In 1887 Mandell Creighton, a church historian at Cambridge and editor of the newly founded English Historical Review, asked a learned acquaintance for a review. Creighton was writing a multivolume history of the papacy in the age of the Reformation and had treated the popes in it with great leniency. The sharp draft led to an exchange of letters, and on April 5 the reviewer wrote Creighton a long letter from Cannes. He could not accept, he wrote, Creighton’s “canon that we are to judge Pope and King unlike other men, with a favourable presumption that they did no wrong.” If there was any presumption, it was “the other way against holders of power, increasing as the power increases.”
A few lines later came the sentence that made the letter famous: “Power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely.” Its author was John Emerich Edward Dalberg-Acton, Lord Acton, and his sentence is quoted today in parliaments and editorials, often shortened and usually without the idea it grew out of, even though only that idea shows what Acton was actually demanding with it.
At a glance
- Life: January 10, 1834, in Naples to June 19, 1902, in Tegernsee
- Work: Liberal member of the House of Commons 1859 to 1866, from 1869 Baron Acton and member of the House of Lords, from 1895 Regius Professor of Modern History at Cambridge
- Major works: Nationality (1862), the lectures The History of Freedom in Antiquity and The History of Freedom in Christianity (1877), the letter to Mandell Creighton (1887), the inaugural lecture The Study of History (1895)
- In one sentence: He wrote the history of Europe as a history of liberty and demanded that the powerful be judged more strictly than anyone else.
A European shut out of Cambridge
Acton was born in Naples. His grandfather, an English baronet, had been an admiral and prime minister of the Kingdom of Naples; his mother came from the Dalberg family, and after his father died young, she married the Liberal politician Lord Granville in 1840. The boy went to school near Paris, at Oscott in England, and in Edinburgh, and these stops alone show how naturally he moved among the countries of Europe.
Because he was a Catholic, he was not admitted to study at Cambridge. Instead he went to Munich and lived from 1848 to 1854 in the house of the theologian and church historian Ignaz von Döllinger, who remained his friend for life. Back in England, Acton sat for the Liberals in the House of Commons from 1859 to 1866 and edited Catholic journals, first The Rambler, then the Home and Foreign Review. After a papal statement on Catholic writers, he chose in 1864 to shut down the Review rather than continue it under church supervision.
In 1869 Acton was raised to the peerage as a baron, largely at the urging of William Gladstone. He spent the following winter in Rome, where the First Vatican Council was deliberating on papal infallibility, and worked there against the planned dogma. He lost, and his teacher Döllinger was excommunicated in 1871. Acton, who expected the same fate, was not expelled and remained a Catholic.
Recognition came late. In 1895, on the recommendation of Prime Minister Lord Rosebery, he became Regius Professor of Modern History, and of all places at Cambridge, which had turned him away as a student. He planned the multivolume Cambridge Modern History, whose publication he did not live to see. His library of some 60,000 volumes had been bought by the industrialist Andrew Carnegie during Acton’s lifetime and left to him for his use; after his death it passed through John Morley to the University of Cambridge.
A burden of proof for the powerful
The letter to Creighton contains more than a bon mot, because in it Acton sets out a rule for the burden of proof. Under this rule, whoever exercises power over others deserves less trust, and the distrust grows with the extent of the power. Kings and popes seldom stand before a court in their lifetime, and so, in Acton’s words, “Historic responsibility has to make up for the want of legal responsibility.” And then comes the sentence that is perhaps even sharper than the famous one: “There is no worse heresy than that the office sanctifies the holder of it.”
With this Acton turns against a tendency that is strong in every society. People like to assume that those who govern have reasons ordinary people simply cannot see through, and so they excuse in them what they would condemn in any neighbor. Acton considered this leniency a seduction of judgment. Acton reproaches Creighton in the same letter: “You would hang a man of no position, . . . Here are the greater names coupled with the greater crimes. You would spare these criminals, for some mysterious reason.”
In his inaugural lecture at Cambridge on June 11, 1895, he passed this attitude on to his students. He exhorted them “never to debase the moral currency,” to “try others by the final maxim that governs your own lives,” and to “suffer no man and no cause to escape the undying penalty which history has the power to inflict on wrong.” For the thought of liberty this rigor is a gain, because it allows no special ethics for states and rulers.
