Skip to content Skip to footer

Bastiat’s parable: a broken window creates work for the glazier, but only because the money is now missing somewhere else. Those who count only what is visible overlook the costs.

See also:
Austrian School

The broken window fallacy comes from Frédéric Bastiat. In his 1850 essay “Ce qu’on voit et ce qu’on ne voit pas” (“That Which Is Seen, and That Which Is Not Seen”), a shopkeeper’s son smashes the shop window. The bystanders console him: now the glazier has work, and the money will stimulate the economy. Bastiat counters that without the incident, the owner would have bought shoes. The glazier gains, the shoemaker loses, and in the end there is a hole in the till where a window and a pair of shoes might have been.

The mistake lies in the counting: the new order is visible, while the business that never happens because the money is missing elsewhere stays invisible. Every expenditure has opportunity costs, that is, the benefit of the best alternative given up. Anyone who looks only at the visible half of the ledger mistakes destruction for prosperity. The same pattern appears with disasters, wars, and public construction projects.

The Keynesian view partly disagrees. In a recession with idle resources, the argument goes, the alternative would not be available in the first place; spending could then raise demand and employment without crowding anything out. The objection deserves attention, because it hinges on one condition: spare capacity. Bastiat had in mind an economy with scarce means, and there his arithmetic holds.

For individual liberty, the concept is a sober tool against the assumption that every expenditure or every ban is beneficial simply because it creates work. Those who regularly ask about the unseen side strip political promises of their air of self-evidence.

← All Glossary

Popular:

Tip: press / or Ctrl+K to open search from any page.