Skip to content Skip to footer

Michelangelo: A Giant for the Republic

Michelangelo Buonarroti

On the evening of May 14, 1504, the wall above the gate of the cathedral workshop in Florence was broken open so that a marble giant could pass through. Hauled on rollers by more than forty men, it took four days to reach the Piazza della Signoria. On the first night, as a contemporary account recorded, unknown persons threw stones at it, and it had to be guarded. By June 8 it had been lifted onto the pedestal in front of the government palace, in the spot where Donatello’s Judith had stood until then.

No one knows who threw the stones, but the fact that a statue had enemies says something about where it stood. The David of the 29-year-old Michelangelo Buonarroti now stood in front of the seat of a republic that had driven out the Medici ten years earlier. Its creator never wrote a political theory, and anyone who turns his figures into slogans makes them smaller. His life, however, says a great deal about how a man keeps his dignity among a republic, princes, and popes.

At a glance

  • Life: March 6, 1475, in Caprese to February 18, 1564, in Rome, buried in Santa Croce in Florence
  • Work: sculptor, painter, architect, and poet in Florence and Rome; in 1529 head of the fortifications of the Florentine Republic; from 1547 architect of St. Peter’s
  • Major works: Pietà (before 1500), David (1501–1504), ceiling of the Sistine Chapel (1509–1512), New Sacristy in San Lorenzo, Brutus (around 1539/40), dome of St. Peter’s, poems
  • In one sentence: He worked for the most powerful men of his time and yet kept, in dealing with them, the pride of a free Florentine.

A pupil of the Medici

Michelangelo was born in Caprese, the son of Lodovico Buonarroti, and grew up in Florence. As a youth he trained at the school for sculptors that Lorenzo de’ Medici had set up in the garden of San Marco. The family he would oppose in 1529 thus stood at the beginning of his career.

In the fall of 1494, shortly before the Medici were chased out of the city, he left for Venice and Bologna. What then made him famous was the Pietà in Rome.

The Giant before the Palazzo

Contrary to what one often reads, the David was not commissioned by the government. On August 16, 1501, the consuls of the wool guild and the overseers of the cathedral workshop signed a contract with Michelangelo for the figure that Florentines simply called “the Giant.” The block lay in the cathedral workshop, badly roughed out by the sculptor Agostino di Duccio, and the figure was meant for the cathedral.

When it was finished, an assembly of artists and craftsmen, among them Leonardo da Vinci and Sandro Botticelli, met in January 1504 to decide where it should stand. They chose the entrance of the Palazzo della Signoria, and with it the place of a statue with a history of its own: Donatello’s Judith, slaying the tyrant Holofernes, had been set up there in 1495 to commemorate the expulsion of Piero de’ Medici.

From this location comes the interpretation that has accompanied the David to this day. A shepherd boy who defeats the overpowering Goliath suited a small republic that had to hold its own against princes and foreign armies. No written program by Michelangelo on this exists, but whoever placed the Giant in front of the town hall supplied the interpretation along with the location. Since 1873 it has stood in the Galleria dell’Accademia, with a copy in front of the palace.

Giorgio Vasari tells an anecdote about it that should be taken as an anecdote: Piero Soderini, the head of the republic, supposedly found the nose too large, whereupon Michelangelo pretended to chisel and let marble dust trickle down. Soderini was satisfied, and the nose stayed as it was.

A groom at the pope’s door

How little he cowered before the powerful became clear in Rome in 1506. Pope Julius II had entrusted him with his tomb in 1505, and Michelangelo had paid the freight for the marble with borrowed money because the pope did not pay. When he asked for money at the Vatican in the spring, the pope had a groom turn him away. According to his own account looking back in 1542, Michelangelo then wrote to the pope that from that time forward, “if you want me, you must look for me elsewhere than at Rome.” Then he had his household goods sold and rode to Florence.

Five of the pope’s horsemen caught up with him at Poggibonsi, but Michelangelo sent word that he would return as soon as the pope met his obligations. Only when Julius sent three briefs to the Signoria did the Florentines tell him, as he recalled it, “We do not want to go to war with Pope Julius because of you.” In November 1506 he made peace with Julius in Bologna; he then painted the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel from 1509 to 1512.

He kept this self-assurance all his life. In 1548 he wrote to his nephew Lionardo that he had never been “either sculptor or painter in the way of one who keeps a shop”; he had served three popes, but “that was a matter of necessity.” In this lies the pride of a citizen who felt he belonged to no court, and at the same time the honest admission that he could not have worked without the popes.

