Skip to content Skip to footer

Tertullian: The Man Who First Spoke of Religious Freedom

Tertullian

In the year 212, the proconsul Scapula once again had Christians persecuted in the province of Africa. A writer from Carthage answered him with a short open letter. Instead of pleading for mercy for his fellow believers, he reminded the governor of a right that belongs to every human being by nature: to worship what he himself considers right.

The author was Tertullian, and he was not a gentle man. He forbade Christians to attend the theater, considered the soldier’s life hardly compatible with the faith, and later joined a particularly strict movement. Yet it was this uncompromising Christian who wrote sentences that are still quoted today whenever the point is that the state has no authority over conscience.

At a glance

  • Life: born around 160 in Carthage, died after 220, probably there as well (exact dates unknown)
  • Work: Christian writer and apologist, trained in rhetoric and probably also in law, the first theological writer in the Latin language
  • Major works: Apologeticum (197), Ad Scapulam (212), De praescriptione haereticorum, De spectaculis, De corona (211), Adversus Praxean
  • In one sentence: As far as we know, he was the first to speak of freedom of religion, and he argued that forced worship is worthless and that every human being has a natural right to choose his faith.

An Educated African in the Service of a Forbidden Cause

Tertullian came from Carthage, the great port city in what is now Tunisia, received a thorough education in rhetoric, and was familiar with Roman law. According to a late account by the Church Father Jerome, he was the son of an army officer and became a priest; whether this is true is disputed among scholars. What is certain is that he turned to Christianity as an adult, by the year 197 at the latest.

From then on he wrote tirelessly: against pagan critics, against Christian groups he regarded as false teachers, and about questions of everyday life. In his treatise against Praxeas he developed the formula of three persons and one substance, which became authoritative for Latin theology.

After 206 he turned to the so-called New Prophecy, also known as Montanism after its founder Montanus. The movement came from Asia Minor, appealed to ecstatic prophecies, demanded stricter fasting, prohibited second marriages, and called on believers to stand firm under persecution rather than flee. Whether Tertullian formally broke with the church in Carthage as a result is still disputed. Two centuries later, Augustine still knew of a small group that called itself Tertullianists after him.

Condemned for a Name

Christians in the Roman Empire faced a peculiar legal situation. Since the Emperor Trajan, the rule he had communicated to the governor Pliny applied: the authorities were not to seek out Christians on their own initiative, but anyone who was accused and convicted was to be punished. In practice, a person counted as convicted if he confessed to the name “Christian” and refused to offer sacrifice.

Against this practice Tertullian wrote his Apologeticum in 197, a defense addressed to the governors of the empire. He attacked Trajan’s rule with a lawyer’s precision. His objection, in essence, was that the rule forbids seeking out Christians as though they were innocent and commands punishing them as though they were guilty. In trials of Christians, he writes, what is tried is the confession of the name, not an examination of any crime: confessio nominis, non examinatio criminis.

Here Tertullian touches on a principle that the rule of law today takes for granted: what is punished is an act, not a conviction or membership in a group. He did not formulate it as a general legal rule, but he did use it as a standard against which he measured Rome’s own law.

Freedom of Religion Gets a Name

Chapter 24 of the Apologeticum contains the sentence for which Tertullian is known to this day. The Romans accused the Christians of disregarding the gods. Tertullian turns the accusation around: “See whether this, too, does not add to the charge of irreligion: to take away freedom of religion and to forbid the choice of a deity, so that I may not worship whom I wish but must worship whom I do not wish. No one wants to be worshiped by someone unwilling, not even a human being.” (Apologeticum 24.6, our own translation)

The Latin phrase is libertas religionis. The American patristics scholar Robert Louis Wilken considers Tertullian the first person in the history of the West to have spoken of “religious freedom.” The argument behind it is simple: worship performed under coercion is worthless, for even a human being sets no value on being worshiped by someone unwilling, let alone a god. Whoever forces others into a religion therefore misses the very thing that makes religion what it is.

