Skip to content Skip to footer

Marcus Tullius Cicero: The True Law Above the Law

Marcus Tullius Cicero

On a December day in 43 BC, servants carried a litter toward the coast near Formiae. Inside sat a man in his sixty-fourth year who hoped to escape by sea from the soldiers of Mark Antony. When his pursuers caught up with him, he had the litter set down, looked them in the face, and stretched out his neck, as Plutarch tells it. On Antony’s orders, his head and hands were displayed at the speakers’ platform in the Forum, the hands with which he had written his speeches against Antony.

Marcus Tullius Cicero had been Rome’s most famous orator and one of its consuls. The republic he defended perished, but his writings survived. They passed on to the West the idea that above every decision of the powerful stands a law they cannot change, and that a political order exists above all to secure to each his own. Even so, he does not make a libertarian. He was a Roman senator with the convictions of his class, and that is exactly why it is worth asking which of his ideas point beyond him.

At a glance

  • Life: born in 106 BC in Arpinum, killed in December 43 near Formiae
  • Offices: quaestor 75, praetor 66, consul 63, governor of Cilicia 51 to 50 (all years BC)
  • Major works: De re publica (On the Republic), De legibus (On the Laws), De officiis (On Duties), Philippics
  • Citations: by book and section, for example “De officiis II 73”; quotations are rendered in our own translation
  • In one sentence: He made the Stoic doctrine of natural law, and the protection of property as the purpose of the state, the common heritage of Europe.

A Newcomer from a Country Town

Cicero came from a wealthy family of the equestrian order in Arpinum, southeast of Rome. None of his ancestors had sat in the Senate, and as a homo novus, a new man, he had to make his way against the old families. As an advocate he became famous in 70 with his prosecution of Gaius Verres, who as governor had plundered Sicily and went into exile before the verdict.

As consul in 63, Cicero uncovered the conspiracy of Lucius Sergius Catilina. He had five arrested co-conspirators, among them a sitting praetor, Publius Cornelius Lentulus, strangled in the state prison without any court having convicted them; the Senate had followed Cato’s motion. In the same session Caesar had proposed imprisonment and confiscation of their property and warned, in Sallust’s account, that “all bad precedents have originated in cases which were good.” Cicero argued that the law guaranteeing citizens a trial before the people before any death sentence did not apply to enemies of the state, because an enemy of the state was no citizen. This reasoning caught up with him when the tribune of the plebs Clodius pushed through a law in 58 against anyone who had put citizens to death without trial. Cicero went into exile and did not return until the following year.

In the civil war he sided with Pompey and was afterward pardoned by Caesar. After Caesar’s murder he attacked Antony in fourteen speeches, called the Philippics after the model of Demosthenes, and when Antony, Octavian, and Lepidus formed their alliance, his name stood on the list of the proscribed.

A Law No Senate Can Repeal

Cicero’s best-known passage on legal theory is in the third book of De re publica. The work was long lost and was largely rediscovered only in 1819, but this sentence survived because the Christian writer Lactantius quoted it. In the English translation of Lactantius by William Fletcher, Cicero says: “There is indeed a true law, right reason, agreeing with nature, diffused among all, unchanging, everlasting.” Of this law he says: “Nor, truly, can we be released from this law, either by the senate or by the people.” And: “Nor will there be one law at Rome and another at Athens; one law at the present time, and another hereafter: but the same law, everlasting and unchangeable, will bind all nations at all times” (De re publica III 33).

In De legibus, Cicero draws the conclusion. Much of what nations enact to their own ruin deserves the name of law no more than what robbers agree on among themselves, just as one would not call the instructions of an ignorant doctor who prescribes something deadly a medical prescription (De legibus II 13). For him, law is the distinction between right and wrong according to the standard of nature, and every assembly must be measured against that standard. Cicero took the idea from the Greek Stoics but gave it the Latin form in which Church Fathers such as Lactantius, and later the natural law thinkers of the early modern period, read it.

So That Each May Keep His Own

Cicero wrote De officiis in the fall of 44 as a treatise on duties for his son, who was studying in Athens. The second book contains the sentence that makes him so important for the history of the idea of liberty: states and civic communities were founded above all so that each person might keep what is his. Nature, he says, did bring people together, but they sought protection in cities in the hope of safeguarding their possessions (II 73).

From this follows his warning against politicians who try to win popularity by driving owners off their land or canceling debts. They destroy concord, which cannot exist when property is taken from some and given to others, and equity, which vanishes when no one may keep what belongs to him (II 78). A general cancellation of debts, he argues, amounts to this: you buy a piece of land with my money, and then you have the land while I no longer have my money. Nothing holds a state together more firmly than good faith, and there is none unless debts must be repaid (II 84).

