Skip to content Skip to footer

Deirdre McCloskey: The Dignity of Ordinary People

Symbolic image: a Dutch merchant's counting-house desk with scales, coins, and a model ship

Until about 1800, the average person in the world earned and consumed the equivalent of two or three dollars a day in today’s prices. Then a development without precedent began, first in Holland, then in England, and soon in other parts of Europe and North America. In the rich countries, real income per person is now about thirty times what it was then, and even the world average has grown roughly twentyfold.

Deirdre McCloskey calls this process the Great Enrichment, and she considers it the most important secular event since the domestication of wheat and horses. In her explanation, laid out in three hefty volumes, trade, colonies, and accumulated capital play only supporting roles. The lead role goes to a change in ideas: people began to allow ordinary men and women to try their luck with a new idea, and they began to respect them for it.

At a glance

  • Life: born September 11, 1942, in Ann Arbor, Michigan
  • Work: economist and economic historian; taught at the University of Chicago (1968 to 1980), the University of Iowa (1980 to 1999), and the University of Illinois at Chicago (2000 to 2015, emerita since then); since 2023 holder of the Isaiah Berlin Chair in Liberal Thought at the Cato Institute in Washington
  • Major works: The Rhetoric of Economics (1985), Crossing (1999), The Bourgeois Virtues (2006), Bourgeois Dignity (2010), Bourgeois Equality (2016), Why Liberalism Works (2019), Leave Me Alone and I’ll Make You Rich (2020, with Art Carden), Equality of Permission (2026)
  • Self-description: Christian classical liberal, former Marxist
  • In one sentence: She explains modern prosperity by the liberty and dignity that came to be granted to ordinary people.

A Path Across Many Fields

McCloskey is the daughter of the Harvard political scientist Robert G. McCloskey, and she studied economics at Harvard. In 1970 she earned her doctorate there under the economic historian Alexander Gerschenkron. Her dissertation took up an old controversy: Did Victorian entrepreneurs fail at the end of the 19th century, when Germany and the United States were catching up? In the case of the iron and steel industry, McCloskey found no evidence for it. Britain had matured industrially earlier, and the latecomers grew faster because they had started later.

She taught for twelve years at the University of Chicago, then for almost two decades at the University of Iowa, and until 2015 at the University of Illinois at Chicago, where she was professor of economics, history, English, and communication at the same time. In The Rhetoric of Economics (1985) she showed that economists persuade their readers with metaphors, comparisons, and stories just as much as with formulas, and that their profession would do well to admit this openly. In 2008, together with the economist Stephen Ziliak, she criticized how often economists confuse statistical significance with economic importance.

In 1995, at the age of 53, McCloskey transitioned from man to woman. Donald became Deirdre, and in Crossing (1999) she described this journey with great candor. With her usual delight in lists, she calls herself a literary, quantitative, postmodern, free-market, progressive Episcopalian, ex-Marxist Midwestern woman who was once a man, and she stresses that she is not a conservative but a Christian classical liberal.

Three Thousand Percent

Since 1800, real income per person has risen by about 3,000 percent. In a talk from 2016, McCloskey translates this into everyday things: food ten times better, health care thirty times better, light a hundred times better.

In Bourgeois Dignity (2010), McCloskey goes through the usual suspects one by one: capital accumulation, foreign trade, colonialism, slavery, geography, institutions. Much of this already existed in Babylon, in China, or in antiquity, without a thirtyfold enrichment following. She considers capital and the legal order necessary, but necessary in roughly the way that labor, liquid water, and the passage of time are necessary. They are not sufficient, and that applies to the left’s explanation from exploitation just as much as to the right’s explanation from diligent saving.

What first made capital productive was new ideas. A village carpenter, a young telegraph operator, or a teenage computer tinkerer from Seattle had an idea, and if it paid off, the capital turned up too. For this McCloskey borrows an image from the writer Matt Ridley: ideas having sex.

Why Holland, Why England

McCloskey dates the beginning to Holland around 1600 and England around 1700, followed by the North American colonies, Scotland, Belgium, northern France, and the Rhineland. She sums up her answer in a single word, liberty. “Liberated people, it turns out, are ingenious,” she said in her 2016 talk. Slaves, serfs, subordinated women, and people stuck in a hierarchy of landlords or bureaucrats are not.