A Right That Belongs to Everyone

Fifteen years later, in the letter to Scapula, the idea becomes more fundamental. There we read: “It is a fundamental human right, a privilege of nature, that every man should worship according to his own convictions: one man’s religion neither harms nor helps another man. It is assuredly no part of religion to compel religion, to which free-will and not force should lead us, the sacrificial victims even being required of a willing mind.” (Ad Scapulam 2, trans. S. Thelwall)

Three things stand out in this passage. Tertullian speaks of every man (in the Latin, unicuique, “to each one”) and not only of Christians; the right thus applies also to the worshipers of the gods, whom he himself regarded as demons (Apologeticum 23). He grounds it in human nature and not in a permission granted by the authorities. And he gives a reason why the state can stay out of the matter: one person’s faith does no harm to another. Anyone who speaks today of the harm principle, the rule that coercion is justified only to prevent harm to others, will find a very early relative here.

Loyal to the Emperor, but Not at Any Price

Tertullian was no rebel. In the Apologeticum he stresses that Christians prayed for the welfare of the emperors, and he points out that they paid their taxes more conscientiously than many others. In the letter to Scapula he writes: “A Christian is enemy to none, least of all to the Emperor of Rome.” (Ad Scapulam 2, trans. S. Thelwall) The line was drawn at sacrifice. He was willing to honor the emperor but not to worship him, and his entire argument hinges on this distinction between what is due to the state and what is not.

This should not be reinterpreted as a modern separation of church and state. Tertullian held that the emperor was appointed by God and even wrote that the emperor was more “ours” than the pagans’ (Apologeticum 33.1). He demanded that a pagan government leave a minority in peace, and he supplied reasons for this that reach beyond the occasion that prompted them.

He describes the Christian community as a corporate body, united by a common confession, a common rule of life, and a common hope. Its treasury, he says, is filled by small gifts that each member makes once a month, if he wishes and if he can: “For there is no compulsion; all is voluntary.” (Apologeticum 39, trans. S. Thelwall) This money, he writes, feeds and buries the needy, provides for orphaned children and elderly household servants, and supports fellow believers in the mines and in prison. Here Tertullian portrays a voluntary community that organizes its own care, without a mandate from the state and without state money.

A Man of Strict Rules

A complete picture must include the fact that Tertullian was a rigorist, a champion of rules without exceptions. In De spectaculis he forbade Christians to attend the circus, the theater, and the arena. In De corona, in 211, he defended a soldier who had refused to wear the festive wreath, and he called military service as such into question. In his Montanist period he even rejected fleeing from persecution. His liberty applied to conscience in relation to the state, not to conduct within the community, where he was generous with rules.

Toward Christian groups he considered heretics he was unyielding. This is the context of his famous question: “What indeed has Athens to do with Jerusalem?” (De praescriptione haereticorum 7.9) It is aimed at a theology that made philosophical schools the measure of faith. Even so, he was no enemy of reason. He argued like a trained lawyer; the sentence “I believe because it is absurd,” often attributed to him, does not appear in his writings in that form. It is a sharpened version from later centuries, derived from a passage on the death and resurrection of Christ in De carne Christi.

Some of his statements about women, by contrast, leave no room for doubt: in De cultu feminarum, with Eve in mind, he addresses woman as “the devil’s gateway,” a harshness that even sympathetic readers should not pass over.

Inventor or First Witness?

So was Tertullian the inventor of religious freedom? The title promises more than can be proven. As far as we know today, the phrase libertas religionis first appears in his work, and he supported it with arguments that recur later. Lactantius, a Latin Christian of the early fourth century, wrote in his Divine Institutes, in essence, that nothing is so much a matter of free will as religion, and that it must be defended by dying, not by killing. Thomas Jefferson owned an edition of the Apologeticum and marked the passage on religious freedom in it, though Wilken doubts that it directly influenced Jefferson’s wording. John Locke’s A Letter Concerning Toleration of 1689 revolves around the same idea, that coerced faith counts for nothing before God.

Tertullian did not invent religious freedom in the sense of an institution. There was no court to enforce his argument, and the persecutions did not stop because of his letter. What he created was the language in which the cause could be expressed, and a justification that does not depend on the goodwill of those in power. That makes him the first witness to religious freedom rather than its inventor.

What Friends of Liberty Find in Him

The simplest insight first: a coerced confession is worthless, and a state that compels belief gets hypocrisy at best. This observation reaches beyond religion to any conviction that a government might wish to prescribe to its citizens.

The second concerns criminal law. Anyone punished merely for belonging to something, and not for a deed, suffers persecution under the guise of law. Tertullian made this case as the advocate of a despised minority, and many a right of liberty was later won out of the situation of persecuted minorities.

The third is the image of the voluntary community. People who care for their poor without a mandate from the state and contribute according to their own means are described by him, without any pathos, as the normal case.