Liberty as the highest end
His reputation as the historian of liberty rests on two lectures that Acton gave in 1877 before the Bridgnorth Institution in the Agricultural Hall of Bridgnorth, the small town he had once represented in Parliament: on February 26 on the history of freedom in antiquity, on May 28 on the history of freedom in Christianity.
In the first of them stands the statement: “Liberty is not a means to a higher political end. It is itself the highest political end.” Acton’s reasoning: “It is not for the sake of a good public administration that it is required, but for security in the pursuit of the highest objects of civil society, and of private life.” He even concedes that more freedom “may sometimes promote mediocrity” and “may even retard useful legislation,” and still holds fast to it.
His definition remains remarkable to this day: “By liberty I mean the assurance that every man shall be protected in doing what he believes his duty against the influence of authority and majorities, custom and opinion.” In this formulation liberty must hold its own against kings just as much as against the majority and social pressure. “The State,” Acton adds, “is competent to assign duties and draw the line between good and evil only in its immediate sphere.” From this follows his best-known test: “The most certain test by which we judge whether a country is really free is the amount of security enjoyed by minorities.”
Historically, Acton found liberty where power was divided. Of the medieval struggle between church and crown he wrote: “To that conflict of four hundred years we owe the rise of civil liberty.” Both sides strove for absolute rule, but because neither won, they had to appeal to the people for help, and so the cities of Italy and Germany won their liberties, France its Estates General, and England its Parliament. In this view, liberty owes less to the goodwill of rulers than to the fact that their claims to power hold each other in check. He also knew how rare its defenders are: “At all times sincere friends of freedom have been rare, and its triumphs have been due to minorities.”
Many nations under one roof
As early as 1862, in his essay Nationality, Acton had defended a thesis that ran against the grain of his century. Italy had just been unified, Germany was striving for unity, and the demand that every nation should have its own state was considered liberal. Acton disagreed: “The combination of different nations in one State is as necessary a condition of civilised life as the combination of men in society.” And: “The co-existence of several nations under the same State is a test, as well as the best security of its freedom.”
The reason again lies in the division of power. A state that identifies itself with a single nation can never recognize other ethnic groups within its borders as equals without abandoning its own principle. That is why, in his words, “The greatest adversary of the rights of nationality is the modern theory of nationality.” Anyone who thinks of the expulsions and persecutions of minorities that the twentieth century saw in the name of national unity reads this warning from 1862 with different eyes.
The same preference for divided power led Acton to sympathize with the Southern states in the American Civil War. In November 1866 he wrote to Robert E. Lee: “I saw in State Rights the only availing check upon the absolutism of the sovereign will.” That the Constitution of the Confederate States expressly protected slavery was lost in this calculation, and here a sound principle led to a judgment that could hardly be reconciled with Acton’s own test, the security of minorities.
What friends of liberty can learn from him
The most important lesson is the rule on the burden of proof. It is power that must justify itself, and the more authority someone claims, the more closely one must look. Friedrich August von Hayek understood this: in The Road to Serfdom (1944) he placed Acton’s sentence at the head of the tenth chapter, in which he explains why in a directed economy the most unscrupulous rise to the top. When Hayek gathered scholars from Europe and America in 1947 to found a liberal society, he proposed naming it after Acton and Tocqueville. The proposal did not prevail, and the society is still named after its meeting place, Mont Pèlerin.
Second, Acton shows that liberty has a rank of its own. Whoever defends it only because it brings prosperity will give it up as soon as someone promises more prosperity through central direction. Whoever instead understands it as the highest political end holds fast to it even when it becomes inconvenient.
Third, he directs our attention to minorities and to the division of power. His definition of liberty expressly protects the individual against majorities and against the pressure of public opinion as well, and his history of Europe tells how liberty grew where no single power could swallow all the others. This links him with Alexis de Tocqueville, whom he named in his lecture on antiquity, where he wrote that “our cause owes more to Cicero and Seneca, to Vinet and Tocqueville, than to the laws of Lycurgus or the Five Codes of France.” It links him, too, with all who regard federalism and decentralization as conditions of liberty.
