On April 10, 1968, a hearing on the planned Lower Manhattan Expressway took place in the auditorium of Seward Park High School in Manhattan. The expressway was to cut straight across the southern tip of the island, through SoHo, Little Italy, and Chinatown. When protesters stormed the stage and the stenographic record of the meeting was destroyed, a plainclothes police officer arrested a 51-year-old woman.
She was charged with inciting a riot, criminal mischief, and obstructing public administration; after months of proceedings, all that remained was a charge of disorderly conduct. The woman was Jane Jacobs, and at that point she was the best-known critic of American city planning. The expressway was never built. Anyone walking through SoHo today moves through a neighborhood that the route would have cut apart, and through exactly the kind of street life to which she devoted her most important book.
At a glance
- Life: May 4, 1916, in Scranton, Pennsylvania, to April 25, 2006, in Toronto
- Work: Journalist, editor at Architectural Forum (1952 to 1962), author and civic activist in New York and Toronto, Canadian citizen from 1974
- Major works: The Death and Life of Great American Cities (1961), The Economy of Cities (1969), Cities and the Wealth of Nations (1984), Systems of Survival (1992)
- In one sentence: Using the street outside her front door, she showed that the liveliest order in a city is the one nobody designed.
A Reporter from Scranton
Jane Butzner grew up in the coal town of Scranton, the daughter of a physician and a former teacher and nurse. In the mid-1930s, in the middle of the Great Depression, she moved to New York with her sister Betty, first to Brooklyn and soon after to Greenwich Village. For two years she took courses at Columbia University’s School of General Studies, from geology to economics, never earned a degree, and later worked for Amerika, a Russian-language magazine of the State Department. In 1944 she married the architect Robert Hyde Jacobs. The couple had three children and lived in a house on Hudson Street, and its everyday life became the material of her best-known book.
From 1952 on, as an editor at Architectural Forum, she wrote about the large urban renewal projects of the postwar years. In 1958 she published the essay “Downtown Is for People” in Fortune, and the same year she received a grant from the Rockefeller Foundation. About three years later, The Death and Life of Great American Cities was finished. Its first sentence left no doubt about its purpose: “This book is an attack on current city planning and rebuilding.”
What the Street Knows
Jacobs first asked what actually happens in neighborhoods that work, and only then what a city ought to look like. Her answer begins with the sidewalk. A street is safe when there are “eyes upon the street,” the eyes of shopkeepers, residents, and passersby who casually keep watch over what goes on. Beneath the seeming disorder of the old city, she wrote, lies a remarkable order, and Hudson Street was the stage every day for an intricate “sidewalk ballet.”
Out of many small encounters, trust grows. Jacobs lists them affectionately in her third chapter, from a beer at the bar to advice from the grocer to a chat at the newsstand. No one plans this web; it arises as a by-product of people going about their own business.
Four Conditions for Lively Neighborhoods
What does a district need for such life to arise? Jacobs named four conditions, which she called “generators of diversity.” A neighborhood must have more than one primary use, so that people are there at different times and for different reasons. Blocks must be short, with many corners and routes. Old and new buildings must be mixed, because only old buildings offer the low rents that a young business, a workshop, or a small restaurant can afford. And there must be a sufficient density of people. Only all four together, she stressed, produce urban diversity.
The guiding ideals of the planners of the day ran almost exactly counter to these conditions: towers set in green space, neatly separated zones for living, working, and shopping, wide corridors for car traffic. Jacobs answered them with a sentence that Sanford Ikeda made the title of his major study of her in 2024: “A city cannot be a work of art.” Anyone who wants to arrange a neighborhood the way an architect arranges a model, she argued, puts art in the place of life. In her final chapter, borrowing a term from the mathematician Warren Weaver, she called the city a problem of “organized complexity,” which can be handled only by thinking in processes and starting from the particular case.
Against the Master Builder of New York
Her great adversary was Robert Moses, who for decades built bridges, parks, expressways, and housing projects in New York. His power rested on appointed offices; the only election he ever entered, the 1934 race for governor, he lost. In the 1950s he revived an old plan to extend Fifth Avenue through Washington Square Park. The residents formed a committee with the delightful name “Joint Emergency Committee to Close Washington Square Park to All but Emergency Traffic,” and in 1958 the city closed the park to through traffic.