Through a series of historical accidents between the Reformation and the French Revolution, which had nothing to do with any special European virtue, more and more Europeans were freed from such bonds. Opinions changed first. In the Netherlands and then in Britain, the view took hold that merchants, craftsmen, and inventors, whom the nobility and the clergy had looked down on for centuries, were honorable people. In the 19th century came laws that put this view into practice: in Britain, Catholics were granted equal civil rights, slavery in the Caribbean was abolished, and the import of wheat was freed.

McCloskey calls the equality that arose in this process Scottish, after David Hume and Adam Smith. What she means is equality before the law and equality of social dignity. She sharply distinguishes it from the French equality of outcome envisioned by Rousseau or, more recently, Thomas Piketty. In her newer work she speaks of an equality of permission: women may become pilots, occupational licensing blocks no one’s way, and anyone may give it a try.

The Bourgeois Deal

Her formula for this change is an offer that the innovator makes to society. McCloskey calls it the Bourgeois Deal, and in its shortest version it runs like this: “Let me have a go, and I’ll make you rich.” Elsewhere she describes it as a play in three acts: first the inventor keeps the profits of the innovation, then imitators drive those profits down, and in the end everyone is enormously better off. The book title she chose in 2020 together with the economist Art Carden can be read as a summary: Leave Me Alone and I’ll Make You Rich.

For this reason McCloskey avoids the word capitalism as far as she can. It suggests the false idea that the modern world arose from piling up capital, brick on brick, when capital was already being accumulated in ancient Mesopotamia. She prefers to speak of trade-tested betterment and, more recently, of innovism. What she means is an economy in which tens of thousands of new products are tried out every year in American supermarkets alone. Most of them fail, and the few that succeed benefit everyone.

Virtues of the Market

McCloskey’s trilogy begins with The Bourgeois Virtues (2006), a book about ethics. Contempt for the merchant is old, and according to McCloskey it rests on the error that voluntary exchange has no moral worth. McCloskey counters that the market both demands and nurtures the seven traditional virtues of the West: the four classical ones, prudence, temperance, justice, and courage, and the three Christian ones, faith, hope, and love.

In this she builds on Adam Smith, who wrote The Theory of Moral Sentiments alongside The Wealth of Nations. At the same time she opposes an economics that reduces human beings to utility maximizers. She mockingly calls this figure Max U and describes it as a vending machine that responds to prices but never invents anything. Her alternative is called humanomics, an economics in which philosophy, history, and literature keep their place.

As Little Government as Is Wise

For politics, McCloskey draws a brief conclusion in her 2016 talk: policy should be “as little as is prudent.” With Adam Smith, she calls industrial and agricultural policy a presumption of kings and ministers, and she rejects steering from above, whether it comes from the right or from the left.

This is not a refusal of all help for the poor. “We can tax ourselves to give a hand up to the poor, certainly,” she writes. But she adds that 95 percent of the enrichment of the poor since 1800 has come from a more productive economy and only a small remainder from charity. In a 2014 interview with the broadcaster PBS, she said she would rather be taxed for a minimum income than see a minimum wage imposed. There she called herself a motherly libertarian.

In 2022 she ran in Illinois as the Libertarian Party candidate for comptroller, the state’s chief fiscal officer, and received just under 77,000 votes. Since 2023 she has held a chair at the Cato Institute in Washington named after the philosopher Isaiah Berlin. Past the age of eighty she keeps writing; in November 2026 the University of Chicago Press published Equality of Permission.

What friends of liberty can learn from her

The first lesson concerns the causes of prosperity. Anyone who has read McCloskey sees in every room the many inventions that became possible only after 1800, from machine-woven carpets and large windowpanes to central heating. They come from ordinary people who were allowed to go ahead. Every licensing requirement, every tariff, and every regulation that makes new attempts harder therefore holds back a piece of this inventive power.

The second lesson concerns the importance of words. If McCloskey is right, a society’s prosperity also depends on how it talks about entrepreneurs, traders, and tinkerers. Friends of liberty would therefore do well to fight not only over tax rates and laws but also for the standing of those who take risks.

The third lesson is one of tone. McCloskey defends the market on ethical grounds where others point only to efficiency, and she writes with visible joy in good prose. She shows that liberalism in its original meaning, an attitude worthy of a free person, need not be a cold doctrine.

Respect as the Beginning

Deirdre McCloskey has given liberalism a story that begins with people. At its center are the carpenter, the inventor, and the shopkeeper who were allowed to try, while planners and generals move to the margins. Her work puts a question to every society that helps decide its future prosperity: Do we respect those who dare something new, or do we first demand that they ask permission?

