On April 1, 2026, Hans-Hermann Hoppe received an email from Auburn, Alabama. The leadership of the Ludwig von Mises Institute informed him that he would no longer hold the title of Distinguished Senior Fellow, which he had carried since around 2000, and pointed to his recent public statements about the institute. Half a year later, on September 20, Hoppe gave a lecture on historiography at the annual meeting of his own society in Bodrum, Turkey, that has drawn sharp criticism ever since, including from within the libertarian camp.
Hoppe is at the same time one of the most influential theorists of anarcho-capitalism. His justification of property, his analysis of democracy, and his monetary theory are read in many languages. Anyone who studies libertarian thought can hardly avoid him, and that is exactly why it is worth setting the two side by side: what he contributed to the idea of liberty and where he moves away from it.
At a glance
- Born: September 2, 1949, in Peine, Germany; now lives in Istanbul
- Work: Professor of economics at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas (1986 to 2008, emeritus since), founder and president of the Property and Freedom Society (since 2006), longtime editor of the Journal of Libertarian Studies
- Major works: A Theory of Socialism and Capitalism (1989), The Economics and Ethics of Private Property (1993), Democracy: The God That Failed (2001, German edition Demokratie. Der Gott, der keiner ist, 2003), The Myth of National Defense (ed., 2003), A Short History of Man (2015)
- Turning points: Title withdrawn by the Mises Institute (April 1, 2026), controversial lecture in Bodrum (September 20, 2026)
- In one sentence: He gave anarcho-capitalism a philosophical foundation of its own and combined it with theses on exclusion and history that are hard to reconcile with the liberty of the individual.
From Frankfurt to Las Vegas
Hoppe studied philosophy, sociology, history, and economics in Saarbrücken, Frankfurt am Main, and Ann Arbor. In Frankfurt he earned his doctorate in 1974 with a dissertation on the epistemology of David Hume, supervised by Jürgen Habermas, the best-known philosopher of the Frankfurt School; in 1981 he completed his habilitation, the German postdoctoral qualification for a professorship, in sociology and economics. After teaching posts at German universities and at the Bologna Center of Johns Hopkins University, he moved to the United States in 1986 to work with Murray N. Rothbard, the founder of modern anarcho-capitalism. Both taught at the University of Nevada in Las Vegas, and Hoppe remained closely associated with Rothbard until Rothbard’s death in January 1995.
He also became known through a dispute over academic freedom. In March 2004, in a lecture on time preference, he cited homosexuals as an example of a group that on average has fewer children and therefore plans less far ahead. After a student complained, the provost, in a letter expressly described as non-disciplinary, accused him of having created a hostile learning environment. The ACLU of Nevada represented Hoppe, and university president Carol Harter overturned the decision in February 2005 on the grounds that academic freedom must take precedence in case of doubt. In 2006 Hoppe founded the Property and Freedom Society, whose annual meetings take place in Bodrum. He lives in Istanbul with his wife, the economist Gülçin Imre Hoppe.
Four Varieties of Socialism
In A Theory of Socialism and Capitalism (1989), Hoppe defined socialism more broadly than usual. His starting point is a pure private property order in which everyone controls his own body and the things he was the first to take into possession or acquired by contract. Every departure from this is, for him, a form of socialism.
He distinguishes four varieties and devotes a chapter to each: Russian-style socialism with nationalized means of production, social-democratic socialism with taxes and redistribution, conservative socialism, which protects existing holdings through regulation, and the socialism of social engineers, who want to shape society according to plans. With this, Hoppe wants to show that even countries without a planned economy suffer, in weakened form, from the same perverse incentives, because every intervention in property makes producing and saving less rewarding.
To Argue Is Already to Acknowledge
His most original contribution is a new justification of property rights, which he presented in September 1988 in the magazine Liberty and worked out in the seventh chapter of the same book. The approach recalls the discourse ethics of his Frankfurt teacher but leads to conclusions that were far from Habermas’s mind. Anyone who argues with another person about what is right, instead of coercing him, already presupposes that the other controls his own body and can freely agree or disagree.