In 1961 the City Planning Commission designated the western part of Greenwich Village an urban renewal area, which in the language of the time meant demolition. Jacobs organized the Committee to Save the West Village, which proposed renovating the existing buildings instead, and she prevailed. Against the Lower Manhattan Expressway she led a coalition of neighborhood groups until, after the 1968 hearing, the plans disappeared from the city’s agenda.
That same year the family moved to Toronto, partly because both sons were of draft age and Jacobs opposed the Vietnam War. There, of all places, their rented house stood on the route of yet another planned urban expressway. Jacobs helped organize the opposition to the Spadina Expressway, and on June 3, 1971, the government of the province of Ontario withdrew its support for the project.
Prosperity from the City
In The Economy of Cities and Cities and the Wealth of Nations, Jacobs turned her gaze from the sidewalk to the economy. She saw cities, not nation-states, as the real engines of prosperity. A city grows when it learns to produce for itself goods it previously imported, and Jacobs called this “import replacement.” She explicitly did not mean sealing off the economy with tariffs and subsidies. The replacement is carried out by entrepreneurs who imitate and improve, and a city that has replaced imports goes on to buy other things, but by no means less.
Her boldest thesis was that cities are older than agriculture. To illustrate it she invented the settlement of New Obsidian, an early trading place for volcanic glass, in which exchange among hunter-gatherers is what first gives rise to farming. Most archaeologists have not accepted this sequence, but some consider her core idea correct: that urban exchange furthered the development of agriculture.
Traders and Guardians
In Systems of Survival (1992), a book written as a dialogue, she distinguished two moral systems. The commercial one includes precepts such as “Shun force,” “Come to voluntary agreements,” “Respect contracts,” and “Be honest.” The guardian system, to which she assigned government, the military, and the police, demands instead obedience, loyalty, respect for hierarchy, and the renunciation of trading. She considered both necessary. Danger arises, she held, when they mix, that is, when guardians do business or traders use force, and for such mixtures she coined the term “monstrous moral hybrids.” For friends of liberty, what stands out is how clearly she described the market as a sphere of voluntary agreement and the state as a sphere of command and obedience.
An Ally of Her Own Kind
Jacobs never called herself a libertarian. In a 1985 interview she spoke in favor of help for the poor, good education for everyone, and publicly funded health care, and she wanted to treat political questions pragmatically, according to what proves itself in practice. In The Death and Life of Great American Cities she proposed replacing public housing with rent guarantees and subsidies. Even then, however, thousands of private builders and owners were to do the building, house by house among the existing buildings, instead of, as she wrote, a handful of agencies and large developers deciding the fate of cities.
All the more striking is her closeness to Friedrich August von Hayek. The economists Gene Callahan and Sanford Ikeda have shown how closely her ideas on spontaneous order, local knowledge, and the false imitation of the natural sciences resemble Hayek’s, even though she did not know his writings when she wrote her first book. In 1945, in “The Use of Knowledge in Society,” Hayek had explained why a society’s knowledge is dispersed among countless minds and cannot be gathered by any central authority. Jacobs found the same thing on the sidewalk.
In a 2001 interview with the magazine Reason, she criticized the use of eminent domain on behalf of private development projects, the fear of any change to zoning plans, and the monopoly of municipal transit systems. Two years later, Reason included her in its list of 35 heroes of freedom.
What friends of liberty can learn from her
The most important lesson concerns knowledge. A living order rests on knowledge that is dispersed among shopkeepers, tenants, craftsmen, and passersby and that no planner can bring together. Anyone who wants to improve a city, a market, or a society would therefore do well to look closely first at what already works there, instead of replacing it with a blueprint.
Just as instructive is her eye for the small players in the economy. Her case for old buildings was at heart a case for cheap space where new businesses can start with little capital, and her theory of import replacement is about entrepreneurs who imitate and improve.
And finally, her life shows what citizens can accomplish. A woman without office and without a degree, together with her neighbors, stopped plans backed by agencies, laws, and a great deal of money. Her tools were careful observation and patient conversation with her neighbors, and she always trusted her readers to see for themselves.
