When the Parliamentary Council began work on the Basic Law, Germany’s constitution, in Bonn in 1948, it had before it a draft prepared on the island of Herrenchiemsee by a constitutional committee of the minister-presidents (state premiers) of the three western zones. Its first article opened with the sentence: “The state exists for the sake of man, not man for the sake of the state.” The sentence did not make it into the final version of 1949 in this form; its place was taken by the inviolable dignity of the human person.
Carlos A. Gebauer quotes this sentence in the preface to his book Grundgesetz 2030 (Basic Law 2030), and it fits his entire body of work. Gebauer has practiced as a lawyer since 1994 and has been writing since 1995, and in both roles the same question occupies him: How much room does the law leave the individual, and who takes that room away piece by piece? A broad audience knows him from television. Readers of pro-liberty journalism have known him for two decades as a columnist who treats legal questions with precision and dry wit.
At a glance
- Born: 1964 in Düsseldorf
- Profession: lawyer since 1994, certified specialist in medical law, at the firm Lindenau, Prior & Partner in Düsseldorf; appointed judge at the lawyers’ disciplinary court in 2003
- Journalism: columnist for the libertarian magazine eigentümlich frei since 2005 (column “Make love not law”)
- Offices: legal counsel on the board of the Friedrich A. von Hayek Society (as of November 2026); chairman of the Javier Milei Institute for Deregulation in Europe since its founding in December 2025
- Books (selection): Warum wir alle reich sein könnten (2008), Der Gesundheits-Affront (2009), Rettet Europa vor der EU (2014), Grundgesetz 2030 (2021), Hayeks Warnung vor der Knechtschaft (2024), and as editor Die Akte Guérot (2026)
- In one sentence: A jurist who sees the law as a protective wall around the individual and makes that case with intellect and humor.
From the Courtroom to the Television Studio
Gebauer was born in Düsseldorf in 1964 and studied philosophy, modern history, linguistics, law, and musicology in Düsseldorf, Bayreuth, and Bonn. Already during his legal clerkship he chose placements that would later shape his path, among them the special chamber for the law of statutory health insurance physicians at the Düsseldorf Social Court. As a lawyer he worked mainly in insurance and hospital law, and from 1995 to 2007 also as a deputy notary. Since April 2012 he has been with the Düsseldorf business law firm Lindenau, Prior & Partner, which still lists him on its team today. In November 2003 the Justice Ministry of North Rhine-Westphalia appointed him a judge at the Anwaltsgericht, the disciplinary court for lawyers, for the district of the Düsseldorf Bar Association.
He became known across Germany by an unusual route. From 2002 to 2008 he appeared as a defense attorney in several hundred episodes of the RTL courtroom show Das Strafgericht (The Criminal Court), followed in 2010 and 2011 by the series Die 2 – Anwälte mit Herz (The Two: Lawyers with Heart) for Sat.1. He describes those years with self-irony as “a paid internship on the question of how television programs are produced.” He was a guest on talk shows such as Sabine Christiansen and Nachtcafé, and so his arguments reached an audience far beyond legal circles.
Medicine Without a Guardian
His first major subject lay close to his work as a lawyer in hospital and insurance law. In 2005 he published an essay in the legal policy journal Zeitschrift für Rechtspolitik titled “Einige Grundrechte gegen Staatsmedizin” (Some Fundamental Rights Against State Medicine). Four years later came Der Gesundheits-Affront (The Health Affront), whose subtitle names the program: Plädoyers für die Entpolitisierung unserer Gesundheit und gegen die staatliche Industrialisierung der Medizin (Pleas for the depoliticization of our health and against the state industrialization of medicine). In 2016, with Die Würde des Menschen im Gesundheitssystem (Human Dignity in the Health Care System), he presented five fundamental reflections on the body, society, and law.
The titles alone reveal the idea. Health is to be freed from the grip of politics, and the dignity of the patient stands above the logic of an administration that plans medicine like an industrial operation. Gebauer has argued this view for years in the professional journals of physicians and dentists as well, and in 2009 he also sat on the scientific advisory board of the magazine Der Kassenarzt.
We Could All Be Rich
In 2008 the publisher Lichtschlag brought out his book Warum wir alle reich sein könnten und wie unsere Politik das verhindert (Why We Could All Be Rich and How Our Politics Prevents It). The publisher sums up the thesis briefly: without the policies practiced today, we could all be considerably richer, and the weakest in particular would benefit. Notable is the subtitle, which announces a “plea for a return to a consistent civil law.” It shows where Gebauer looks for the solution: in the law that people create among themselves through contracts, rather than in ever new powers for the administration.