So anyone who uses arguments to deny that people own themselves refutes himself the moment he speaks; philosophers call this a performative contradiction. From self-ownership Hoppe derives the right to things that someone was the first to use or acquired voluntarily, and from that the illegitimacy of all violence against person and property, including violence by the state.
Murray Rothbard, who had long believed that no ethics could be derived from the theory of human action, called the approach in November 1988 “a dazzling breakthrough for political philosophy in general and for libertarianism in particular.” In a symposium that Liberty held the same month, however, the majority of those asked rejected the argument, and it remains disputed among libertarians to this day.
The Owner and the Caretaker
Hoppe became known to a wider public with Democracy: The God That Failed, which appeared in 2001 and in German in 2003 under the title Demokratie. Der Gott, der keiner ist. The English edition’s subtitle, The Economics and Politics of Monarchy, Democracy, and Natural Order, reveals the structure of the argument, which compares the two forms of rule in terms of time preference, that is, how strongly someone prefers the present to the future.
A hereditary monarch regards his country like an owner who can pass it on and therefore has an interest in preserving its value over generations. An elected politician, by contrast, is a temporary caretaker who can neither sell nor bequeath the country but can use up its resources within a few years. From this Hoppe explains why taxes, public debt, and government spending as a share of GDP have risen in the democratic age, and why wars waged in the name of the whole people became more total than the cabinet wars of princes.
The book is not a plea for kings. Hoppe’s goal is a natural order, a private law society without a state, and the comparison is meant to show that democracy, too, is rule and has its own, often overlooked, perverse incentives.
Gold, Paper, and Fractional Reserves
In monetary theory, too, Hoppe follows the line of Mises and Rothbard. In the essay “How Is Fiat Money Possible?” in the Review of Austrian Economics (1994), he argues that money arises on the market as a commodity, gold for example, and that pure paper money without backing cannot emerge from voluntary exchange. It presupposes a monopoly enforced by the state; no paper money, in his words, could come into being “innocently” or “immaculately.”
Banks that back demand deposits only partly with reserves and lend out the rest give, in his view, two parties a claim to the same money. He calls this practice “fraud and embezzlement” and blames it for inflation, redistribution in favor of the banks and their debtors, and business cycles. As a just monetary order he envisions commodity money such as gold, competing banks, and deposits with one hundred percent backing. Economists of the free banking school such as George Selgin and Lawrence White have disagreed.
Security as a Service
To the question of how a society without a state would protect its members, Hoppe answers with an idea that the Belgian-French economist Gustave de Molinari had formulated in 1849. Insurers have an interest in preventing damage, because every loss costs them money; they would maintain security services, have disputes settled by arbitration, and, unlike a state, could not force anyone to pay. In the edited volume The Myth of National Defense (2003), Hoppe and his coauthors applied this idea to national defense.
Where Property Turns into Exclusion
From the same theory of property, Hoppe draws conclusions that are hard to square with the liberty of the individual. In 1998 he argued in the Journal of Libertarian Studies that free trade and restricted immigration belong together. As long as the state administers public goods and spaces, he wrote, unrestricted immigration amounts to “forced integration,” because politicians, not property owners, decide who comes.
A passage in Democracy: The God That Failed (pp. 216–218) goes further. In a covenant community as Hoppe envisions it, advocates of democracy and communism would have to be “physically separated and expelled from society,” and people whose way of life he regards as hostile to the family would likewise have to be “physically removed.” The exclusion is thus tied to opinions and ways of life and does not require any act of violence. Walter Block considers this conclusion hard to reconcile with libertarianism.
In 2025 and 2026, Hoppe also broke with institutions he had been associated with for decades. In July 2025 he resigned, together with Jörg Guido Hülsmann and Rolf W. Puster, from the scientific advisory board of the Ludwig von Mises Institute Germany, because it intended to give Javier Milei a memorial award in honor of Mises. On March 25, 2026, he criticized the course of the American institute in the essay “Mises Institute: Quo Vadis?” One week later, on April 1, the institute withdrew his title and pointed to his recent public statements about the institute; Hoppe accepted the decision. His writings remain available on its website.
