Skip to content Skip to footer
2002 Minority Report Director: Steven Spielberg

Films · Self-determination

Minority Report

Director: Steven Spielberg

A brilliantly constructed thriller showing that a society without crime is far from a free one once the state punishes people for acts they never committed.

Year
2002
Country
United States
Genre
Science fiction thriller
Running time
145 min
Rating
12 (German FSK rating)
Message of liberty
Explicit

Ratings: IMDb 7.6/10 · Rotten Tomatoes 89% · Metacritic 80 · as of 11/2026

Where to watch: In Germany: included with a Paramount+ subscription, rent from €2.99, available on DVD, Blu-ray, and 4K · as of 11/2026

What it is about

Washington in the year 2054: the Precrime police division stops murders before they happen. Three clairvoyant people, the precogs, lie in a pool and foresee future crimes, and the police arrest the perpetrators before they act. There has not been a murder in the city for years. Chief John Anderton (Tom Cruise) believes in the system, partly for personal reasons: years ago his son vanished without a trace.

Just as an investigator from the Justice Department is reviewing Precrime before it is to be expanded to the whole country, the precogs predict that Anderton himself will soon kill a man he does not even know. He flees from his own colleagues through a city where retinal scanners identify every person at every turn, and searches for proof that the predictions are not infallible: a dissenting “minority report.”

The film is based on Philip K. Dick’s 1956 short story The Minority Report. It keeps the story’s basic idea but tells a largely different plot; the screenplay is by Scott Frank and Jon Cohen.

What the film says about liberty

At its center is a question every state under the rule of law has to answer: can someone be guilty before they have acted? Precrime says yes. Those arrested get no trial and no defense; they are put into a coma and locked away indefinitely for a crime that never took place. The film thus takes apart the presumption of innocence and ties it to the question of free will, because anyone punished before they could decide never got the chance to decide otherwise.

What is remarkable is that Precrime works. There are no more murders, and that is exactly why the film shows so convincingly that a society without crime is not automatically a free one. In 2002 the parallel was obvious: German critics saw a kinship between the war on terror and the war on crime, Thomas Assheuer spoke of a “Präventivdiktatur,” a preventive dictatorship, and the magazine Spiked drew the line to the prevention plans of then US Attorney General John Ashcroft. Bastiat would probably have objected that this state abolishes the very law it is supposed to protect.

Then there is total surveillance. Retinal scanners stand in the subway, in stores, and in the streets, and in one of the strongest scenes small search robots comb an entire apartment building and shine a light into every resident’s eye, whether that person is wanted or just sitting in the bathtub. Spielberg explicitly meant the film as a warning. In 2002 he said the scary thing was that “we’ll lose our right to privacy,” and that “Orwell’s prophecy really comes true, not in the twentieth century but in the twenty-first.”

The precogs belong in this picture too. They are human beings who lie permanently in a pool for the safety of others, and the state has turned them into a tool. Anderton, finally, is not a rebel from outside but a believer in the system who only understands what it does once he is its target, and that makes the film especially accessible as a lesson about state power.

Where the film falls short

The surveillance in the film is not only the state’s. In the shopping mall, billboards recognize Anderton by retinal scan and address him by name, and Spielberg described this advertising, too, as part of his warning: “An ad will appear in the air around us, talking directly to us.” The critic Susan Vahabzadeh considered these billboards the coldest and most anti-capitalist detail of the film. Spiked countered that the real danger lies in the state’s access to the data, and that reading, in which the same scanner that recommends sneakers also serves the manhunt, is ours here. That this film of all films held the record for product placement for ten years lends its critique of consumerism a certain comedy.

The second objection concerns the craft. The big philosophical questions at times recede behind chases, fistfights, and shootouts, which filmstarts.de, a German film site, criticizes despite a high rating; Spiegel Online, the website of the German newsweekly Der Spiegel, even found the film pompous, lifeless, and too long. At 145 minutes it does take its time. Violence is never celebrated as a political solution, and the film does not offer rescue by a strongman either; its question is rather whether the rule of law can correct itself.

Who should watch it

Minority Report is rated 12 in Germany (FSK), and filmdienst.de, a German film review site, recommends it from 16; above all it is a gripping, technically brilliant thriller. Critics and audiences agree unusually well here. If you want to see what becomes of the presumption of innocence when a state puts security above everything else, and how readily people get used to scanners in everyday life, you will find a vivid thought experiment that has aged well. It works very well for a movie night with discussion, especially since the question of how much prevention a free state may allow itself has not grown smaller since 2002.

Sources

  • Minority Report (German Wikipedia, in German), https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minority_Report
  • Minority Report (film) (Wikipedia), https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minority_Report_(film)
  • Minority Report (Wikidata Q244604), https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q244604
  • Minority Report – Film ∣ Kritik (filmdienst.de, Lexikon des internationalen Films, in German), https://www.filmdienst.de/film/details/519249/minority-report
  • Minority Report – Die Filmstarts-Kritik auf FILMSTARTS.de (in German), https://www.filmstarts.de/kritiken/34917/kritik.html
  • Minority Report | Rotten Tomatoes, https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/minority_report
  • Minority Report | Metacritic, https://www.metacritic.com/movie/minority-report/
  • Minority Report – Stream: Jetzt Film online finden und anschauen (JustWatch Germany, in German), https://www.justwatch.com/de/Film/Minority-Report
  • Minority Report (TCM, Jeremy Arnold), https://www.tcm.com/articles/648300/minority-report
  • Minority Report: Spielberg’s precognition (Spiked, Sandy Starr, July 4, 2002), https://www.spiked-online.com/2002/07/04/minority-report-spielbergs-precognition/

← All films

Popular:

Tip: press / or Ctrl+K to open search from any page.