Skip to content Skip to footer

Modern Enlightenment

A burning candle and a smartphone on a table in front of a shelf of old books

The Enlightenment is regarded as one of the most significant intellectual revolutions in human history. Yet what remains of it is fiercely contested to this day. While collectivists and advocates of the state celebrate the Enlightenment as the birth of democratic institutions and of reason embodied in the state, libertarians see in it above all one thing: the fundamental discovery of the dignity and autonomy of the individual. This article shows why the libertarian tradition can rightly claim to be a legitimate heir of the Enlightenment, and why a modern Enlightenment is more urgent today than ever.


1. What was the Enlightenment, and who does it belong to?

“Have courage to use your own understanding!” With this motto, Immanuel Kant summed up the essence of the Enlightenment in 1784.1 The idea is as simple as it is revolutionary: human beings should no longer need a guardian. Neither church nor king, neither tradition nor the authorities should determine how they think and act. The Enlightenment was a liberation: reason instead of dogma, the individual instead of the collective, liberty instead of submission.

Yet this legacy has been fought over for centuries. On one side stand those who see in the Enlightenment the justification for the modern state: rational, orderly, paternalistically caring. Jean-Jacques Rousseau with his “general will,” later Hegel with his deification of the state, and finally Marx with collective emancipation through revolution: they all lay claim to the legacy of the Enlightenment.2 On the other side stand thinkers such as John Locke, Adam Smith, Frédéric Bastiat, Herbert Spencer, and Friedrich August von Hayek, for whom the Enlightenment meant: The state is the problem, not the solution.

Both sides appeal to reason. Both appeal to liberty. But they mean something fundamentally different by it.

2. The collectivist narrative: the state as the embodiment of reason

The collectivist reading of the Enlightenment is the dominant one today. It assumes that the individual alone is too weak, too irrational, and too self-interested to secure the common good. What is needed, so the conviction goes, is a higher authority, the state, that tames conflicting interests, evens out inequalities, and ensures the collective welfare.

This narrative sounds plausible. It has aesthetic appeal: you are not fighting for yourself but for “society,” for “social justice,” for “the common good.” It appeals to moral intuitions, and it is taken for granted in schools, the media, and politics. Anyone who questions state intervention on principle is quickly seen as heartless, as an egoist, as someone who “leaves the weak in the lurch.”

But history paints a different picture.

3. What history teaches: state power as an instrument of oppression

No honest look at the last two hundred years can get around one fact: in human history, the state has far more often been a tool of oppression than a guarantor of liberty. The greatest mass murders of the 20th century were not committed by free markets or anarchic individuals. They were committed by states that explicitly invoked collectivist ideologies.3

The Gulag, the Holodomor, the Killing Fields of Cambodia, Mao’s Great Leap Forward, the persecutions in National Socialist Germany: all these crimes were committed by apparatuses that claimed to act in the name of the collective, the nation, the class, or the race. The individual counted for nothing. The system counted for everything.

It would be wrong to equate every state with totalitarian regimes. But it would be just as wrong to ignore the warning: state power, unchecked and unrestrained, tends to expand itself and to oppress those who do not share it. Friedrich August von Hayek called it the “road to serfdom”: liberty loses ground not through sudden tyranny but through the gradual expansion of the state’s responsibilities.4

Anyone who thinks this is exaggerated might ask: how many areas of life are left today in which the state does not intervene?

4. The Basic Law: a collection of rights against the state

It is telling that even Germany’s Basic Law, the country’s constitution, which grew out of the immediate experience of totalitarian rule, has at its core rights that protect citizens against the state. Article 1, paragraph 1 reads: “Human dignity shall be inviolable.” Article 2 guarantees the right to the free development of one’s personality. Article 10 protects the privacy of correspondence and telecommunications. Article 13 declares the home inviolable.5

None of these rights are directed against one’s neighbor, employer, or a company. They are directed against the state itself. The Basic Law does not trust the state blindly; it binds it. It sets limits for it. It proceeds from the unspoken assumption that state power is a danger that must be contained.

This basic principle is deeply libertarian. And yet it is increasingly hollowed out in everyday politics: by laws that restrict freedom of speech, by surveillance powers that are expanded, by regulations that reach deep into private and economic life, always in the name of the good, of protecting, of administering.6

5. Libertarians as heirs of the Enlightenment

The libertarian tradition, whether one calls it that or not, is profoundly a child of the Enlightenment. It starts with the individual: the thinking, feeling, deciding human being who wants to, and may, shape his life according to his own ideas. It credits the individual with what collectivist theories deny: responsibility, judgment, self-organization.

