In July 1944, delegates from 44 nations met at Bretton Woods, New Hampshire, to design the monetary order of the postwar era. The most important economics editorial writer at the New York Times followed their decisions with a critical eye. By his own count, Henry Hazlitt wrote 26 editorials on the conference and its consequences, 23 of which were published.
Then the publisher, Arthur Hays Sulzberger, called him in. Hazlitt had been allowed to criticize the delegates’ decisions, he said, but now the paper had to go along. According to a biography published by the Mises Institute, Hazlitt replied that this was an inflationary scheme that would end badly and that he could not support it. He moved to Newsweek and in 1946 published a slim book that made him better known than all his earlier editorials: Economics in One Lesson. The Bretton Woods system came to an end in the early 1970s, after President Nixon suspended the conversion of dollars into gold in August 1971.
At a glance
- Life: November 28, 1894, in Philadelphia, to July 9, 1993, in Fairfield, Connecticut
- Work: journalist at the Wall Street Journal and at The Nation, editor of the American Mercury (1933 to 1934), editorial writer for the New York Times (1934 to 1946), columnist at Newsweek (1946 to 1966)
- Network: founding vice president of the Foundation for Economic Education, founding member of the Mont Pèlerin Society, cofounder and editor of The Freeman
- Major works: Economics in One Lesson (1946), The Great Idea (1951, later Time Will Run Back), The Failure of the “New Economics” (1959), The Foundations of Morality (1964)
- In one sentence: He showed that you can tell good economic policy from bad by asking about the consequences no one sees.
A self-taught man in the newsroom
Hazlitt’s father died before the boy was three years old, and after the death of his stepfather in 1907 money in the family grew tight. Hazlitt attended City College in New York for about a year and then took evening classes for a few more months, but, as he later recalled, he was too tired after the day’s work to get much out of them. Not yet twenty, he started at the Wall Street Journal in 1913 as a secretary and worked his way up to reporter. When he misunderstood a dividend notice, he realized that the stock market can only be understood with knowledge of a much broader field, and he taught himself economics. He published his first book, Thinking as a Science, in his early twenties.
Positions followed at several New York newspapers, at the magazine The Nation, from which he parted after it changed course because of his criticism of the New Deal, and at the American Mercury, where he succeeded H. L. Mencken in 1933. Mencken called him one of the few economists in history who could really write. From 1934 on, Hazlitt wrote the economics editorials for the New York Times, and after leaving, he wrote the column “Business Tides” in Newsweek for twenty years. When he stopped in 1966, the magazine replaced him with three professors, among them Milton Friedman and Paul Samuelson.
One lesson in one sentence
Economics in One Lesson opens with a claim that sounds bold: the whole of economics can be reduced to a single lesson, and that lesson to a single sentence. It reads: “The art of economics consists in looking not merely at the immediate but at the longer effects of any act or policy; it consists in tracing the consequences of that policy not merely for one group but for all groups.”
Hazlitt made no secret of where he got the idea. In the preface he calls Frédéric Bastiat’s 1850 essay Ce qu’on voit et ce qu’on ne voit pas his greatest debt and describes his own book as a modernization, extension, and generalization of Bastiat’s approach. The second chapter retells Bastiat’s famous example right away. A hoodlum throws a brick through a shop window, and the onlookers console themselves that the glazier now has work. What they overlook is the new suit the shopkeeper had meant to buy with the same money. Instead of a window and a suit, he now has only the window, and the community is poorer by a suit that would otherwise have been made.
The lesson applied
In short chapters, Hazlitt traces the most popular fallacies of economic policy back to this pattern. Public works create visible jobs, but the money for them comes from taxes that prevent just as many invisible orders elsewhere. A tariff protects one industry and at the same time raises the cost of living for everyone who buys its goods. Legal price ceilings worsen the very shortage they are meant to cure, because the real cause of rising prices is a scarcity of goods or a surplus of money. He describes inflation itself as a kind of tax that escapes the control of the tax authorities.
