Nineteen Eighty-Four
Nineteen Eighty-Four
A faithful, oppressively gray adaptation that takes Orwell's warning about the total state more seriously than many who use the word “Orwellian” every day.
- Year
- 1984
- Country
- United Kingdom
- Genre
- Science fiction, drama
- Running time
- 106 min
- Rating
- 16 (German FSK rating)
- Message of liberty
- Explicit
Ratings: IMDb 7.0/10 · Rotten Tomatoes 76% · Metacritic 67 · as of 11/2026
Where to watch: In Germany: subscription via the MGM+ Amazon Channel; rent or buy on Apple TV, Amazon Video, MagentaTV, Sky Store and others · as of 11/2026
What it is about
Oceania in the year 1984: Winston Smith works at the Ministry of Truth, where he rewrites old newspaper reports so that they fit whatever the current party line happens to be. What was reported yesterday never happened today, and Winston sees to it. In his apartment, at the office and on the street, the telescreen watches him, and Big Brother looks down from every wall. Even so, Winston secretly begins a diary, which in this state already counts as thoughtcrime.
At work he notices young Julia, whom he at first takes for an informer. Suspicion turns into a forbidden love affair, and the two rent a room above old Mr. Charrington’s junk shop, where they believe they are unobserved. At the same time, Winston seeks out O’Brien, a member of the Inner Party, in whom he suspects a secret ally. How it ends will not be revealed here; anyone who knows the novel can guess anyway.
Michael Radford, who also wrote the screenplay, shot the film in the spring of 1984 in and around London, that is, exactly at the time in which Orwell sets his novel. By his own account, he wanted to make a science fiction film that looks as if it had been shot in 1948. Cinematographer Roger Deakins drained almost all the color from the images with a bleach bypass, and the run-down postwar London looks the part.
What the film says about liberty
The film shows the total state without any embellishment, and it needs no spaceships to do so. The very first gesture is political: Winston sits down in a blind spot of the telescreen in order to write. In Oceania, privacy is not a right but a gap in the system, and whoever uses it makes himself suspect. In this the film captures an idea that thinkers of liberty have stressed again and again: where the state may see everything, there is no space left in which a person can form an opinion of his own.
The control of thought is just as plain. No deed is needed to be guilty, a thought is enough, and the Two Minutes Hate, in which the staff scream together at an enemy of the state on the screen, shows the collective as a ritual. The core, however, is Winston’s work at the Ministry of Truth: whoever falsifies the past determines what counts as true in the present. The diary, by contrast, stands for the simple right to record one’s own perceptions.
What the state also claims for itself is striking. The relationship between Winston and Julia is private and not meant politically at all, and precisely for that reason it is forbidden. Added to this is the gray economy of scarcity with rationing and substitute goods, while real goods are reserved for the Inner Party. The state ideology is called Ingsoc, English Socialism, and it is a centrally planned economy that administers the misery. Readers of Hayek’s The Road to Serfdom will recognize a good deal here; the book appeared five years before Orwell’s novel.
Where the film falls short
Honesty is called for here. George Orwell was a democratic socialist: in his 1946 essay Why I Write, he writes that his serious work since 1936 had been directed against totalitarianism and for democratic socialism as he understood it. After the novel appeared, he had it stated explicitly in 1949 that the book was not intended as an attack on socialism. Radford, too, saw his film as a rejection of every tyranny and set it apart from the 1956 adaptation, which he regarded as an anticommunist smear. Reading the planned economy and the name Ingsoc as a warning against socialism is therefore our interpretation, not the author’s. The film still supports it well, precisely because it warns against every all-powerful state, whatever flag it flies. It is not, however, a plea for markets and private property.
If you are looking for encouragement, you will be disappointed. The film is bleak; it offers no counterworld and no savior, which is honest but leaves the viewer rather alone. On top of that there is a dispute over the music: the film company Virgin Films pushed through tracks by Eurythmics, Radford and his producer considered this a distortion of the film’s meaning, and Radford withdrew the film from the BAFTA awards as a result. Since then there have been two versions, one with pop music and a director’s cut with an orchestral score, and unfortunately no telescreen will tell you which one you will get on a stream.
Who should watch it
The film is worthwhile for everyone who has read Orwell’s novel or wants to, and for anyone who wants to understand how surveillance, propaganda and the falsification of history work together. It is quietly told, dark and harsh in some scenes; its German rating of 16 and up is appropriate. It works very well for a film night with discussion, especially if the debate is anchored in the film and not in current politics. Every camp now hurls the word “Orwellian” at the others; after this film, you will at least know again what it actually means.
Sources
- 1984 (1984), Wikipedia (in German), https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/1984_(1984)
- Nineteen Eighty-Four (1984 film), Wikipedia (en), https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nineteen_Eighty-Four_(1984_film)
- 1984 (1984), Rotten Tomatoes, https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/1984_1984
- 1984 (1985), Metacritic, https://www.metacritic.com/movie/1984/
- 1984 (1984), IMDb (search index only, page blocked), https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0087803/
- 1984, Die Filmstarts-Kritik, FILMSTARTS.de (in German), https://www.filmstarts.de/kritiken/1791/kritik.html
- 1984, Film-Kritik, filmdienst.de (in German), https://www.filmdienst.de/film/details/32986/1984
- 1984, JustWatch Germany (in German), https://www.justwatch.com/de/Film/1984
- The Den of Geek interview: Michael Radford, https://www.denofgeek.com/movies/the-den-of-geek-interview-michael-radford/
- Why I Write, The Orwell Foundation, https://www.orwellfoundation.com/the-orwell-foundation/orwell/essays-and-other-works/why-i-write/
- The secrets of Nineteen Eighty-Four, International Socialism Journal, https://isj.org.uk/the-secrets-of-nineteen-eighty-four/
- 1984 (1984) Teaser Trailer, Rotten Tomatoes Classic Trailers (YouTube), https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=djx5i7nNZ-Y
- 1984 trailer, German dubbed version, FILMSTARTS.de (in German), https://www.filmstarts.de/kritiken/1791/trailer/20601775.html