Finally, his own life is an example. Acton applied the standards he applied to kings to his own church as well, of which he remained a member until his death. He would rather shut down a journal than submit to censorship, and he fought in Rome against the expansion of papal authority, even though it could have brought excommunication upon himself.
A sentence and the thinking behind it
Acton left no great systematic work; his ideas are found in lectures, essays, and letters, and yet they are still read and republished today. His famous sentence is only the most visible point of an attitude that demands more accountability from the holder of power than from anyone else and places the liberty of the individual above the convenience of good administration. When a government or agency today asks for more powers, it is worth remembering the letter from Cannes. The presumption is against it, and all the more strongly the more it wants.
Further reading
- Lord Acton: The History of Freedom and Other Essays, ed. J. N. Figgis and R. V. Laurence, Macmillan, London 1907
- Lord Acton: A Lecture on the Study of History, Macmillan, London 1895
- Selected Writings of Lord Acton, ed. J. Rufus Fears, 3 vols., Liberty Fund, Indianapolis 1985 to 1988
- Friedrich August von Hayek: The Road to Serfdom, chapter 10
This article is part of our series on thinkers, doers, and historical figures of liberty.
Sources
- Acton, Lord: “Nationality,” in: The Home and Foreign Review, July 1862; reprinted in: The History of Freedom and Other Essays, Macmillan, London 1907.
- Acton, Lord: “The History of Freedom in Antiquity” (lecture before the Bridgnorth Institution, February 26, 1877) and “The History of Freedom in Christianity” (ibid., May 28, 1877), in: The History of Freedom and Other Essays, ed. J. N. Figgis and R. V. Laurence, Macmillan, London 1907, online: https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/31278
- Acton, Lord: Letter to Robert E. Lee, Bologna, November 4, 1866, printed in: Douglas Southall Freeman, R. E. Lee, vol. 4, appendix, online: https://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Gazetteer/People/Robert_E_Lee/FREREL/4/Appendices/4*.html
- Acton, Lord: Letter to Mandell Creighton, Cannes, April 5, 1887, excerpt based on the Online Library of Liberty text: https://history.hanover.edu/courses/excerpts/165acton.html; complete: https://www.econlib.org/the-acton-creighton-correspondence
- Acton, Lord: A Lecture on the Study of History, delivered at Cambridge, June 11, 1895, Macmillan, London 1895, online: https://www.gutenberg.org/files/25720/25720-0.txt
- Acton, Lord: Selected Writings of Lord Acton, ed. J. Rufus Fears, 3 vols., Liberty Fund, Indianapolis 1985–1988, https://about.libertyfund.org/books/selected-writings-of-lord-acton
- Hayek, Friedrich August von: The Road to Serfdom, Routledge, London 1944, ch. X, “Why the Worst Get on Top” (epigraph), scan: https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.46585
- Constitution of the Confederate States of America (1861), art. I, sec. 9, Avalon Project: https://avalon.law.yale.edu/19th_century/csa_csa.asp
- Figgis, J. N.; Laurence, R. V.: “Chronicle” (Acton’s life dates), in: Acton, The History of Freedom and Other Essays, London 1907.
- Wikipedia (en): John Dalberg-Acton, 1st Baron Acton, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Dalberg-Acton,_1st_Baron_Acton (starting point)
- Wikipedia (en): Mandell Creighton, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mandell_Creighton
- National Portrait Gallery, London: John Acton, 1st Baron Acton, https://www.npg.org.uk/collections/search/portrait/mw00026
- Encyclopedia.com: Döllinger, Johannes Joseph Ignaz von, https://encyclopedia.com/religion/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/dollinger-johannes-joseph-ignaz-von
- Mises Institute: Freedom and Power, Acton-Creighton Correspondence, https://mises.org/online-book/freedom-and-power/acton-creighton-correspondence
- Foundation for Economic Education: The Mont Pelerin Society, https://fee.org/articles/the-mont-pelerin-society/
- Wikipedia (en): Mont Pelerin Society, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mont_Pelerin_Society
Featured image: Lord Acton (AI illustration)