As a model he names the Greek Aratus of Sicyon. After fifty years of tyranny, Aratus brought back 600 exiles whose estates had long since passed to others, often acquired through inheritance, purchase, or dowry. Aratus wanted neither to leave the returnees in want nor to expropriate the current owners. He raised money, had the estates appraised, and negotiated compensation until everyone parted in peace (II 81 to 83).

Two things belong to a fair assessment. The agrarian laws Cicero wrote against concerned, to a large extent, public land that wealthy families had farmed for generations, and his concept of property also protects their position. Moreover, for him private property is not given by nature. It arises, he says, from ancient occupation, conquest, law, contract, or lot, and whatever has fallen to someone in this way he should keep (I 21). John Locke would later derive property from labor; Cicero thinks of it in terms of an established order that must not be wantonly overturned.

Harm No One, Keep Your Word

Cicero puts the first duty of justice in a brief formula: no one should harm another unless provoked by a wrong, and everyone should use common things as common and private things as his own (I 20). Anyone familiar with the modern principle of not using force against the innocent will recognize an early relative of it here. But Cicero goes further, for he holds that a person also does wrong who fails to ward off a wrong done to others when he could (I 23). As the foundation of all justice he names fides, faithfulness to one’s given word and to agreements (I 23), and he describes human community as an exchange of services, a giving and receiving (I 22).

The Grain Merchant of Rhodes

How seriously he took honesty is shown by a case from the third book. During a famine, a merchant brings grain to Rhodes and knows that more ships are on the way. May he keep silent and sell at the high price? The Stoic Diogenes of Babylon said yes, his student Antipater demanded openness, and Cicero sides with Antipater: whoever conceals from others what it is in their interest to know, in order to profit from it himself, does not act honestly (III 50 to 57). In the thirteenth century, Thomas Aquinas countered that silence does not violate justice, even if openness would be especially virtuous. Both argue about decency in free exchange, and neither calls for an authority to fix the price.

For economic life as a whole, Cicero held the standards of a landowner. He considered wage labor unworthy of a free man and accused small traders of earning only by lying. Wholesale trade, on the other hand, which brings in goods from everywhere and distributes them without deception, he did not want to censure, and he ranked agriculture highest of all (I 150 to 151). Like almost all his contemporaries, he did not question slavery, even though he freed his secretary Tiro.

A Governor Who Kept to His Edict

How Cicero himself handled power is shown by his letters from Cilicia. Agents of the influential Marcus Brutus demanded from the city of Salamis on Cyprus interest of four percent a month, that is, 48 percent a year. Cicero withdrew the cavalry with which they had harassed the city under his predecessor and held to the maximum rate of one percent a month that he had announced in his edict, even though Brutus stood behind the claim. The Salaminians were prepared to pay at that rate, so to speak out of the money they would otherwise have given the governor, since Cicero had accepted nothing. He did not quite see the matter through, however: at the creditor’s request, he left it unresolved (Letters to Atticus V 21).

What Friends of Liberty Can Learn from Cicero

The most important lesson is the primacy of law over power. A decision does not become just because a senate, a parliament, or a majority makes it. This insight runs from Cicero to John Locke, who advised young people to read De officiis as a basic book of morals before studying the natural rights of man in Pufendorf and Grotius. In 1825, Thomas Jefferson named Cicero alongside Aristotle, Locke, and Algernon Sidney among the authors whose ideas had flowed into the Declaration of Independence, and in 1787 John Adams wrote, in substance, that no age had produced a greater statesman and philosopher united in one person.

Just as lasting is the link between the state and property. Long before the middle classes won their rights, a widely read schoolbook taught that commonwealths are founded to protect what is one’s own, and that debt cancellations destroy the trust on which every order rests.

His life shows how hard it is to stay true to these principles in a crisis. That the very teacher of the true law had citizens killed without a verdict because he saw the state in danger is part of his portrait, and if anything it confirms why even an emergency must remain bound by law. In the end he stood against the stronger side. He could have kept silent when Antony reached for power, and he did not.

What a Majority Cannot Decide

Plutarch relates that years later Augustus came upon one of his grandsons holding a work by Cicero, read in it, and said, in Plutarch’s words: “A learned man, my child, a learned man and a lover of his country.” It was the same man who, when power was divided, had after two days of resistance given Cicero up to Antony after all. Cicero’s sentences outlived the republic, and to this day they put a question to every lawmaker: is his decision a law, or merely an agreement among those who happen to hold the majority?

