Das Experiment
A gripping, brutal thriller that reads well as a warning against power without accountability, even if it exaggerates its already contested model.
- Year
- 2001
- Country
- Germany
- Genre
- Psychological thriller
- Running time
- 120 min
- Rating
- 16 (German FSK rating)
- Message of liberty
- Between the lines
Ratings: IMDb 7.7/10 · Rotten Tomatoes 74% · Metacritic 59 · as of 11/2026
Where to watch: In Germany: not currently streaming, DVD rental from Videobuster · as of 11/2026
What it is about
Cab driver Tarek Fahd (Moritz Bleibtreu), a former journalist, answers a newspaper ad: 4,000 marks for two weeks in a mock prison at a university. A hidden camera is built into his glasses, because he wants to turn the experiment into an exposé. Twenty men are assigned by lot to be guards or prisoners, and the team led by Professor Thon (Edgar Selge) and Dr. Grimm (Andrea Sawatzki) watches everything on camera. The prisoners give up their names and some basic rights and wear numbers; the guards are supposed to keep order but may not use violence.
Tarek provokes from the start, partly because a quiet week won’t give him a story he can sell. On the other side, the quiet Berus (Justus von Dohnányi) gains the upper hand, convinced that control is won back through humiliation. What begins as paid role-play tips over within a few days, and while the professor is away at a conference, those left in charge argue over whether they have to call it off.
Oliver Hirschbiegel’s first theatrical feature is based on the novel Black Box by Mario Giordano, who co-wrote the screenplay, and draws on the 1971 Stanford prison experiment.
What the film says about liberty
The state does not appear in the film. The participants voluntarily sign a contract with a university, and Hirschbiegel sees his work as a statement about human nature and about prisons in general, and explicitly not as a parable about fascism. So when we read the film here as a lesson in how power corrupts, that is our reading and not the filmmakers’. It is an obvious one, though, because the film shows how people who suddenly have power over others and answer to no one first bend the rules and then break them. The agreed limit holds exactly as long as someone is watching; when the professor cannot be reached, it falls. What holds in the lab holds all the more for the state with its monopoly on force.
The methods are familiar from every dictatorship: numbers instead of names, uniforms, shaved heads, and pointless duties meant to break the individual. What stands out is who becomes the leader. In everyday life Berus is an inconspicuous man without influence, and Hirschbiegel sums up the dynamic in the idea that power breeds more power. Lord Acton’s dictum that power tends to corrupt gets, in a sense, its experimental setup here.
The other side matters just as much. Tarek refuses to submit, if at first out of self-interest; the guard Bosch helps a prisoner and is locked up for it by his own colleagues; Dr. Grimm wants to stop the experiment and is outvoted. The film thus shows that individuals can make choices and are not simply their roles, and Hirschbiegel himself stresses that you always remain responsible for your actions as an individual. Incidentally, the events are no argument against freedom of contract: the contract prohibited violence, and it is broken at the point where one side gains de facto rule without oversight.
Where the film falls short
The real-life model now stands on shaky ground. Drawing on archival material, the French researcher Thibault Le Texier has argued that Zimbardo coached the guards at Stanford to behave in particular ways in order to confirm conclusions that were largely fixed in advance; Zimbardo rejected this. The claim that anyone placed in the role of guard will inevitably become a perpetrator is therefore unproven, which if anything strengthens the pro-liberty reading, because cruelty arose where an authority directed or condoned it and individuals handed their responsibility over to that authority.
Spoiler alert (the ending is not revealed): The film goes well beyond its model. At Stanford the experiment was called off after six of fourteen days, and no one died; Hirschbiegel escalates things to torture in an isolation box, two deaths, and a bloody finale of hand-to-hand fighting. The Lexikon des internationalen Films, Germany’s standard film reference, faults it for ending up wallowing in the very voyeuristically staged violence the film at first claims to question. A second objection fits with this: the story narrows to a good victim against an evil tormentor, which weakens the thesis that the situation changes everyone. Anyone who wants to understand how an inconspicuous man turns into a tormentor gets a villain rather than an explanation.
Critics and audiences are far apart: Rotten Tomatoes at 74% and Metacritic at 59 stand against 88% from audiences and 7.7 on IMDb. The gap probably has more to do with genre than with politics, since the film works superbly as a thriller and less well as an experiment about human beings.
Who should watch it
Das Experiment is rated 16 in Germany, and rightly so: humiliation, abuse, and an attempted rape make it a tough evening. Bleibtreu, Dohnányi, and Sawatzki carry the film, and as a psychological thriller it keeps the tension high to the very end. Anyone interested in why people abuse power as soon as no one is checking anymore will find plenty to talk about here, especially if you go on to discuss the doubts about the Stanford experiment as well. For a cozy Sunday night, it is the wrong choice.
Sources
- Das Experiment (Film), Wikipedia (in German), https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Das_Experiment_(Film)
- Das Experiment, Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Das_Experiment
- Das Experiment, filmportal.de (in German), https://www.filmportal.de/film/das-experiment_e389f8a8b73d494c9717b72e117dbd80
- Das Experiment, Lexikon des internationalen Films (filmdienst.de, in German), https://www.filmdienst.de/film/details/514409/das-experiment
- Das Experiment, review by the FILMSTARTS editorial team (Carsten Baumgardt, in German), https://www.filmstarts.de/kritiken/27244/kritik.html
- The Experiment (2001), Rotten Tomatoes, https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/1116582-experiment
- The Experiment Reviews, Metacritic, https://www.metacritic.com/movie/the-experiment/
- Das Experiment – Stream, JustWatch Germany (in German), https://www.justwatch.com/de/Film/Das-Experiment
- Das Interviews (Carlo Cavagna with Oliver Hirschbiegel and Moritz Bleibtreu), AboutFilm, https://aboutfilm.com/features/dasexperiment/interview.htm
- Stanford prison experiment, Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanford_prison_experiment
- Debunking the Stanford Prison Experiment (Le Texier, American Psychologist 74 (7), 2019), Crossref metadata, https://api.crossref.org/works/10.1037/amp0000401
- DAS EXPERIMENT | Offizieller deutscher Trailer (official German trailer), Wild Bunch Germany (YouTube), https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YPRum7kHcMo