The method becomes especially clear with the minimum wage. A wage, Hazlitt writes, is a price, and anyone who is worth less to an employer than the legal minimum will simply not be hired at all. His summary reads: “In brief, for a low wage you substitute unemployment.” What stands out is the tone in which he makes the case. Hazlitt does not deny that low wages are an evil, and he grants special cases in which workers are paid below their market value. He only insists that we also count the people who lose their jobs, or never get one, because of the well-meant law. Later editions added a separate chapter on rent control.
The book appeared in July 1946 from Harper & Brothers; a condensed version followed in Reader’s Digest as early as August, and a Spanish edition came out in Buenos Aires in 1947. Hazlitt revised it in the late 1970s and added a final chapter on the lesson after thirty years. It has sold more than a million copies and has been translated into many languages, first into German in 1983 under the title Economics. Über Wirtschaft und Misswirtschaft.
Against the new economics
The economics profession of the postwar era largely followed John Maynard Keynes, whose General Theory of 1936 became the basis of a policy that sought to fight unemployment with government spending and cheap money. Hazlitt pushed back, and at length. In The Failure of the “New Economics” in 1959, he went through Keynes’s main work chapter by chapter. He summed up his verdict with a nod to a quip attributed to Samuel Johnson: “What is original in the book is not true; and what is true is not original.” A year later, with The Critics of Keynesian Economics, he edited a volume that brought together critical essays by other authors on Keynesian doctrines.
Anyone who knows Economics in One Lesson will recognize the same idea here in greater detail. A government that spends money must first take it through taxes, borrow it from future taxpayers through debt, or take it from savers through new money. What the recipients of the spending gain is visible; what others lose in exchange remains hidden.
A friend to Ludwig von Mises
On January 8, 1938, Hazlitt reviewed Socialism, the book by the Viennese economist Ludwig von Mises, in the New York Times and called it a classic. When Mises emigrated to the United States in 1940, Hazlitt made sure he could write editorials for the Times, helped him obtain his teaching position at New York University, and put him in touch with the academic publisher through which Human Action eventually appeared at Yale. At Mises’s request, he even prepared a journalistically polished version of this major work, of which Mises, however, adopted little. It did the friendship no harm: on Hazlitt’s 70th birthday in 1964, Mises called him “the economic conscience of our country and of our nation.”
Hazlitt knew that ideas need places where they are cultivated. In 1946 he became founding vice president of the Foundation for Economic Education, which Leonard Read established and on whose board he served. In April 1947 he traveled to Switzerland for the first meeting of the Mont Pèlerin Society, and in 1950 he founded the magazine The Freeman with John Chamberlain and Isaac Don Levine, at times editing it on his own. His circle of friends also included Ayn Rand, whom he introduced to Mises.
A novel and an ethics
Hazlitt was more than a commentator on the politics of the day. In 1951 he published the novel The Great Idea, later reissued as Time Will Run Back. In it, the rulers of a centrally planned socialist world, amid economic chaos, discover that they must restore market prices, private ownership of the means of production, and competition if their society is to survive. The book appeared almost four decades before the planned economies of Eastern Europe collapsed.
His most ambitious work was The Foundations of Morality of 1964. In it, Hazlitt set out to show that the rules of morality are not arbitrary commands. He grounded them in their contribution to social cooperation, which he regarded as the great means by which people achieve nearly all of their own ends. In the preface to the second edition, he called his system Cooperatism. In doing so, he placed himself in the tradition of David Hume and advocated an ethics that does not judge each individual action by its utility, but judges general rules by whether they sustain peaceful coexistence. Libertarians who argue from natural law ground liberty differently, as a right that holds regardless of utility. Hazlitt, by contrast, set morality and economics on the same foundation: the voluntary cooperation of human beings.
What friends of liberty can learn from him
Hazlitt’s most important lesson is a question anyone can ask: And what happens next, and to whom? Every measure has beneficiaries who are visible and who express their thanks. Its costs are often borne by people no one knows, because all they have done is miss out on something: the contract that was not awarded, the job that was never created, the suit the shopkeeper did not buy. Anyone who gets into the habit of asking about these people will see through many debates without ever having studied economics.
