeck), and wants to get rid of his rival.
Wiesler has the apartment bugged and listens in from the attic. Dreyman’s friend, the director Albert Jerska, has been banned from working in his profession and is broken by it. In response, Dreyman begins writing an article for a West German magazine on a smuggled typewriter, about the suicide rate in the GDR (East Germany), which the state no longer publishes. Wiesler, who has no life outside his job, is drawn ever deeper into the lives of the people he is listening to and has to decide what he puts in his reports.
What the film says about liberty
Few German films show as precisely how surveillance dissolves private life. The bugs, the transcripts, and the neighbor silenced with a curt threat add up to a picture in which no space is left that belongs to the individual. For the eavesdropping equipment, the production used genuine Stasi gear. George Orwell sketched this condition in his novel 1984, and there is a particular irony in the film beginning in that very year.
The abuse of power is just as clear. The entire operation serves a minister’s desire and an officer’s career, so state power appears not as the protector of an order but as a tool of individuals. Behind this lies the old insight of the liberty tradition that unchecked power will be abused because no one can prevent its abuse. Part of this is the artists’ dependence: Jerska is no longer allowed to work, Sieland can be blackmailed because her roles depend on the minister’s goodwill, and anyone who lives by the Party’s grace writes cautiously.
Dreyman’s article about the suppressed statistic is a classic free speech motif, and the hidden typewriter becomes its symbol. The film counters propaganda not with violence but with truth, art, and silence. Florian Henckel von Donnersmarck has said the idea came to him when he remembered Gorky’s account that Lenin could not listen to Beethoven’s Appassionata often because it affected his nerves. He believes that honest art, art that is not propaganda, can change people, and so a “Sonata for a Good Man” and a volume of Brecht poems that Wiesler takes with him play a quiet leading role.
The film is strongest where it shows the watcher himself. Wiesler has as little private life as the apartments he bugs, and yet he remains responsible for what he does. The director described the Stasi as breakers of souls, in contrast to the Gestapo as breakers of bones, and the film takes this distinction seriously.
Where the film falls short
The objection worth knowing concerns the good Stasi officer. Historians know of no documented case in which a full-time officer went through a transformation like Wiesler’s, and the historian Jens Gieseke called such an idealist a foreign body within the Stasi. The author Anna Funder considered the film outstanding but not true to life, because Stasi officers usually worked in teams and were themselves watched. Hubertus Knabe refused to make a Stasi man a hero, which is why filming was not allowed at the Hohenschönhausen Memorial, the former Stasi prison, and Werner Schulz accused the film of creatively playing down the Stasi.
The film’s picture of the era is also disputed. Christoph Hein, whose life story partly went into it and who had his name removed from the credits, called the film a horror fairy tale; the taz, a left-leaning Berlin daily, faulted it for showing a high Stalinism that no longer existed in that form by the mid-eighties. Joachim Gauck, the first head of the federal agency that manages the Stasi files, felt by contrast that despite inaccuracies it got a great deal right, and his successor Marianne Birthler pointed out that it is not a documentary. Even filmstarts.de, otherwise full of praise, finds Wiesler’s transformation not entirely convincing and the film somewhat long.
So the film is best seen as a parable about conscience. The reality in the Stasi files was harsher, and it knew far fewer Wieslers than Grubitzes.
Who should watch it
For anyone who wants to know what a surveillance state feels like from the inside, and for younger viewers who know the GDR only from history books. The film is quietly told, without graphic violence, but oppressive, and it asks for some patience. It works very well for a movie night with discussion, precisely because Wiesler’s credibility is so good to argue about.
Sources
- Das Leben der Anderen, Wikipedia (in German), https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Das_Leben_der_Anderen
- The Lives of Others, Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Lives_of_Others
- The Lives of Others, Rotten Tomatoes, https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/the_lives_of_others
- The Lives of Others, Metacritic, https://www.metacritic.com/movie/the-lives-of-others/
- Das Leben der Anderen, filmstarts.de (in German), https://www.filmstarts.de/kritiken/111643.html
- Das Leben der Anderen, filmportal.de (search result only), https://filmportal.de/en/print/81579
- Das Leben der Anderen, JustWatch Germany (in German), https://www.justwatch.com/de/Film/Das-Leben-der-Anderen
- The Lives of Others | Official Trailer (2006), YouTube (Sony Pictures Classics), https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n3_iLOp6IhM