Further reading

  • Deirdre Nansen McCloskey: Bourgeois Dignity. Why Economics Can’t Explain the Modern World, University of Chicago Press, Chicago 2010
  • Deirdre Nansen McCloskey: Why Liberalism Works, Yale University Press, New Haven 2019
  • Deirdre Nansen McCloskey and Art Carden: Leave Me Alone and I’ll Make You Rich. How the Bourgeois Deal Enriched the World, University of Chicago Press, Chicago 2020
  • Lynne Kiesling: Deirdre McCloskey, in: The Essential Women of Liberty, Fraser Institute, Vancouver 2022

This article is part of our series on thinkers, doers, and historical figures of liberty.

Sources

  • McCloskey, Donald N.: “Did Victorian Britain Fail?”, in: The Economic History Review 23 (1970), no. 3, pp. 446–459.
  • McCloskey, Donald N.: The Rhetoric of Economics, University of Wisconsin Press, Madison 1985 (2nd edition 1998; first published as an article in Journal of Economic Literature 21, 1983).
  • McCloskey, Deirdre N.: Crossing. A Memoir, University of Chicago Press, Chicago 1999 (new edition 2019 as Crossing. A Transgender Memoir).
  • McCloskey, Deirdre N.: The Bourgeois Virtues. Ethics for an Age of Commerce, University of Chicago Press, Chicago 2006.
  • McCloskey, Deirdre N.: Bourgeois Dignity. Why Economics Can’t Explain the Modern World, University of Chicago Press, Chicago 2010.
  • McCloskey, Deirdre N.: Bourgeois Equality. How Ideas, Not Capital or Institutions, Enriched the World, University of Chicago Press, Chicago 2016.
  • McCloskey, Deirdre N.: “How the Light Really Gets In: The Liberal and Bourgeois Deal”, talk at Hay-on-Wye, April 28, 2016, https://www.deirdremccloskey.com/docs/pdf/Hay-on-Wye_Talk_2016.pdf
  • McCloskey, Deirdre N.: Why Liberalism Works, Yale University Press, New Haven 2019.
  • McCloskey, Deirdre N.; Carden, Art: Leave Me Alone and I’ll Make You Rich. How the Bourgeois Deal Enriched the World, University of Chicago Press, Chicago 2020.
  • McCloskey, Deirdre N.: “Liberalism Caused the Great Enrichment”, version of May 2023 (Cato Institute, project “Exploring the Role of Freedom in Human Progress”), https://bfi.uchicago.edu/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/HOW-ACATO-VERSION-May-23-final.pdf
  • McCloskey, Deirdre N.: Equality of Permission, University of Chicago Press, Chicago 2026.
  • McCloskey, Deirdre N.: biography and list of works, https://w.deirdremccloskey.com/main/bio.php and https://www.deirdremccloskey.com/
  • Solman, Paul; McCloskey, Deirdre: “Why this gender-crossing economist prefers motherly libertarianism to government paternalism”, PBS NewsHour, April 24, 2014, https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/why-this-gender-crossing-economist-prefers-motherly-libertarianism-to-government-paternalism
  • Kiesling, Lynne: “Deirdre McCloskey (1942– )”, in: The Essential Women of Liberty, Fraser Institute, Vancouver 2022, pp. 123–131, https://www.essentialscholars.org/sites/default/files/2023-01/essential-women-of-liberty-ch10-deirdre-mccloskey.pdf
  • Wikipedia (en): Deirdre McCloskey, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deirdre_McCloskey (career dates, starting point)
  • University of Chicago Press: publisher’s page for Crossing. A Transgender Memoir, https://www.press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/C/bo43988326.html
  • RePEc/IDEAS: Equality of Permission, University of Chicago Press, November 2026, https://ideas.repec.org/b/ucp/bkecon/9780226852393.html
  • Ballotpedia: Deirdre McCloskey and Illinois state executive official elections 2022, https://ballotpedia.org/Deirdre_McCloskey
  • Books-A-Million: No One’s In Charge (Cato Institute, announced for December 8, 2026), https://www.booksamillion.com/p/9781969284212

Featured image: Symbolic image for Deirdre McCloskey (AI)

Leave a Comment

Popular:

Tip: press / or Ctrl+K to open search from any page.