Since 2005 he has been a regular columnist for eigentümlich frei. His column bears the same name as his website, “Make love not law,” and it still appears regularly, most recently at the end of October 2026. For years he also gave the laudatory speech for the Liberal Network Foundation (Stiftung Liberales Netzwerk) at its negative award “Gängelband des Jahres” (roughly, “Leash of the Year”). Those so honored included the politicians Ulla Schmidt and Horst Seehofer, the Federal Employment Agency (then still called the Federal Labor Office), and the European Court of Justice, which says a good deal about the speaker’s sense of humor.
A Liberal Within His Own Party
His commitment to liberty also led Gebauer into party politics. In the summer of 2009, by his own account, he let Frank Schäffler, a member of the Bundestag (Germany’s federal parliament), persuade him to return to the Free Democratic Party (FDP), Germany’s liberal party, and to co-found the “Liberaler Aufbruch” (Liberal Awakening) there. In 2011 the two of them, together with Holger Krahmer, were among the initiators of a membership ballot against the European Stability Mechanism, the eurozone’s permanent bailout fund. Against their own party leadership, a full 44.2 percent of participants voted for the critics’ motion in December 2011, although the required quorum was not reached. In 2017 Gebauer ran for the FDP in the Bundestag constituency of Duisburg I and received 7.0 percent of the first votes, the votes cast for constituency candidates.
He set out his position on Europe in 2014 in Rettet Europa vor der EU (Save Europe from the EU). The book makes the case for a return to decentralized, subsidiary self-responsibility and to the law. On his website he states that, in view of the principle of subsidiarity in the Basic Law, he considers a European federal state with centrally steering state power to be unconstitutional.
Renovating the Basic Law to Preserve It
With Grundgesetz 2030 Gebauer took an unusual approach in 2021. He prints every article of the constitution, including those he wants to leave unchanged, and shows in annotations where he suggests a change and why. He explicitly describes his proposals as “modernization proposals for a renovation” meant to preserve it, a thorough repair of the existing structure rather than a new building. The Basic Law has given Germany a remarkably stable order since 1949, he writes in the preface, and for that very reason one must examine whether its structures are still resilient enough. Each proposal is meant to be discussed on its own, and the joint deliberation, he hopes, could be concluded by 2030. The book carries a Latin sentence as its motto: Neminem laede, immo omnes, quantum potes, iuva, harm no one, but rather help everyone as much as you can.
Hayek for Today’s Readers
Gebauer joined the Friedrich A. von Hayek Society in 2005 at the suggestion of Roland Baader. In June 2015 the members elected him deputy chairman; today the board lists him as legal counsel and press contact. In May 2026 he opened the Hayek Days in Münster. According to the report in hayekforum, he defended liberalism there against being classified as “right-wing,” saying it stands “neither left nor right,” and he took on a widespread error: “No, Friedrich A. Hayek did not advise Augusto Pinochet!”
For the 80th anniversary of The Road to Serfdom in 2024, Gebauer published an annotated introduction, Hayeks Warnung vor der Knechtschaft (Hayek’s Warning Against Serfdom), printed with the support of the Hayek Society. He follows Hayek’s chapters step by step and places them in the context of the present. Right in the preliminary remarks he sums up the core: “A human being can only be either a free and personally acting subject or a heteronomous, acted-upon object in a whole constructed by other powers.”
In doing so, he refrains from making Hayek more radical than he was. He reminds readers that in 1944 Hayek thought little of mere laissez-faire and even entrusted the state with tasks in currency and the supervision of monopolies. He calls the common reading of the book “as a hymn to market radicalism” “definitely incorrect.” This fairness toward the original makes the introduction valuable, especially for readers encountering Hayek for the first time. In Tichys Einblick, a German opinion magazine, Gebauer recommended Hayek’s classic for the school curriculum in November 2024 and showed that its question about the limits of centralized knowledge arises anew in the age of algorithms.
Deregulation as a Program
In early December 2025 the Javier Milei Institute for Deregulation in Europe was founded in Germany, with the approval of the Argentine president. Gebauer took over as chairman. Among the other founding members, Apollo News named the economist Philipp Bagus, the former leader of the Alternative for Germany (AfD) Frauke Petry, and the chairman of the Hayek Society, Stefan Kooths; Thorsten Polleit of the Ludwig von Mises Institut Deutschland sits on the academic advisory board. The institute aims to draw up concrete proposals for how the state can be returned to its core tasks. In March 2026 the first conference took place near Leipzig under the motto “Deregulate Germany. Now!” At the Hayek Days in May, Gebauer stressed that the institute and the Hayek Society remain “consistently private and not publicly funded.”
At the founding he said a sentence that sums up his stance well: “Nothing is more humane, more appreciative, and more socially necessary than liberalism, rightly understood and lived.”