A Sentence That Outlived Its Author

Tertullian wrote that the blood of Christians is a seed: the more they are mown down, the more numerous they become. He meant the growth of his church, but the sentence fits his arguments as well. The letter to Scapula had no discernible effect, while the idea that every human being may choose for himself whom he worships, and that one person’s religion does no harm to another, has survived the centuries. Tertullian was not a libertarian. But anyone who defends freedom of conscience today stands on ground that this stern man from Carthage helped to lay.

Further reading

  • Tertullian: Apologeticum. Verteidigung des Christentums, Latin and German, ed. and translated by Carl Becker, Kösel, Munich 1952 (in German)
  • Tertullian: An Scapula, translated by Heinrich Kellner, in: Tertullian, Apologetische, dogmatische und montanistische Schriften, Bibliothek der Kirchenväter vol. 24, Kösel, Kempten and Munich 1915 (in German)
  • Robert Louis Wilken: Liberty in the Things of God. The Christian Origins of Religious Freedom, Yale University Press, New Haven 2019
  • Timothy D. Barnes: Tertullian. A Historical and Literary Study, Clarendon Press, Oxford 1971, 2nd edition 1985

This article is part of our series on thinkers, doers, and historical figures of liberty.

Sources

  • Tertullian: Apologeticum (197), English translation by S. Thelwall (Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 3), https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/0301.htm; Latin text: The Latin Library, https://www.thelatinlibrary.com/tertullian/tertullian.apol.shtml; German: Apologeticum. Verteidigung des Christentums, Latin/German, ed. and trans. by Carl Becker, Kösel, Munich 1952 (in German).
  • Tertullian: Ad Scapulam (212), English translation by S. Thelwall (Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 3), https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/0305.htm; Latin text: https://www.tertullian.org/latin/ad_scapulam.htm; German: An Scapula, trans. by K. A. Heinrich Kellner, in: Tertullian, Apologetische, dogmatische und montanistische Schriften, Bibliothek der Kirchenväter, 1st series, vol. 24, Kösel, Kempten and Munich 1915 (in German), https://bkv.unifr.ch/works/cpl-24/versions/an-scapula-bkv
  • Tertullian: De praescriptione haereticorum, Latin text: https://www.tertullian.org/latin/de_praescriptione_haereticorum.htm
  • Tertullian: De carne Christi and De cultu feminarum, Latin texts: https://www.thelatinlibrary.com/tertullian.html
  • Lactantius: Divinae institutiones, book 5, English translation by William Fletcher (Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 7), https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/07015.htm
  • Locke, John: Ein Brief über Toleranz, Meiner, Hamburg 1996 (first published 1689) (in German).
  • Barnes, Timothy D.: Tertullian. A Historical and Literary Study, Clarendon Press, Oxford 1971, 2nd ed. 1985.
  • Wilken, Robert Louis: Liberty in the Things of God. The Christian Origins of Religious Freedom, Yale University Press, New Haven 2019.
  • Chapman, John: article “Tertullian,” Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 14, New York 1912, https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14520c.htm
  • Movsesian, Mark L.: review of Wilken, Liberty in the Things of God, The University Bookman, August 11, 2019, https://kirkcenter.org/reviews/tertullian-and-the-rise-of-religious-freedom/
  • Eire, Carlos: “Forged in Fire,” First Things, November 2019, https://www.firstthings.com/article/2019/11/forged-in-fire
  • Harrison, Peter: “I Believe Because it is Absurd”: The Enlightenment Invention of Tertullian’s Credo, in: Church History 86 (2017), https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/church-history/article/abs/i-believe-because-it-is-absurd-the-enlightenment-invention-of-tertullians-credo/69340C3AF8366E79BCF3BDD804DED82E
  • Sider, Robert D.: Credo quia absurdum?, https://tertullian.org/articles/sider_credo.htm
  • Kaye, John: Ecclesiastical History of the Second and Third Centuries, 1845, ch. 1, https://tertullian.org/articles/kaye/kaye01.htm
  • Themelios: “Why were the Montanists condemned?”, https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/themelios/article/why-were-the-montanists-condemned/
  • tertullian.org: The Montanists, https://tertullian.org/montanism.htm

Featured image: Tertullian (AI illustration, free interpretation)

Leave a Comment

Popular:

Tip: press / or Ctrl+K to open search from any page.