Skip to content Skip to footer
Cover: An Essay on the Trial by Jury

Books · Getting started

An Essay on the Trial by Jury

by Lysander Spooner

Lysander Spooner shows why the jury must judge not only the facts but the law itself, and what that means for the liberty of every individual.

Level
Advanced
Published
1852
Publisher
Independently Published
ISBN
1729020410

What it is about

Lysander Spooner (1808–1887) is one of the most original thinkers in American history: a legal philosopher, an uncompromising abolitionist, and an opponent of government monopolies. His essay on the jury, first published in the nineteenth century, takes up a question that has lost none of its explosive force: Who has the final say on whether a law is just?

Spooner’s answer is unequivocal. He argues that since Magna Carta in 1215, jurors have been entitled to decide not only whether a defendant committed an act, but also whether the underlying law is just at all. For Spooner, this so-called jury nullification, the right of jurors to refuse to apply a law in a particular case, is not a marginal curiosity of legal history but the very core of the protection against arbitrary government.

The book develops this idea with legal care and historical depth. Spooner examines the English and American constitutional traditions, cites historical sources, and shows how the jury principle was originally meant as a barrier against laws that harm a minority or the individual. Anyone who simply accepts laws as given, Spooner argues, surrenders an essential part of their liberty.

The essay is for anyone interested in legal philosophy, constitutional history, and the foundations of individual liberty. Some background in law helps but is not required: Spooner’s language is clear, and his argument is easy to follow.

Did you enjoy the book? The author and publisher will appreciate a short review, for example with the retailer you bought it from.

Popular:

Tip: press / or Ctrl+K to open search from any page.