On September 20, 2026, at the 20th annual meeting of the Property and Freedom Society in Bodrum, Hoppe spoke on “Learning and Revising History: Rothbardian Lessons”; the society published the recording on October 25. After the lecture came criticism, including from the libertarian scene. The philosopher Matt Zwolinski quotes sentences from it about the criminalization of doubts about the Holocaust in Germany, about a “so-called German guilt” and the “so-called Nuremberg trial,” and judges them to be Holocaust denial.
What exactly Hoppe meant by this remains open. The accusations rest on individual quotations from a longer lecture, no complete transcript is available, and Hoppe himself has not yet responded to the criticism. On this basis, no judgment can be made as to whether he denies the Holocaust.
What Can Be Learned from Him
Despite everything, Hoppe’s work contains ideas that deserve to be examined rather than discarded along with their author. The most important one lies in the title of his best-known book: democracy, too, is rule, and a majority has no more right than a king to take a person’s property. His explanation of the growth of the state does not need to blame individual parties; whoever governs only for a limited time and does not pay the bill himself has a short horizon. And argumentation ethics reminds us that every honest conversation presupposes the freedom of the other person.
A Body of Work That Cannot Be Separated
Hans-Hermann Hoppe gave anarcho-capitalism an original philosophical foundation, a sharp analysis of democracy, and a rigorous monetary theory. Yet he also uses the same theory of property to justify excluding people because of their opinions or way of life, and his 2026 lecture has discredited him even among libertarians, though it is still unclear what he meant by it. Whoever reads his books reads both. The question he puts to democracy can also be put to him: where does a community get the right to exclude a person who has done violence to no one?
Further reading
- Hans-Hermann Hoppe: Demokratie. Der Gott, der keiner ist. Monarchie, Demokratie und natürliche Ordnung, translated by Robert Grözinger, Manuscriptum, Leipzig 2003 (in German); in English: Democracy: The God That Failed. The Economics and Politics of Monarchy, Democracy, and Natural Order, Transaction Publishers, New Brunswick 2001
- Hans-Hermann Hoppe: A Theory of Socialism and Capitalism, Kluwer, Boston 1989 (new edition Ludwig von Mises Institute, Auburn 2007)
- Hans-Hermann Hoppe: How Is Fiat Money Possible? or, The Devolution of Money and Credit, in: Review of Austrian Economics 7 (2), 1994
- Matt Zwolinski: The Trouble with Hans-Hermann Hoppe, The Bleeding Heart Libertarian, October 29, 2026
This article is part of our series on thinkers, doers, and historical figures of liberty.
Sources
- Hoppe, Hans-Hermann: Handeln und Erkennen. Zur Kritik des Empirismus am Beispiel der Philosophie David Humes, doctoral dissertation, Frankfurt am Main 1974, Lang, Bern 1976 (in German).
- Hoppe, Hans-Hermann: A Theory of Socialism and Capitalism, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston 1989; new edition Ludwig von Mises Institute, Auburn 2007, online: https://mises.org/online-book/theory-socialism-and-capitalism
- Hoppe, Hans-Hermann: The Economics and Ethics of Private Property, Kluwer, Boston 1993; 2nd edition Ludwig von Mises Institute, Auburn 2006.
- Hoppe, Hans-Hermann: The Case for Free Trade and Restricted Immigration, in: Journal of Libertarian Studies 13 (2), 1998, pp. 221–233, https://mises.org/journal-libertarian-studies/case-free-trade-and-restricted-immigration
- Hoppe, Hans-Hermann: The Private Production of Defense, in: Journal of Libertarian Studies 14 (1), 1998/99.