Bastions for the last republic

In 1527 the Florentines drove out the Medici a second time. Pope Clement VII, himself a Medici, allied himself with Emperor Charles V in 1529, and in the fall an imperial army lay before the city. Michelangelo, who had worked for Clement for years, took the side of the republic. Early in 1529 he was elected to the Nove della Milizia, the nine-member committee for the militia, and on April 6, 1529, he was appointed governor general and procurator of the fortifications.

Above all, he fortified the hill of San Miniato. His drawings for bastions and gates are now kept in the Casa Buonarroti. Condivi reports that Michelangelo had the bombarded bell tower of San Miniato hung at night with wool-filled mattresses that swung freely in front of the wall and caught the cannonballs. He also lent money to the besieged government.

This commitment was not heroic without a break. On September 21, 1529, Michelangelo fled to Venice because he suspected the mercenary commander Malatesta Baglioni of treason. The government stripped him of his office and pay but urged him to return, and by November he was back. His mistrust was not unfounded: Baglioni made secret contacts with the pope and the imperial commander, and on August 12, 1530, Florence capitulated.

Night, who does not want to be woken

After the fall of the city, Michelangelo had to fear for his life and went into hiding, according to Condivi and the historian Benedetto Varchi in the house of a friend. Others place the hiding place in a chamber with charcoal drawings beneath the New Sacristy, discovered in 1975, which is disputed. Clement VII finally sent word that Michelangelo would be left alone if he continued working on the Medici tombs. He did, according to Condivi in substance, more out of fear of the pope than out of love for the Medici. To win the favor of Baccio Valori, the pope’s governor in Florence, he even began a marble figure for him, according to Vasari.

So after 1530 the republic’s builder of fortifications worked again for the family against which he had built the walls. But when Duke Alessandro de’ Medici asked him to choose the site for a new fortress to dominate the city, Michelangelo refused on the grounds that he had no commission from the pope to do so. Condivi believed that without the pope’s protection the duke would have had him killed. In September 1534 Michelangelo moved to Rome for good.

From the sacristy comes the sleeping figure of Night. The poet Giovanni Strozzi praised it, saying one need only wake it and it would speak. Michelangelo had the statue reply in four lines of verse:

“Caro m’è ’l sonno, e più l’esser di sasso, / mentre che ’l danno e la vergogna dura; / non veder, non sentir m’è gran ventura; / però non mi destar, deh, parla basso.” (Rime, no. 247, Girardi edition)

Translation by the editors: Dear to me is sleep, and dearer still to be of stone, as long as harm and shame endure; to see nothing, to hear nothing is great good fortune to me; so do not wake me, ah, speak softly. The poem does not say which harm is meant; the common interpretation relates it to Florence under the Medici.

A head for Brutus

In Rome, Michelangelo found friends among the Florentine exiles. One of them, the republican Donato Giannotti, asked him for a bust of Brutus for Cardinal Niccolò Ridolfi. Both saw in Lorenzino de’ Medici, who had murdered his cousin Alessandro in 1537, a “new Brutus.” The bust was probably made around 1539/40, remained unfinished, and is now in the Bargello in Florence.

Whether Michelangelo meant it to celebrate tyrannicide cannot be proven, because he never commented on it. In a dialogue by Giannotti about Dante, however, the character Michelangelo explains why the poet put Brutus and Cassius in the deepest part of hell: for their attack on the majesty of the empire in the person of Caesar, rather than as tyrant slayers. This is a literary conversation, but it shows what occupied Michelangelo’s circle of friends in Rome.

Cosimo I, the new duke, tried several times through Cellini and Vasari to win his return. Michelangelo asked for a delay because St. Peter’s kept him in Rome, and he came back to Florence only in death, in March 1564, when he was buried in Santa Croce.

For St. Peter’s without pay

On January 1, 1547, Pope Paul III appointed the man, by then over seventy, architect of St. Peter’s for life, with full authority to change the model and the building. Michelangelo declined a salary. He wished to work without pay for the love of God and out of reverence for the Prince of the Apostles, he declared, and he kept to this until his death.

He could afford it because he had managed his money well. From bank accounts and purchase contracts, the art historian Rab Hatfield has shown that Michelangelo was a very wealthy man who invested his money mainly in land and yet liked to complain about poverty. Behind his unbending attitude, then, there was also an economic independence he had earned for himself.