For Academic Freedom
In 2020 Gebauer was among the first signatories of the Appeal for Free Spaces of Debate (Appell für freie Debattenräume). In 2026 he edited Die Akte Guérot (The Guérot File) for Westend Verlag, a legal case study on academic freedom. The volume documents the legal dispute between the political scientist Ulrike Guérot and the University of Bonn, which had dismissed her in February 2023 over allegations of plagiarism. The Bonn Labor Court and the Cologne Higher Labor Court held the dismissal to be valid, and the Federal Labor Court dismissed her complaint against the denial of leave to appeal on points of law. Gebauer, who by his own account followed the proceedings at her side as a non-specialist in labor law, documents the judgments and briefs from every instance. In his preliminary remarks he sees the case as a warning sign for the independence of scholarship at German universities.
What friends of liberty can learn from him
The first lesson concerns the tools. In Gebauer’s work, liberty is defended in the fine print, in fundamental rights, jurisdictions, and procedures, rather than in grand slogans. Anyone who wants to understand how powers grow will find in his writing a precise description of how vague concepts and new jurisdictions narrow the individual’s room to maneuver.
The second lesson concerns fairness. His introduction to Hayek shows that the best way to defend a classic is to render it accurately, even where it was less radical than some of its readers today.
The third lesson is one of tone. Gebauer can judge sharply and still remain cheerful. Someone who hands out a “Leash of the Year” and names a column “Make love not law” takes the cause seriously without taking himself too seriously.
The Human Being First
On his website Gebauer describes himself as a “purist liberal” who believes in the moral obligation of every individual to shape his life responsibly, for himself and for his fellow human beings. Everything else follows from this. Whoever trusts people with this responsibility must limit laws, administration, and political influence to what is necessary, and must make sure that the law holds this line. The sentence from Herrenchiemsee did not make it into the Basic Law. In Gebauer’s work as a lawyer and author, it has lived on for three decades.
Further reading
- Carlos A. Gebauer: Hayeks Warnung vor der Knechtschaft. Eine kommentierte Einführung in das Jahrhundertbuch „The Road to Serfdom“ 80 Jahre nach seiner Erstausgabe, Lichtschlag, Grevenbroich 2024 (in German)
- Carlos A. Gebauer: Grundgesetz 2030. Modernisierungsvorschläge für eine Erhaltungssanierung, Lau-Verlag, Reinbek 2021 (in German)
- Carlos A. Gebauer: Warum wir alle reich sein könnten und wie unsere Politik das verhindert, Lichtschlag, Grevenbroich 2008 (in German)
- Friedrich A. von Hayek: The Road to Serfdom, 1944 (German edition: Der Weg zur Knechtschaft)
This article is part of our series on thinkers, doers, and historical figures of liberty.
Sources
- Gebauer, Carlos A.: “Grenzen der Übermittlung von Patientendaten zwischen Krankenhaus und Krankenkasse,” in: Neue Juristische Wochenschrift 56 (2003), no. 11, pp. 777–780 (in German).
- Gebauer, Carlos A.: “Einige Grundrechte gegen Staatsmedizin,” in: Zeitschrift für Rechtspolitik 38 (2005), no. 5, pp. 162–165 (in German).
- Gebauer, Carlos A.: Warum wir alle reich sein könnten und wie unsere Politik das verhindert, Lichtschlag, Grevenbroich 2008, ISBN 978-3-939562-12-2 (in German).
- Gebauer, Carlos A.: Der Gesundheits-Affront. Plädoyers für die Entpolitisierung unserer Gesundheit und gegen die staatliche Industrialisierung der Medizin, Lichtschlag, Grevenbroich 2009, ISBN 978-3-939562-19-1 (in German).
- Gebauer, Carlos A.: Rettet Europa vor der EU. Wie ein Traum an der Gier nach Macht zerbricht, FinanzBuch Verlag, Munich 2014, ISBN 978-3-89879-846-4 (in German).
- Gebauer, Carlos A.: Die Würde des Menschen im Gesundheitssystem. Fünf grundsätzliche Überlegungen zu Körper, Gesellschaft und Recht, Lichtschlag, Grevenbroich 2016, ISBN 978-3-939562-41-2 (in German).
- Gebauer, Carlos A.: Grundgesetz 2030. Modernisierungsvorschläge für eine Erhaltungssanierung, Lau-Verlag, Reinbek 2021, ISBN 978-3-95768-231-4 (in German) (reading sample: https://cdn-assets.versacommerce.de/agshop_versacommerce_de/mediafiles/images/Leseprobe_carlos_gebauer_Grundgesetz_2030.pdf).
- Gebauer, Carlos A.: Hayeks Warnung vor der Knechtschaft. Eine kommentierte Einführung in das Jahrhundertbuch „The Road to Serfdom“ 80 Jahre nach seiner Erstausgabe, Lichtschlag, Grevenbroich 2024, ISBN 978-3-948971-21-2 (in German) (reading sample: https://cdn-assets.versacommerce.de/agshop_versacommerce_de/mediafiles/images/Leseprobe_carlos_gebauer_hayeks_warnung.pdf).
