Skip to content Skip to footer

Roland Baader: The Man Who Warned Against the God-Players

Roland Baader, portrait photo

In February 1992 the member states of the European Community signed the Maastricht Treaty, which a few years later gave rise to the euro. A year after that, a small publisher in Böblingen, near Stuttgart, brought out a book titled Die Euro-Katastrophe (The Euro Catastrophe), with a creed for a subtitle: Für Europas Vielfalt – gegen Brüssels Einfalt (For Europe’s Diversity, Against Brussels’ Uniformity). Its author was neither a professor nor a central banker. Until 1987 he had run his family’s textile business, and now, in his home village, he was writing books about money, the state and liberty.

When Philipp Bagus published his analysis of the monetary union, The Tragedy of the Euro, in 2010, this 1993 book was listed in his bibliography. By then Roland Baader had spent almost twenty years explaining to German-speaking readers what Ludwig von Mises and Friedrich August von Hayek had discovered about money and planning. The Mises Austria institute credits him with a large share in the revival of the Austrian School in the German-speaking world.

At a glance

  • Life: February 14, 1940, in Kirrlach (today part of Waghäusel, Baden) to January 8, 2012, in the same place
  • Work: degree in economics (diploma thesis under Hayek in Freiburg, 1968), some twenty years as an entrepreneur in the textile industry, from 1987 an independent author and private scholar
  • Network: member of the Mont Pèlerin Society (from 1996) and the Property and Freedom Society, regular contributor to the libertarian magazine eigentümlich frei and the Swiss monthly Schweizer Monat
  • Honors: Hayek Medal of the Friedrich A. von Hayek Society (2015, posthumously); the Roland Baader Award, presented since 2012, is named after him
  • Major works: Kreide für den Wolf (1991), Die Euro-Katastrophe (1993), Fauler Zauber (1997), Totgedacht (2002), Geld, Gold und Gottspieler (2004), Geldsozialismus (2010)
  • In one sentence: He translated the Austrian School’s critique of money and the state into a language that readers without an economics degree could understand.

From the Lecture Hall to the Family Business

Baader was born in 1940 in Kirrlach, a village in northern Baden that is now part of the town of Waghäusel, the eldest of three brothers. From 1961 to 1968 he studied economics in Freiburg im Breisgau. Friedrich August von Hayek, the future Nobel laureate, had been teaching there since the early 1960s, and it was under him that Baader wrote the diploma thesis with which he completed his studies in 1968.

He did not go on to an academic career. For some twenty years he worked in his parents’ textile company, and after his father’s death he became its managing partner. When the market changed sharply in the mid-1980s, the business was partly wound up and sold in 1986 and 1987. From then on Baader lived as an independent author and private scholar who knew the economy from more than just books.

His first book appeared in 1988 and was about gold. More than a dozen others followed by 2010, most of them from small publishers such as Tykve, Resch and later Lichtschlag, along with 157 articles according to the bibliography compiled by Mises Austria, among them pieces in the Catholic weekly Rheinischer Merkur, the Swiss conservative paper Schweizerzeit and the magazine liberal. When the libertarian magazine eigentümlich frei was founded in 1998, he was one of its writers from the start. Hans-Hermann Hoppe visited him in Waghäusel in 1995 and 2004, and Baader contributed a warm recollection of those visits to Hoppe’s 2009 festschrift.

The Wolf with the Gentle Voice

In 1991, shortly after the fall of the Berlin Wall and in the middle of the collapse of the Soviet Union, Kreide für den Wolf (Chalk for the Wolf) was published. The title alludes to the Grimms’ fairy tale of the wolf and the seven young goats, in which the wolf eats chalk to make his voice sound gentle so that the little goats will open the door to him. The subtitle states the thesis: Die tödliche Illusion vom besiegten Sozialismus (The Deadly Illusion of Socialism Defeated). While the world was celebrating the end of the planned economy, Baader warned against believing the victory was complete.

He called the welfare state, as an Italian obituary reports, socialism in velvet gloves. It worked in the same direction as open state socialism, only more slowly. The very titles of his books from the 1990s show how much this idea occupied him, for example Fauler Zauber. Schein und Wirklichkeit des Sozialstaates (Hocus-Pocus: Appearance and Reality of the Welfare State, 1997) and the collection Wider die Wohlfahrtsdiktatur (Against the Welfare Dictatorship, 1995).

How seriously he meant this is shown by a text he wrote on December 27, 2011, barely two weeks before his death, which the same obituary quotes at length. In it Baader listed what in Germany is in state hands or under state control: pensions, health care, schools, the labor market, a tax and social contribution rate of more than fifty percent, the monopoly on paper money. Almost forty percent of the population, he wrote, lived entirely or mainly on government money. Anyone who calls such a reality capitalism, he concluded in essence, is ideologically blind.