What the stone tells

What Michelangelo left behind is more an attitude than a doctrine. He derived his standing from his own work and let even a pope feel it. He took the republic that governed itself without princes seriously enough to build walls for it, lend it money, and risk his life. When it was lost, he kept working because he had to, but he refused where the new ruler demanded help against his own city.

This republic had little in common with today’s civil liberties, and Michelangelo remained dependent on the Medici and the popes all his life. All the more remarkable is how he insisted on his self-respect, toward Julius II as toward Alessandro, without which no liberty lasts for long.

The David has often been read as a symbol of citizens who take on a superior power. Whether Michelangelo meant it that way, no one knows. What he carved is a young man, the sling over his left shoulder, who in the common reading still has the fight ahead of him. That the Florentines placed him in front of their town hall in 1504 instead of at the cathedral was their interpretation, and it has remained the strongest to this day.

Further reading

  • Ascanio Condivi: Vita di Michelagnolo Buonarroti, Rome 1553
  • Michelangelo: Rime, ed. Enzo Noè Girardi, Laterza, Bari 1960
  • William E. Wallace: Michelangelo. The Artist, the Man, and His Times, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2010

This article is part of our series on thinkers, doers, and historical figures of liberty.

Sources

  • Michelangelo Buonarroti: Rime, ed. Enzo Noè Girardi, Laterza, Bari 1960, no. 247 (“Caro m’è ’l sonno, e più l’esser di sasso”), p. 117; online: https://it.wikisource.org/wiki/Rime_(Michelangelo)/247._Caro_m%27%C3%A8_%27l_sonno,_e_pi%C3%B9_l%27esser_di_sasso
  • Michelangelo Buonarroti: letters, including to Giovanni Francesco Fattucci (January 1524), to a prelate (October 1542), and to his nephew Lionardo (1548), quoted from the English translation in Symonds 1893
  • Ascanio Condivi: Vita di Michelagnolo Buonarroti, Rome 1553
  • Giorgio Vasari: Le vite de’ più eccellenti pittori, scultori e architettori, 2nd edition, Florence 1568, Life of Michelangelo; German edition: Das Leben des Michelangelo, Wagenbach, Berlin 2009 (in German)
  • Luca Landucci: Diario fiorentino (entry on the transport of the David, May/June 1504), after Symonds 1893
  • Donato Giannotti: Dialogi de’ giorni che Dante consumò nel cercare l’Inferno e ’l Purgatorio (around 1546)
  • Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani, vol. 15 (1972), entry “BUONARROTI, Michelangelo,” Treccani: https://www.treccani.it/enciclopedia/michelangelo-buonarroti_(Dizionario-Biografico)/
  • John Addington Symonds: The Life of Michelangelo Buonarroti, London 1893, Project Gutenberg no. 11242: https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/11242
  • William E. Wallace: Michelangelo. The Artist, the Man, and His Times, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2010
  • Rab Hatfield: The Wealth of Michelangelo, Edizioni di Storia e Letteratura, Rome 2002: https://ebooks.mpdl.mpg.de/ebooks/Record/EB000914620/Description
  • Charles de Tolnay: “Michelangelo’s Bust of Brutus,” The Burlington Magazine 67 (1935); Thomas Martin: “Michelangelo’s ‘Brutus’ and the Classicizing Portrait Bust in Sixteenth-Century Italy,” Artibus et Historiae 14 (1993), both via https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brutus_(Michelangelo)
  • Wikipedia: David (Michelangelo), https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_(Michelangelo); Judith and Holofernes (Donatello), https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judith_and_Holofernes_(Donatello) (only as a starting point)
  • Smithsonian Magazine, November 2023, on the chamber beneath the New Sacristy: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/the-secret-room-where-michelangelo-sketched-while-hiding-from-a-death-sentence-opens-to-the-public-180983175/
  • Casa Buonarroti, fortification drawings (Porta al Prato d’Ognissanti), Google Arts & Culture: https://artsandculture.google.com/asset/14a-study-of-a-fortification-for-the-porta-al-prato-of-ognissanti-michelangelo-buonarroti/XQGHuxRHJijRUQ
  • Quote Investigator: “You Just Chip Away Everything That Doesn’t Look Like David,” June 22, 2014: https://quoteinvestigator.com/2014/06/22/chip-away/

Featured image: Michelangelo Buonarroti (AI illustration)

Leave a Comment

Popular:

Tip: press / or Ctrl+K to open search from any page.