In February 1849, the Journal des Économistes, the leading journal of the liberal economists in Paris, printed an essay with the sober title “De la production de la sécurité,” on the production of security. The editors prefaced it with a note one rarely finds in a scholarly journal: although the article might appear utopian in its conclusions, they considered it right to publish it. It had become useful, they wrote, to determine precisely where the intervention of the authorities ceases to be protective and begins to become tyrannical.
The author was not yet thirty years old, and his name was Gustave de Molinari. His thesis was that the protection of person and property is a service like any other and is therefore better provided by competing suppliers than by a monopoly. With this he went one step further than his friends, who wanted to limit the state to the role of a night watchman, and he raised a question that has never gone away since.
At a glance
- Life: March 3, 1819, in Liège to January 28, 1912, in Adinkerke (Belgium)
- Work: journalist and economist in Paris, professor in Brussels, editor in chief of the Journal des Débats (1871 to 1876) and of the Journal des Économistes (1881 to 1909)
- Major works: “De la production de la sécurité” (1849), Les Soirées de la rue Saint-Lazare (1849), Cours d’économie politique (1855), L’Évolution économique du dix-neuvième siècle (1880), Grandeur et décadence de la guerre (1898), Ultima Verba (1911)
- In one sentence: He consistently applied the principle of free competition to the protection of life and property as well.
From Doctor’s Son in Liège to Free Trader in Paris
Molinari was born in 1819 in Liège, which at the time belonged to the United Kingdom of the Netherlands. His father was a physician and had served as an officer in Napoleon’s army. In 1840, at the age of 21, the son moved to Paris to work as a journalist, and in 1842 he joined the Société d’économie politique, the discussion circle of the liberal economists.
There he found his intellectual home. He became deputy secretary of the Association pour la liberté des échanges, the French free trade association, and contributed to its journal Le Libre-Échange, edited by Frédéric Bastiat. When the February Revolution of 1848 gave a boost to the socialist currents, he and Charles Coquelin tried to reach ordinary people with the street paper Jacques Bonhomme. The attempt failed, but it shows that Molinari wanted his ideas to reach beyond the circle of scholars.
Security as a Commodity
The 1849 essay begins with a principle that any free trader would have signed. In all things, the consumer should be free to choose, and his interest must take precedence over that of the producer. Molinari drew from this a conclusion from which his colleagues shrank: “Que la production de la sécurité doit, dans l’intérêt des consommateurs de cette denrée immatérielle, demeurer soumise à la loi de la libre concurrence.” In English, this means that the production of security must, in the interest of the consumers of this intangible commodity, remain subject to the law of free competition.
He sketched what this might look like in the later sections. A producer of security would charge his customers a regular premium, graded according to their situation, their activities, and the value of their property, and would pay compensation in the event of loss. Such a supplier resembles an insurer. What matters to Molinari is the buyer’s freedom to obtain security wherever it seems best to him. Behind this lies the ordinary logic of competition: a supplier who protects poorly or charges too much loses his customers, while a monopolist can do both without fearing the consequences.
The idea has a simple consistency. Anyone who believes that competition in bread, cloth, and transport produces better and cheaper services must explain why it should be different for the most important good of all. Molinari found no such explanation and drew the conclusion.
Evenings on the Rue Saint-Lazare
The same year saw the publication of Les Soirées de la rue Saint-Lazare, subtitled “conversations on economic laws and defense of property.” The title recalls the street where Molinari met regularly with liberal friends between 1844 and early 1848, among them Bastiat, Joseph Garnier, Alcide Fonteyraud, and Coquelin. In the evening conversations, a conservative who defends protective tariffs and state monopolies, a socialist, and an economist argue with one another.
The book defends property on two fronts: against the socialists, who wanted to abolish it, and against the conservatives, who defended it poorly with privileges and tariffs. In the eleventh soirée, the economist presents the idea that police and defense, too, could be provided voluntarily through the market. The dialogue form keeps the book readable to this day, because every opposing position gets its say before it is answered.
