In June 1381, thousands of peasants and craftsmen from Kent and Essex were camped on the heath of Blackheath outside the gates of London. Before them spoke a priest who had been in prison only a few days earlier. His sermon began, according to the monk Thomas Walsingham, with a couplet that has been linked to his name ever since: When Adam dalf, and Eve span, who was thanne a gentilman? When Adam delved and Eve span, who was then the gentleman?
The man’s name was John Ball, and with these words he asked a question his century considered improper: Where does one person get the right to decide another’s work, place of residence, and marriage? Ball stands at the beginning of a long line of people who have asked this question, even though he did not yet speak of property rights and markets in our sense.
At a glance
- Life: born around 1338, executed on July 15, 1381, in St Albans
- Work: priest, first associated with St Mary’s in York, later in Colchester; for almost two decades an itinerant preacher despite prohibition, excommunication, and imprisonment
- Role in 1381: preacher and spokesman in the English Peasants’ Revolt
- What survives: one sermon and a few short letters, recorded by the chroniclers Thomas Walsingham, Henry Knighton, and Jean Froissart, all of whom were hostile to him
- In one sentence: He publicly denied that God had created people as lords and serfs, and he paid for it with his life.
A Priest Without a Pulpit
Little is known about Ball’s origins. It is thought that he came from Peldon near Colchester in Essex, but there is no proof. In a letter attributed to him, he calls himself “som tyme Seynte Marie prest of York, and now of Colchestre,” once priest of St Mary’s in York and now of Colchester. He belonged to the lower clergy and to those clerics who moved from place to place and preached wherever people gathered: in markets, churchyards, and fields.
The authorities had their eye on him early. As early as February 1364, King Edward III revoked a letter of protection issued for him on the grounds that Ball pursued no business but went from county to county preaching articles contrary to the faith of the Church. He was later excommunicated, and the faithful were forbidden to listen to him. Ball kept preaching anyway, was imprisoned several times, and clashed again and again with Simon Sudbury, the Archbishop of Canterbury. When the revolt began, according to the chronicles, he was being held in the archbishop’s prison at Maidstone in Kent. The historian Andrew Prescott, however, considers it possible that Ball was the John Ball whom rebels freed at Bishop’s Stortford on June 11, 1381.
England After the Great Plague
To understand why his words caught fire, one has to look at the decades before. The plague of 1348 and 1349 had killed a large part of the population. Those who survived were suddenly in demand: labor became scarce, and wages rose. Many peasants at the time were still villeins, bound to their lord’s land, obliged to perform labor services, and free neither to move away nor to marry without his permission. The shortage of hands gave them a bargaining power they had not had before.
The Crown responded with coercion. A law of 1351, the Statute of Labourers, was meant to push wages back down to their pre-plague level and threatened violations with penalties. On top of this came poll taxes to pay for the war against France. The first was levied in 1377; Parliament approved the third at the end of 1380: an average of twelve pence for every person over fifteen, three times as much as before. Within a village the wealthy were supposed to bear more of the burden, but no one paid less than four pence, and for a poor family with several grown children that was a heavy load. When the tax collectors tried to collect arrears in Essex in the spring of 1381, the villages refused to pay, and the resistance quickly spread to Kent.
The Sermon at Blackheath
The sermon that Walsingham records and dates to June 12 is the core of what we know about Ball. In the beginning, Walsingham has Ball say, all people were created equal by nature. Bondage came into the world only through the unjust oppression of wicked men, against the will of God. Had God wanted serfs, he would have determined at the beginning of the world who was to be serf and who lord. Now the time appointed by God had come, in which people, if only they wished, could cast off the yoke of bondage.
The couplet about Adam and Eve was probably a saying that circulated before Ball. But he gave it a twist that made it dangerous. The order of estates was considered ordained by God, and whoever defended the lords against the serfs appealed to Creation. Ball turned the argument around: Creation itself knows no lords. In doing so he placed the rule of one person over another under a burden of justification, and he did not accept a justification based on the will of God.
Walsingham also reports that Ball urged his listeners to kill first the most powerful lords of the realm, then the lawyers, judges, and jurors. Whether Ball actually said this cannot be verified. But the fact that the chronicler attributes it to him is part of the record and must not be left out.