Against the Single Currency

Die Euro-Katastrophe of 1993 was one of the early German warnings against monetary union. Its subtitle alone sets Europe’s diversity against standardization imposed from Brussels. In this book Baader also acknowledged that he had been influenced by ordoliberal thought, even though he did not count himself among the ordoliberals and was critical of the social market economy, the model of postwar West Germany. He nevertheless had high praise for Wilhelm Röpke, one of its founding fathers.

Money, Gold and God-Players

Money is at the center of his work. Geld, Gold und Gottspieler (Money, Gold and God-Players) was published in 2004 by Resch in Gräfelfing near Munich, a volume of 344 pages with the subtitle Am Vorabend der nächsten Weltwirtschaftskrise (On the Eve of the Next World Economic Crisis). In it Baader proceeded like a physician. The chapters are called “Case History,” “Diagnosis” and “Therapy,” and the patient is the economy of the industrialized nations. In the preface he names the cause of its illness as the state-run paper money system, “which is gradually poisoning the monetary circulation.”

His argument follows Mises. When they abandoned the gold standard, governments lost the last barrier that kept them from paying for their spending with newly created money. Artificially cheap money leads to inflation, to asset bubbles and to a debt that keeps generating new debt. Greed, derivatives and hedge funds, which are blamed after every crisis, Baader regarded as consequences of this development, not its cause. At one point he cites Hayek to the effect that for two thousand years governments have used their power over money mainly to exploit and defraud their subjects.

And the God-players? Robert Nef, who reviewed the book in Schweizer Monat in April 2005, interpreted the title this way: since the 19th century many people have replaced faith in God with faith in the state, which is supposed to solve every problem. Where state and money are so closely bound together that neither can exist without the other, the state plays God and seeks to control the fate of the economy and of money.

As a way out, Baader named two paths, both of which take money out of the hands of politicians: a return to a gold currency in the spirit of Mises or, following Hayek, competition among private issuers of money, which Hayek had proposed in 1976 in Denationalisation of Money. An independent central bank was not enough for him. In 2010, in Geldsozialismus (Money Socialism), he took stock of the financial crisis of 2008, whose causes he saw in precisely this state-run monetary system. It was his last completed book, and it also appeared in English in 2012 under the title Money Socialism.

The Responsibility of Intellectuals

In Totgedacht. Warum Intellektuelle unsere Welt zerstören (Thought to Death: Why Intellectuals Are Destroying Our World), Baader asked in 2002 why so many clever minds cling to false ideas. Since antiquity, the jacket copy says, philosophers and men of letters thinking about state and society have let themselves be fascinated by utopias and collectivist blueprints, and the totalitarian systems of the 20th century were at first “brainchildren of intellectuals.” Baader hit out in both directions, at Carl Schmitt and Armin Mohler as well as at Ulrich Beck and Günter Wallraff.

Gerd Habermann, writing in the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, called it an influential polemic and praised it. Detmar Doering, in the Swiss daily Neue Zürcher Zeitung, was convinced by the reckoning and reported feeling a refreshing anger while reading. Baader saw the most important cause of the intellectuals’ errors in the state education system, and he called for it to be privatized.

A Liberal Christian

What set Baader apart from many economists of his school was the religious foundation of his convictions. Habermann described him as an author who saw himself as a liberal Christian. Baader called the Ten Commandments a constitution of liberty, and he considered socialism incompatible with them because it violated most of the commandments, above all the prohibition against stealing. Christ, as the Italian obituary puts his view, invites us to give voluntarily, not to take things from others by force. He was therefore harsh with the churches, because in his opinion they had tied themselves too closely to the welfare state.

It was probably this moral grounding above all that won him readers who could make little of the language of professional economists, because it showed that criticism of the state can also be ethical criticism. Politically he long considered himself a supporter of a minimal state, but toward the end he conceded that the anarcho-capitalists had the better arguments.

What friends of liberty can learn from him

The first lesson concerns money. Whoever controls money can shift burdens without openly deciding to do so, and can pursue a debt policy that others will pay for later. Baader described this connection at a time when hardly anyone was talking about zero interest rates and central bank bond purchases, and he showed that the question of sound money is a question of justice.

His view of the welfare state is just as instructive. For him voluntary help is a virtue, while compulsory redistribution is something fundamentally different, even when it goes by the name of solidarity. With this distinction in mind, it is possible to talk about social policy without confusing a willingness to help with state coercion, and Baader kept putting it before his readers again and again.

Perhaps the most can be learned from the way he worked, though. Baader had no professorship and no institute behind him. He wrote clearly and vividly, with fairy tales, case histories and aphorisms, and in this way reached people who would never have opened a volume by Mises. Robert Nef saw in his books a healing effect on a readership that increasingly distrusts the welfare state.

What Remains of Him

Roland Baader died on January 8, 2012, in Kirrlach after a long illness, at the age of 71. The publisher André F. Lichtschlag called him at the time the “most important liberty author in Germany.” In June of the same year the Roland Baader Award was presented for the first time; later recipients include Lew Rockwell and, in Vienna in 2019, Hans-Hermann Hoppe for his life’s work. In 2015 the Friedrich A. von Hayek Society honored him posthumously with its Hayek Medal, and his readers gather every year in his home village for a Roland Baader meeting.