Disagreement Among Friends
In the fall of 1849, the Société d’économie politique devoted a session to Molinari’s theses, and the minutes appeared in the Journal des Économistes of October 15. Murray Rothbard later summarized the reactions. Coquelin argued that justice needs a supreme authority, and Bastiat declared that justice and security can be guaranteed only by force. Charles Dunoyer alone engaged with the arguments and came to the verdict that Molinari had been carried away by the “illusions of logic.”
No break followed. In 1852 and 1853, Molinari wrote articles for the Paris circle’s Dictionnaire de l’économie politique, and decades later he took over the very journal that had printed the critical debate. The French liberals could disagree with a friend without casting him out. In his 1977 preface to the English translation, Rothbard called the essay “the first presentation anywhere in human history” of what is now called anarcho-capitalism or free-market anarchism, and added that Molinari would probably have had trouble with that name.
Brussels, Antwerp, and Back to Paris
After Louis Napoléon’s coup d’état in December 1851, Molinari left France and went to Belgium. In Brussels he taught political economy at the Musée royal de l’industrie, and he also taught at the Institut supérieur de commerce in Antwerp. In 1855 he founded the journal L’Économiste belge, and the same year saw the publication of his Cours d’économie politique, in which, according to Dries Van Thielen, he continued to advocate private suppliers of security.
In his Belgian journal he struck a more moderate tone. Van Thielen attributes this to consideration for an audience whose liberal elite distrusted radical ideas, and points to a letter from Molinari to Pierre-Joseph Proudhon of February 1859, in which he asked for a contribution that would suit the moderate tone of his readers. That same year he lost an election in Belgium.
In the 1860s he returned to Paris and worked for the Journal des Débats, which he ran as editor in chief from 1871 to 1876. In 1881 he succeeded the late Joseph Garnier at the head of the Journal des Économistes and ran it until 1909, that is, until he was about ninety years old. He then handed it over to Yves Guyot.
Against Tariffs, Slavery, and War
Anyone who knows Molinari only as a theorist of private protection agencies overlooks most of his work. As early as 1846, one of his writings bore the subtitle L’organisation de la liberté industrielle et l’abolition de l’esclavage, explicitly linking the freedom of labor with the abolition of slavery. Throughout his life he wrote against protective tariffs, imperialism, militarism, and socialism.
In broad historical works such as L’Évolution économique du dix-neuvième siècle (1880) and L’Évolution politique et la révolution (1884), he described the rise of the free industrial society as a response to older orders based on class barriers and exploitation. He regarded war as an early driver of social development that had become harmful over time and could be replaced by peaceful economic competition. Consistently, he looked for alliances and systems of collective defense that were meant to end the state of war, because war, as he argued, undermined the liberty of the individual. Grandeur et décadence de la guerre of 1898 sums up these reflections. His last book, Ultima Verba, appeared in 1911, when he was over ninety.
Did He Stick to His Idea?
Whether Molinari moved away from competition among security providers in his old age is still debated today. In Les Lois naturelles de l’économie politique (1887), Rothbard still saw a firm supporter of private police companies competing with one another, but in the Esquisse de l’organisation politique et économique de la société future (1899) a partial retreat to a single private protection company.
More recent research paints a different picture. In a 2019 lecture, the historian David M. Hart examined fifteen of Molinari’s texts on this question and concluded that Rothbard’s assumption of a softening had to be revised. Dries Van Thielen has examined letters and memoirs on the subject. In an 1885 letter to Arthur Mangin, Molinari wrote, in substance, that he was a radical liberal, if one liked, but not an anarchist. The journalist Charles Benoist noted in a portrait that for Molinari the state had certainly been an evil, but not a necessary one. On this reading, Molinari rejected the label but not the substance.
What friends of liberty can learn from him
The first lesson concerns method. Molinari took a principle that all the liberals of his time shared and tested whether it also holds where it is usually not applied. This willingness to think a conviction through to the end, even when one’s friends disagree, is rare and valuable.
The second lesson concerns perspective. Molinari looked at security from the point of view of the person who pays for it and needs it, and asked which order serves that person best. Anyone who talks about police, courts, or defense today can benefit from this perspective, no matter how far he wants to follow Molinari. Murray Rothbard and Hans-Hermann Hoppe took up his question in the 20th century, and Benjamin Tucker and his circle around the journal Liberty were already reading him during his lifetime.