Seen Through the Eyes of His Enemies
Every sentence we know from John Ball has passed through the hands of men who despised him. Thomas Walsingham was a monk of the Benedictine abbey of St Albans, one of the great landlords against whom the revolt was directed. Jean Froissart, who was not in England in 1381, wrote his chronicle for an aristocratic audience and, in Thomas Johnes’s English translation, called Ball a “crazy priest in the county of Kent.” Both shaped the speeches freely, as was customary in the historical writing of their time.
In Froissart, Ball says that things are not going well in England and will not go well “until everything shall be in common,” and there are neither serfs nor lords anymore. What Ball meant by holding things in common, whether an order of property or the end of differences of rank, the source does not say. All that is certain is that Froissart wanted to portray a man who wanted to turn the world upside down.
Walsingham further claims that Ball spread the heresies of the Oxford theologian John Wyclif. Historians regard this as polemic, since Ball was already preaching a decade before Wyclif attracted attention. The basic ideas of his sermon, the original equality of all people and the injustice of bondage, recur in every account. The details bear the stamp of the narrators.
The Days in June
On June 13, 1381, the rebels marched into London. They opened the prisons, destroyed the Savoy Palace of the king’s uncle John of Gaunt, and killed lawyers, royal officials, and many Flemings who lived in the city. The next day the fourteen-year-old King Richard II met the men of Essex at Mile End and promised charters that would release them from serfdom. At the same time another group broke into the Tower and beheaded Archbishop Sudbury, who was also chancellor, and the treasurer Robert Hales.
On June 15, Wat Tyler, the leader from Kent, presented his demands at Smithfield. According to the so-called Anonimalle Chronicle, he demanded that there be no more serfs and no villeinage in England and that equality prevail among all people, with the sole exception of the king. Shortly afterward the mayor, William Walworth, struck him down; Tyler was killed, and the revolt fell apart. On July 2 the king revoked the charters of freedom he had granted at Mile End, on the grounds that they had been extorted from him.
After the revolt collapsed, Ball was captured in Coventry. He was put on trial in St Albans, where, unlike most of the accused, he was allowed to speak. On July 15, 1381, he was hanged, drawn, and quartered in the presence of the king. His head was set on a pike on London Bridge, and the parts of his body were displayed in four towns. How much the authorities feared his influence is shown by a case from Cambridge: shortly afterward a man named John Shirle was hanged there for allegedly praising Ball in a tavern.
What Came After Him
The revolt failed, and yet in the long run the peasants achieved much of what they had demanded. Poll taxes of this kind were never levied again. Serfdom disappeared over the course of the fifteenth century without any law abolishing it. Because labor remained scarce, villeins could negotiate better terms, buy their freedom, or simply move away, and labor services were gradually replaced by money rents. The historian Mark Bailey describes how hereditary unfreedom in this way, through the quiet pressure of many individual agreements, had become almost meaningless by the middle of the century.
Ball himself remained a bogeyman for four centuries, until the radicals rediscovered him toward the end of the eighteenth century. Thomas Paine, who does not mention Ball himself, defended Wat Tyler in 1792, in a footnote to the second part of his Rights of Man, as “an intrepid disinterested man with respect to himself” and wrote that all his proposals to Richard “were on a more just and public ground than those which had been made to John by the Barons.” In 1888 the socialist William Morris made Ball a hero of the labor movement with A Dream of John Ball. Since then the left has invoked him as much as friends of liberty have, and both find in the scant sources something they are looking for.
What Friends of Liberty Can Learn from Him
Ball should not be turned into a libertarian he was not. He thought in the language of the Bible, awaited an hour appointed by God, and, as far as we know, said nothing about markets or contracts. Later thinkers such as John Locke grounded the natural liberty of human beings in their own ways. His contribution lies at an earlier point.
He insisted that rule must justify itself and that custom and birth are no justification. Serfdom rested on the premise that part of a person’s labor, time, and life decisions belonged to someone else. Ball called this an injustice and appealed to the highest authority his listeners knew. The idea that by nature a person belongs to no one returns in the later doctrines of self-ownership, even though no documented line leads from Ball to them.