The question he put to the God-players has not gone away since. As long as governments and central banks believe that newly created money can produce lasting prosperity, his work remains an invitation to look more closely at who pays the bill in the end.

Further reading

  • Roland Baader: Geld, Gold und Gottspieler. Am Vorabend der nächsten Weltwirtschaftskrise, Resch, Gräfelfing 2004 (in German)
  • Roland Baader: Kreide für den Wolf. Die tödliche Illusion vom besiegten Sozialismus, Tykve, Böblingen 1991 (new edition Lichtschlag 2021) (in German)
  • Roland Baader: Totgedacht. Warum Intellektuelle unsere Welt zerstören, Resch, Gräfelfing 2002 (in German)
  • Roland Baader (ed.): Logik der Freiheit. Ein Ludwig-von-Mises-Brevier (The Logic of Liberty: A Ludwig von Mises Breviary), Ott, Thun 2000 (in German)

This article is part of our series on thinkers, doers and historical figures of liberty.

Sources

  • Baader, Roland: Kreide für den Wolf. Die tödliche Illusion vom besiegten Sozialismus, Anita Tykve Verlag, Böblingen 1991 (new edition Lichtschlag Medien 2021) (in German).
  • Baader, Roland: Die Euro-Katastrophe. Für Europas Vielfalt – gegen Brüssels Einfalt, Anita Tykve Verlag, Böblingen 1993 (in German).
  • Baader, Roland (ed.): Wider die Wohlfahrtsdiktatur. Zehn liberale Stimmen, Resch, Gräfelfing 1995 (in German).
  • Baader, Roland: Fauler Zauber. Schein und Wirklichkeit des Sozialstaates, Resch, Gräfelfing 1997 (in German).
  • Baader, Roland (ed.): Logik der Freiheit. Ein Ludwig-von-Mises-Brevier, Ott, Thun 2000 (in German).
  • Baader, Roland: Totgedacht. Warum Intellektuelle unsere Welt zerstören, Resch, Gräfelfing 2002 (in German).
  • Baader, Roland: Geld, Gold und Gottspieler. Am Vorabend der nächsten Weltwirtschaftskrise, Resch, Gräfelfing 2004 (2nd edition 2005) (in German).
  • Baader, Roland: Geldsozialismus. Die wirklichen Ursachen der neuen globalen Depression, Resch, Gräfelfing 2010 (in German); English: Money Socialism, Verlag Johannes Müller 2012.
  • Baader, Roland: “A ‘Loveable Son of a Gun’,” in: Property, Freedom & Society. Essays in Honor of Hans-Hermann Hoppe, Ludwig von Mises Institute, Auburn 2009, https://mises.org/online-book/property-freedom-society/8-loveable-son-gun
  • Hayek, Friedrich August von: Denationalisation of Money, Institute of Economic Affairs, London 1976.
  • Mises Austria: thinker portrait of Roland Baader, https://mises.at/denker/roland-baader (in German)
  • Nef, Robert: review of “Geld, Gold und Gottspieler,” Schweizer Monat no. 939, April 2005, https://schweizermonat.ch/geld-gold-und-gottspieler-am-vorabend-der-naechsten-weltwirtschaftskrise/ (in German)
  • Perlentaucher: Totgedacht (review summaries of Gerd Habermann, FAZ, December 9, 2002, and Detmar Doering, NZZ, April 12, 2003), https://perlentaucher.de/buch/roland-baader/totgedacht.html (in German)
  • Junge Freiheit: obituary “Roland Baader,” January 9, 2012, https://jungefreiheit.de/wirtschaft/2012/roland-baader/ (in German)
  • La Nuova Bussola Quotidiana: “Baader, cristiano e liberale,” January 14, 2012, https://www.newdailycompass.com/it/pdf/baader-cristiano-e-liberale (in Italian)
  • Tichys Einblick: “Hans-Hermann Hoppe für sein Lebenswerk geehrt,” November 29, 2019, https://www.tichyseinblick.de/?p=350934 (in German)
  • Bagus, Philipp: The Tragedy of the Euro, references, https://mises.org/online-book/tragedy-euro/references
  • Resch-Verlag: publisher’s page for Geld, Gold und Gottspieler, https://resch-verlag.com/geld-gold-und-gottspieler.html (in German)
  • List of recipients of the Hayek Medal, https://dewiki.de/Lexikon/Hayek-Medaille (in German)
  • Walter Eucken Institut: Friedrich A. von Hayek, https://www.eucken.de/en/personalities-of-the-fribourg-school/friedrich-a-von-hayek/
  • Wikipedia (de): Roland Baader, https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roland_Baader (list of works, positions, Roland Baader Award) (in German)

Featured image: Background edited

Popular:

Tip: press / or Ctrl+K to open search from any page.