- Gebauer, Carlos A.: “Hayek weist in seinem Klassiker den Weg zur Freiheit,” Tichys Einblick, November 15, 2024, https://www.tichyseinblick.de/feuilleton/buecher/hayek-weist-in-seinem-klassiker-den-weg-zur-freiheit/ (in German)
- Gebauer, Carlos A.: Laudatory speech for the Ludwig von Mises Institut Deutschland on the occasion of the Hayek Society’s Network Prize, Hamburg, June 21, 2024, https://hayek.de/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/Laudatio-Carlos-A.-Gebauer-an-das-Mises-Institut-2024.pdf (in German)
- Gebauer, Carlos A. (ed.): Die Akte Guérot. Eine juristische Fallstudie zur Wissenschaftsfreiheit, Westend, Neu-Isenburg 2026, ISBN 978-3-98791-383-9 (in German) (reading sample: https://westendverlag.de/media/60/61/21/1783591270/Leseprobe_Gebauer_Akte_Guerot.pdf).
- Gebauer, Carlos A.: column “Make love not law,” eigentümlich frei, author page https://ef-magazin.de/autor/carlos-a-gebauer (in German, accessed November 9, 2026).
- Gebauer, Carlos A.: curriculum vitae on make-love-not-law.com, https://www.make-love-not-law.com/lebenslauf.html (in German, accessed November 9, 2026).
- German National Library (Deutsche Nationalbibliothek), catalog entries for Carlos A. Gebauer (GND 135759668), https://portal.dnb.de/opac.htm?query=per%3DGebauer%2C+Carlos
- Lindenau Prior & Partner eGbR, team page, https://lindenau-prior.de/index.php/team/ (in German, accessed November 9, 2026)
- Friedrich A. von Hayek Society: board, https://hayek.de/vorstand/ (in German, accessed November 9, 2026); program of the Hayek Days 2026, https://hayek.de/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/Programm-Hayek-Tage-2026.pdf (in German)
- Ruthardt, Ralf M.: report on Gebauer’s opening speech at the Hayek Days 2026, hayekforum, July 2026, pp. 7–8, https://hayek.de/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/hayekforum_2026-Juli_20260608_Einzelseiten.pdf (in German)
- Apollo News, December 9, 2025: “Mit Zustimmung Mileis: Petry, Gebauer und Kooths gründen Javier Milei Institut für Deregulierung in Europa,” https://apollo-news.net/mit-zustimmung-mileis-petry-gebauer-und-kooths-grnden-javier-milei-institut-fr-deregulierung-in-europa/ (in German)
- Brussels Signal, December 2025: founding of the Javier Milei Institute, https://brusselssignal.eu/2025/12/ex-afd-mps-found-javier-milei-institute-for-radical-deregulation-in-germany
- Leipziger Internet Zeitung, March 2026: Milei conference in Schkeuditz, https://www.l-iz.de/leben/gesellschaft/2026/03/die-erleuchteten-kettensage-milei-konferenz-schkeuditz-650928 (in German)
- Statista: FDP membership ballot on the euro bailout fund, 2011, https://de.statista.com/statistik/daten/studie/214481/umfrage/fdp-mitgliederentscheid-zum-euro-rettungsschirm (in German)
- Die Welt, September 24, 2017: election result for constituency 115 (Duisburg I), https://www.welt.de/politik/bundestagswahl/article168296888/Ergebnis-und-Wahlsieger-im-Wahlkreis-115.html (in German)
- IT Finanzmagazin, November 11, 2014: book presentation Rettet Europa vor der EU, https://www.it-finanzmagazin.de/finanz%C2%ADbuch-verlag-rettet-europa-vor-der-eu-6143/ (in German)
- Lichtschlag Buchverlag: Warum wir alle reich sein könnten, https://lichtschlag-buchverlag.de/programm/carlos-a-gebauer/warum-wir-alle-reich-sein-koennten (in German)
- Forschung & Lehre: reports on the legal dispute Guérot v. University of Bonn, https://www.forschung-und-lehre.de/recht/gericht-erklaert-kuendigung-von-politologin-guerot-als-rechtmaessig-6384 and https://www.forschung-und-lehre.de/recht/guerot-verliert-vor-bundesarbeitsgericht-entlassung-rechtmaessig-7630 (in German)
- Legal Tribune Online: Cologne Higher Labor Court upholds dismissal, https://www.lto.de/recht/nachrichten/n/10sla28924-lag-koeln-ulrike-guerot-uni-bonn-professorin-kuendigung (in German)
- Wikipedia (German): Carlos Gebauer, https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carlos_Gebauer (introduction, first signatories of the Appeal for Free Spaces of Debate 2020, ESM initiative)
Featured image: Photo: Eckhard Henkel, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0 DE, Bonn 2014, background edited