The occasion is instructive too. The revolt was sparked by a tax levied per head to finance a war, and by a law that forbade people to ask for their labor the price others were willing to pay voluntarily. Both show how closely personal liberty and the liberty to trade are connected. And the history of the following decades teaches that the violence of 1381 did little for liberty, while the bargaining power of scarce labor gradually brought it about.
The Question Remains
John Ball left behind no book, no school, and no securely attested speech. He left a rhyme and a question, recorded by men who wanted to refute him. That the question has survived nonetheless speaks to its power. Every order that places one person above another must face it: Who decided it should be so, and by what right? Ball put it to a field full of tired, angry people, and it has not fallen silent since.
Further reading
- R. B. Dobson (ed.): The Peasants’ Revolt of 1381, Macmillan, London 1970, 2nd edition 1983 (collection of sources including Walsingham, Froissart, Knighton, and the Anonimalle Chronicle)
- Juliet Barker: England, Arise. The People, the King and the Great Revolt of 1381, Little, Brown, London 2014
- Mark Bailey: The Decline of Serfdom in Late Medieval England, Boydell & Brewer, Woodbridge 2014
- William Morris: A Dream of John Ball, Reeves & Turner, London 1888
This article is part of our series on thinkers, doers, and historical figures of liberty.
Sources
- Walsingham, Thomas: Historia Anglicana / Chronica maiora (Blackheath sermon, John Ball’s letters); edition: The St Albans Chronicle. The Chronica maiora of Thomas Walsingham, ed. and trans. by John Taylor, Wendy R. Childs, and Leslie Watkiss, vol. 1, Clarendon Press, Oxford 2003, pp. 546–549.
- Froissart, Jean: Chroniques, Book II, ch. 73; English: Chronicles of England, France, Spain, and the adjoining countries, trans. by Thomas Johnes, Leavitt and Allen, New York 1857.
- Anonimalle Chronicle, account of Smithfield, after Charles Oman: The Great Revolt of 1381, Clarendon Press, Oxford 1906, pp. 200–205; online: Internet Medieval Sourcebook, https://sourcebooks.fordham.edu/source/anon1381.asp
- Dobson, R. B. (ed.): The Peasants’ Revolt of 1381, Macmillan, London 1970, 2nd ed. 1983 (collection of sources including Walsingham, Froissart, Knighton, Anonimalle Chronicle; sermon p. 375, letters pp. 380–383).
- Calendar of the Patent Rolls, Edward III, vol. XII, London 1912 (letters patent of February 25, 1364).
- Paine, Thomas: Rights of Man, Part 2, London 1792, ch. 5.
- Morris, William: A Dream of John Ball, Reeves & Turner, London 1888.
- Crossley, James, et al.: John Ball 1381, “The Historical John Ball,” https://johnball1381.org/historical-john-ball/ and “The Letters of John Ball,” https://johnball1381.org/letters/
- Prescott, Andrew: article “Ball, John (d. 1381),” in: Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Oxford 2004, online version 2008 (quoted in Crossley).
- Barker, Juliet: England, Arise. The People, the King and the Great Revolt of 1381, Little, Brown, London 2014.
- Bailey, Mark: The Decline of Serfdom in Late Medieval England. From Bondage to Freedom, Boydell & Brewer, Woodbridge 2014, https://boydellandbrewer.com/9781783271283
- Carlin, Martha: “Two Episodes from Froissart’s Chronicles,” University of Wisconsin–Milwaukee, https://sites.uwm.edu/carlin/?p=1020
- London Museum: “How the Peasants’ Revolt rocked medieval London,” https://londonmuseum.org.uk/collections/london-stories/how-peasants-revolt-rocked-medieval-london
- The National Archives: “Revolt: The story of England’s first protest,” https://blog.nationalarchives.gov.uk/revolt-the-story-of-englands-first-protest/
- World History Encyclopedia: “Peasants’ Revolt,” https://www.worldhistory.org/Peasants’_Revolt/
- Wikipedia (en): “John Ball (priest),” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Ball_(priest) (starting point only)
Featured image: John Ball (AI illustration, free interpretation)