- Hoppe, Hans-Hermann: How Is Fiat Money Possible? or, The Devolution of Money and Credit, in: Review of Austrian Economics 7 (2), 1994, pp. 49–74, https://nakamotoinstitute.org/how-is-fiat-money-possible/
- Hoppe, Hans-Hermann: Democracy: The God That Failed. The Economics and Politics of Monarchy, Democracy, and Natural Order, Transaction Publishers, New Brunswick 2001; German edition: Demokratie. Der Gott, der keiner ist. Monarchie, Demokratie und natürliche Ordnung, translated by Robert Grözinger, Manuscriptum, Leipzig 2003 (2nd edition Waltrop 2004) (in German).
- Hoppe, Hans-Hermann (ed.): The Myth of National Defense, Ludwig von Mises Institute, Auburn 2003.
- Hoppe, Hans-Hermann: My Battle with the Thought Police, Mises Daily, April 12, 2005, https://mises.org/mises-daily/my-battle-thought-police
- Hoppe, Hans-Hermann; Hülsmann, Jörg Guido; Puster, Rolf W.: Statement of resignation from the scientific advisory board of the Ludwig von Mises Institute Germany, July 13, 2025, https://hanshoppe.com/2025/08/resignation-mises-institute-germany/
- Hoppe, Hans-Hermann: Mises Institute: Quo Vadis?, Property and Freedom Journal, March 25, 2026, https://propertyandfreedom.org/2026/03/hoppe-mises-institute-quo-vadis
- Kinsella, Stephan; Hoppe, Hans-Hermann (eds.): Rothbard at 100. A Tribute and Assessment, 2026, https://propertyandfreedom.org/books/rothbard-100/
- Rothbard, Murray N.: Beyond Is and Ought, in: Liberty 2 (2), November 1988, https://mises.org/library/beyond-and-ought
- Molinari, Gustave de: De la production de la sécurité, in: Journal des Économistes, February 1849 (in French).
- HansHoppe.com: About (CV, list of works, awards), https://www.hanshoppe.com/about/
- Ludwig von Mises Institute: Profile of Hans-Hermann Hoppe, https://mises.org/profile/hans-hermann-hoppe
- Kinsella, Stephan: Hoppe Removed as Mises Institute Senior Distinguished Fellow, April 1, 2026, https://hanshoppe.com/2026/04/hoppe-removed-as-mises-institute-senior-distinguished-fellow/
- Property and Freedom Society: PFS 2026 Annual Meeting (program), https://propertyandfreedom.org/2026/01/pfs-2026-annual-meeting/
- Zwolinski, Matt: The Trouble with Hans-Hermann Hoppe, The Bleeding Heart Libertarian, October 29, 2026, https://bleedingheartlibertarian.substack.com/p/the-trouble-with-hans-hermann-hoppe
- Las Vegas Sun: ACLU seeking exoneration of UNLV professor, February 21, 2005, https://lasvegassun.com/news/2005/feb/21/aclu-seeking-exoneration-of-unlv-professor/
- Ludwig von Mises Institute: The Latest in the Hoppe Case (Mises Wire, 2005), https://mises.org/mises-wire/latest-hoppe-case
- Perlentaucher: Hans-Hermann Hoppe, Demokratie, https://perlentaucher.de/buch/hans-hermann-hoppe/demokratie.html (in German)
- Deutsche Digitale Bibliothek / DNB (German Digital Library / German National Library): Handeln und Erkennen, https://www.deutsche-digitale-bibliothek.de/item/PSJ5I5BC73PYIKRY7FEAGZSZZLTNJNW4 (in German)
- Snyder, Martin D.: State of the Profession: Birds of a Feather?, in: Academe 91 (2), 2005, https://www.jstor.org/stable/40253419
- Wikipedia (English): Hans-Hermann Hoppe, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans-Hermann_Hoppe (overview, biography, references)
- Selgin, George; White, Lawrence H.: In Defense of Fiduciary Media, in: Review of Austrian Economics 9 (2), 1996, pp. 83–107, https://mises.org/online-book/review-austrian-economics/defense-fiduciary-media-or-we-are-not-devolutionists-we-are-misesians1
Featured image: Background edited