Further reading

  • Marcus Tullius Cicero: De officiis. Vom pflichtgemäßen Handeln, Latin and German, translated by Heinz Gunermann, Reclam, Stuttgart 1976 (in German)
  • Marcus Tullius Cicero: De re publica. Vom Gemeinwesen, Latin and German, translated by Karl Büchner, Reclam, Stuttgart 1979 (in German)
  • Manfred Fuhrmann: Cicero und die römische Republik, Artemis & Winkler, Munich 1989 (in German); in English as Cicero and the Roman Republic, translated by W. E. Yuill, Blackwell, Oxford 1992

This article is part of our series on thinkers, doers, and historical figures of liberty.

Sources

  • Cicero: De re publica III 33, preserved in Lactantius, Divinae institutiones VI 8; English translation by William Fletcher (Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 7), https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/07016.htm; German: De re publica. Vom Gemeinwesen, translated by Karl Büchner, Reclam, Stuttgart 1979 (in German).
  • Cicero: De legibus II 13 and III 8, Latin: https://www.thelatinlibrary.com/cicero/leg2.shtml and https://www.thelatinlibrary.com/cicero/leg3.shtml
  • Cicero: De officiis I 20–23, I 150–151, II 73, II 78, II 81–84, III 50–57, Latin: https://www.thelatinlibrary.com/cicero/off1.shtml, https://www.thelatinlibrary.com/cicero/off2.shtml, https://www.thelatinlibrary.com/cicero/off3.shtml; German: De officiis. Vom pflichtgemäßen Handeln, translated by Heinz Gunermann, Reclam, Stuttgart 1976 (in German).
  • Cicero: In Catilinam IV 10, Latin: https://www.thelatinlibrary.com/cicero/cat4.shtml
  • Cicero: Epistulae ad Atticum V 21 (the Salamis loan, 50 BC), Latin: https://www.thelatinlibrary.com/cicero/att5.shtml
  • Quintus Tullius Cicero to Marcus, Ad familiares XVI 16 (Tiro’s manumission), Latin: https://www.thelatinlibrary.com/cicero/fam16.shtml
  • Plutarch: Cicero 22, 46–49, translated by Bernadotte Perrin (Loeb 1919), https://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Roman/Texts/Plutarch/Lives/Cicero*.html
  • Sallust: Bellum Catilinae 46, 51–55, translated by J. C. Rolfe (Loeb 1921), https://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Roman/Texts/Sallust/Bellum_Catilinae*.html
  • Thomas Aquinas: Summa theologiae II-II q. 77 a. 3 ad 4, https://www.newadvent.org/summa/3077.htm
  • John Locke: Some Thoughts Concerning Education (1693), §§ 185–186, https://standardebooks.org/ebooks/john-locke/some-thoughts-concerning-education/text/single-page
  • Thomas Jefferson to Henry Lee, May 8, 1825, Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/98-01-02-5212
  • John Adams: A Defence of the Constitutions of Government of the United States of America, vol. 1, London 1787, preface (wording from a secondary quotation).
  • Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Cicero, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/cicero/
  • Wikipedia (en): Political career of Cicero, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_career_of_Cicero (starting point, dates cross-checked)
  • Wikipedia (en): Lex Sempronia agraria, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lex_Sempronia_agraria (context on public land)
  • History of Information: Petrarch discovers Cicero’s letters to Atticus, https://www.historyofinformation.com/detail.php?entryid=4731
  • Heritage Foundation: Cicero: A Republic, If You Can Keep It (Adams quotation), https://www.heritage.org/conservatism/commentary/cicero-republic-if-you-can-keep-it
  • Quote Investigator: The Budget Should Be Balanced (a fabrication from Taylor Caldwell, A Pillar of Iron, 1965), https://quoteinvestigator.com/2013/05/15/cicero-budget/
  • The Cicero Homepage, University of Texas: Myths, https://sites.la.utexas.edu/cicero/myths
  • Snopes: Cicero budget quote, https://www.snopes.com/quotes/cicero.asp
  • PolitiFact, May 3, 2019: “A nation can survive its fools”, https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2019/may/03/facebook-posts/no-roman-statesman-did-not-give-warning-about-trum/
  • Manfred Fuhrmann: Cicero und die römische Republik, Artemis & Winkler, Munich 1989 (in German; recommended reading)

Featured image: Marcus Tullius Cicero (AI illustration)

Leave a Comment

Popular:

Tip: press / or Ctrl+K to open search from any page.