Created by Everybody
At the end of a chapter on the myths of diversity, Jacobs’s major work contains a sentence that sums up her thinking: “Cities have the capability of providing something for everybody, only because, and only when, they are created by everybody” (chapter 12). This holds for every city today as well, where building codes, zoning maps, and permit procedures decide who may live, work, and start something new, and where. Anyone who takes Jacobs seriously will ask of every new plan how much room it leaves the people who live there, and whether it allows them to go on creating the city themselves.
Further reading
- Jane Jacobs: Tod und Leben großer amerikanischer Städte, Bauwelt Fundamente 4, Birkhäuser, Basel 2015 (in German); English original: The Death and Life of Great American Cities, Random House, New York 1961
- Jane Jacobs: Cities and the Wealth of Nations. Principles of Economic Life, Random House, New York 1984
- Sanford Ikeda: A City Cannot Be a Work of Art. Learning Economics and Social Theory From Jane Jacobs, Palgrave Macmillan, Singapore 2024
- Robert Kanigel: Eyes on the Street. The Life of Jane Jacobs, Knopf, New York 2016
This article is part of our series on thinkers, doers, and historical figures of liberty.
Sources
- Jacobs, Jane: The Death and Life of Great American Cities, Random House, New York 1961; cited from the Vintage edition, New York 1992 (chapters 1, 2, 3, 7, 12, 17, 18, 19, 22). German edition: Tod und Leben großer amerikanischer Städte, Bauwelt Fundamente 4 (first German edition 1963), new edition Birkhäuser, Basel 2015 (in German).
- Jacobs, Jane: “Downtown Is for People,” in: Fortune, 1958.
- Jacobs, Jane: The Economy of Cities, Random House, New York 1969.
- Jacobs, Jane: Cities and the Wealth of Nations. Principles of Economic Life, Random House, New York 1984.
- Jacobs, Jane: Systems of Survival. A Dialogue on the Moral Foundations of Commerce and Politics, Random House, New York 1992.
- Steigerwald, Bill: “City Views” (interview with Jane Jacobs), in: Reason, June 2001, https://reason.com/?p=28053
- Hayek, Friedrich August von: “The Use of Knowledge in Society,” in: American Economic Review 35 (1945), no. 4.
- Ikeda, Sanford: A City Cannot Be a Work of Art. Learning Economics and Social Theory From Jane Jacobs, Palgrave Macmillan, Singapore 2024, https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-981-99-5362-2
- Kanigel, Robert: Eyes on the Street. The Life of Jane Jacobs, Knopf, New York 2016; see also the interview “The Life That Shaped Jane Jacobs,” Bloomberg CityLab, September 20, 2016, https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-09-20/the-life-that-shaped-jane-jacobs
- Riggenbach, Jeff: “Jane Jacobs, Libertarian Outsider,” Mises Daily, April 28, 2011, https://mises.org/mises-daily/jane-jacobs-libertarian-outsider (summarizes Callahan/Ikeda and the 1985 interview)
- Boston College, John J. Burns Library: exhibition “Jane Jacobs: Activist,” https://library.bc.edu/burns-exhibits/jane-jacobs/activist/
- Reason: “Jane Jacobs, RIP,” April 25, 2006, https://reason.com/2006/04/25/jane-jacobs-rip
- The Canadian Encyclopedia: “Toronto Feature: Spadina Expressway,” https://thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/toronto-feature-spadina-expressway
- Planetizen: “Jane Jacobs, ‘Cities First,’ and the Virtues of Being Wrong,” https://www.planetizen.com/node/88912
- Market Urbanism: “Book Review: Cities and the Wealth of Nations,” April 24, 2017, https://marketurbanism.com/2017/04/24/market-urbanist-book-review-cities-and-the-wealth-of-nations-by-jane-jacobs
- Caro, Robert A.: The Power Broker. Robert Moses and the Fall of New York, Knopf, New York 1974.
- Wikipedia (en): Jane Jacobs, Systems of Survival, Robert Moses, Import replacement (starting point; dates checked against the other sources)
Featured image: Jane Jacobs (AI illustration)