His life also shows what clarity can achieve. Hazlitt wrote for newspaper readers, and his best-known book reached an audience of millions. He combined this gift with perseverance. When his newspaper demanded that he defend a policy he considered wrong, he gave up one of the most respected posts in American economic journalism. And he understood that good ideas need friends and institutions to outlast a time in which no one wants them.
The question about the unseen
Henry Hazlitt died in Connecticut in July 1993 at the age of 98. His library went to the Foundation for Economic Education. Of his many books, one above all is still read, and that is due to the simplicity of its lesson. It applies to every government and every decade, because the temptation remains to celebrate the visible benefits of a measure and pass over its hidden costs. The next time you read about a new subsidy, a new tariff, or a new price cap, you can start with Hazlitt’s question: Who pays for it, and who loses something they never get to see?
Further reading
- Henry Hazlitt: Economics in One Lesson, Harper & Brothers, New York 1946 (German edition: Economics. Über Wirtschaft und Misswirtschaft, Poller, Stuttgart 1983)
- Frédéric Bastiat: Ce qu’on voit et ce qu’on ne voit pas, Paris 1850 (in German as Was man sieht und was man nicht sieht)
- Henry Hazlitt: The Foundations of Morality, Van Nostrand, Princeton 1964
- Henry Hazlitt: My Life and Conclusions, unfinished memoirs, Foundation for Economic Education 2015
This article is part of our series on thinkers, doers, and historical figures of liberty.
Sources
- Hazlitt, Henry: Economics in One Lesson, Harper & Brothers, New York 1946; full text of the first edition at the Foundation for Economic Education, https://fee.org/resources/economics-in-one-lesson/ (German edition: Economics. Über Wirtschaft und Misswirtschaft, Poller, Stuttgart 1983; reprint Olzog 2009; in German).
- Hazlitt, Henry: The Great Idea, Appleton-Century-Crofts, New York 1951; new edition as Time Will Run Back, Arlington House, New Rochelle 1966.
- Hazlitt, Henry: The Failure of the “New Economics.” An Analysis of the Keynesian Fallacies, Van Nostrand, Princeton 1959.
- Hazlitt, Henry (ed.): The Critics of Keynesian Economics, Van Nostrand, Princeton 1960.
- Hazlitt, Henry: The Foundations of Morality, Van Nostrand, Princeton 1964; preface to the second edition (1972), https://mises.org/online-book/foundations-morality/preface-second-edition
- Hazlitt, Henry: My Life and Conclusions (unfinished memoirs, 1985), Foundation for Economic Education 2015, https://fee.org/ebooks/my-life-and-conclusions/
- Bastiat, Frédéric: Ce qu’on voit et ce qu’on ne voit pas, Guillaumin, Paris 1850.
- Ludwig von Mises Institute: Biography of Henry Hazlitt, https://mises.org/articles-interest/biography-henry-hazlitt
- Ludwig von Mises Institute: Profile of Henry Hazlitt, https://mises.org/profile/henry-hazlitt
- Tucker, Jeffrey A.: The Intellectual Journey of Henry Hazlitt, Foundation for Economic Education, December 17, 2015, https://fee.org/articles/the-intellectual-journey-of-henry-hazlitt/
- American Institute for Economic Research: Research Report of July 20, 1959 (review of The Failure of the “New Economics”), https://aier.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/11/RR19590720.pdf
- Mises Wire: Sixtieth Anniversary of Hazlitt’s Failure of the New Economics, https://mises.org/wire/sixtieth-anniversary-hazlitts-failure-new-economics
- Encyclopedia.com: Hazlitt, Henry Stuart (Scribner Encyclopedia of American Lives), https://www.encyclopedia.com/humanities/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/hazlitt-henry-stuart
- Federal Reserve History: Nixon Ends Convertibility of U.S. Dollars to Gold, https://www.federalreservehistory.org/essays/gold-convertibility-ends
- Wikipedia (en): Henry Hazlitt, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_Hazlitt (career timeline, starting point)
- Wikipedia (en): Economics in One Lesson, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economics_in_One_Lesson (editions, translations)
- Wikipedia (en): The Freeman (magazine), https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Freeman_(magazine) (founding in 1950)
Featured image: Henry Hazlitt (AI illustration)