The third lesson is patience. Molinari wrote for free trade and peace for seven decades, in Brussels after leaving Paris as well as later at the head of a respected Paris journal, and throughout he held to his principles.
The Question of 1849
Gustave de Molinari died on January 28, 1912, in Adinkerke on the Belgian coast and was buried in the Père-Lachaise cemetery in Paris, the city where he had worked for decades. With him, the classical liberal movement in France lost one of its defining voices, and only a few companions such as Yves Guyot and Frédéric Passy remained.
His question, however, has remained. Why should the protection of our liberty, of all things, be left to a supplier whom no one can vote out when he does his job poorly? Molinari gave a bold answer. One need not adopt it in every detail to see that he placed the burden of proof where it belongs: on those who demand a monopoly.
Further reading
- Gustave de Molinari: “De la production de la sécurité,” Journal des Économistes 22 (1849), pp. 277–290; in English: The Production of Security, translated by J. Huston McCulloch, with a preface by Murray N. Rothbard, Center for Libertarian Studies, New York 1977
- Gustave de Molinari: Les Soirées de la rue Saint-Lazare. Entretiens sur les lois économiques et défense de la propriété, Paris 1849
- David M. Hart: “Gustave de Molinari and the Anti-Statist Liberal Tradition,” Journal of Libertarian Studies (1981/82)
This article is part of our series on thinkers, doers, and historical figures of liberty.
Sources
- Molinari, Gustave de: “De la production de la sécurité,” Journal des Économistes 22 (February 1849), pp. 277–290, Wikisource: https://fr.wikisource.org/wiki/De_la_production_de_la_s%C3%A9curit%C3%A9
- Molinari, Gustave de: The Production of Security, translated by J. Huston McCulloch, Occasional Papers Series #2, Center for Libertarian Studies, New York 1977, https://mises.org/library/book/production-security
- Molinari, Gustave de: Les Soirées de la rue Saint-Lazare. Entretiens sur les lois économiques et défense de la propriété, Paris 1849, https://oll.libertyfund.org/titles/molinari-les-soirees-de-la-rue-saint-lazare-1849
- Molinari, Gustave de: Études économiques. L’organisation de la liberté industrielle et l’abolition de l’esclavage, Paris 1846.
- Molinari, Gustave de: Cours d’économie politique, Brussels 1855 (2nd ed. 1863).
- Molinari, Gustave de: L’Évolution économique du dix-neuvième siècle, Paris 1880; L’Évolution politique et la révolution, Paris 1884.
- Molinari, Gustave de: Les Lois naturelles de l’économie politique, Paris 1887.
- Molinari, Gustave de: Grandeur et décadence de la guerre, Paris 1898.
- Molinari, Gustave de: Esquisse de l’organisation politique et économique de la société future, Paris 1899.
- Molinari, Gustave de: Ultima Verba. Mon dernier ouvrage, Paris 1911.
- Rothbard, Murray N.: Preface (1977) to Molinari, The Production of Security, https://praxeology.net/MR-GM-PS.htm
- Hart, David M.: Life and Works of Gustave de Molinari, Econlib, https://www.econlib.org/library/Molinari/MolinariBio.html
- Hart, David M.: “Gustave de Molinari and the Anti-Statist Liberal Tradition,” Journal of Libertarian Studies (1981/82)
- Van Thielen, Dries: Was Gustave de Molinari an Anarchist until the Very End?, Mises Wire, December 9, 2020, https://mises.org/mises-wire/was-gustave-de-molinari-anarchist-until-very-end
- History of Economic Thought Website: Gustave de Molinari, https://hetwebsite.net/het/profiles/molinari.htm
- Online Library of Liberty: Molinari defends the right to property against the socialists … and the conservatives (1849), https://oll.libertyfund.org/quotes/molinari-defends-the-right-to-property-against-the-socialists-who-want-to-overthrow-it-and-the-conservatives-who-defend-it-poorly-1849
- Institut Coppet: Best of Molinari, https://www.institutcoppet.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/Best-of-Molinari-Gustave-de-Molinari.pdf
- Wikipédia (fr): Gustave de Molinari, https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gustave_de_Molinari (in French; dates, list of works)
- Wikipedia (en): Gustave de Molinari, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gustave_de_Molinari (reception)