Frédéric Bastiat put it with inimitable clarity: “The State is the great fiction by which everyone endeavors to live at the expense of everyone else.”7 Lysander Spooner raised the question of whether a constitution can have any moral authority at all over people who never expressly consented to it.8 Hayek showed that no central body can ever possess the knowledge contained in millions of individual decisions, and that the attempt to replace it inevitably leads to inefficiency and a loss of liberty.9

This is not a romanticization of the market. It is epistemology. And it is humility: the insight that no state, no party, no planner can shape another person’s life better than that person can.

6. The modern Enlightenment: what is at stake today

The Enlightenment was never a finished project. It was a promise. And that promise is in danger today, not through open tyranny but through the creeping normalization of control, paternalism, and intellectual conformity.

When platforms are pushed under the European Union’s Digital Services Act to remove unwelcome opinions, that is not a protective measure; it is censorship with a regulatory veneer. When citizens censor themselves because they fear the consequences, that is not voluntary restraint; it is the internalization of oppression.10 When schools, the media, and institutions treat certain questions as “settled” or “dangerous,” the Enlightenment has broken its promise.

A modern Enlightenment would have to begin where Kant demanded: with thinking for oneself. It would have to find the courage to regard state power not as self-evident but as something that requires justification. It would have to ask: Who profits from this regulation? Who pays? Who decides, and by what right?

Libertarian thinking does not offer simple answers. But it asks the right questions.

7. Objections and counterarguments

Of course there are weighty objections to the libertarian position. The most important one: without state intervention, imbalances of power arise and become entrenched. Monopolies form, social security is lacking, the weak lose out to the strong. It is a serious concern that should not simply be dismissed.

The libertarian answer is twofold. First, many of the monopolies we know today are not the result of free markets; they are the result of state privileges, licenses, and protection of cartels. The state that is supposed to fight monopolies is often the same one that created them.11 Second, voluntary solidarity, mutual insurance associations, charitable networks, and decentralized structures of mutual aid have proven throughout history that security in society does not necessarily have to mean security provided by the state.12

This does not mean that every state intervention is wrong per se. It means: the burden of proof lies with the state. It must justify why it intervenes, not the citizen why he wishes to be free.

8. Conclusion: liberty cannot be taken for granted

Liberty is the natural condition of human beings, philosophically speaking. Historically speaking, it is the exception. Most people who have ever lived lived under domination, coercion, and oppression. The brief periods in which individual liberty flourished were always bought with intellectual clarity, moral courage, and institutional limits on power.

Libertarians are therefore neither nostalgics nor utopians. They are, in the best sense, men and women of the Enlightenment: skeptical of claims to power, confident in the abilities of the individual, vigilant against the creeping loss of liberty.

The path to freedom begins where courage begins: to ask questions that are uncomfortable. To question things that are taken for granted. And to recognize that a state that wants to regulate everything ends up protecting nothing, because it has declared liberty itself its enemy.

Sapere aude. Have courage to use your own understanding.


Notes and sources

1 Immanuel Kant: Beantwortung der Frage: Was ist Aufklärung? (English: An Answer to the Question: What Is Enlightenment?). In: Berlinische Monatsschrift, December 1784, pp. 481–494 (in German).

2 See Jean-Jacques Rousseau: Du Contrat Social (1762; English: The Social Contract); Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel: Grundlinien der Philosophie des Rechts (1820; English: Elements of the Philosophy of Right); Karl Marx / Friedrich Engels: Manifest der Kommunistischen Partei (1848; English: The Communist Manifesto).

3 R. J. Rummel: Death by Government. Transaction Publishers, New Brunswick 1994. There Rummel estimated the number of civilians killed by governments between 1900 and 1987 at around 169 million; he later raised his estimate to around 262 million.

4 Friedrich August von Hayek: The Road to Serfdom. University of Chicago Press, Chicago 1944. German edition: Der Weg zur Knechtschaft. Olzog Verlag, Munich 2003.

5 Basic Law for the Federal Republic of Germany (Grundgesetz) of May 23, 1949 (Federal Law Gazette, BGBl., p. 1), Articles 1, 2, 10, and 13.

6 See, for example, Federal Constitutional Court of Germany, judgment of May 19, 2020, 1 BvR 2835/17 (BND Act): the foreign surveillance conducted by the Federal Intelligence Service (BND, Germany’s foreign intelligence agency) violated, in essential parts, the privacy of telecommunications and the freedom of the press. The constitutional complaint was supported by, among others, the Gesellschaft für Freiheitsrechte (GFF), a German civil liberties organization.

7 Frédéric Bastiat: L’État. In: Journal des Débats, September 25, 1848. English wording as in Liberty Fund’s Online Library of Liberty, The Best of Bastiat (2013).

8 Lysander Spooner: No Treason: The Constitution of No Authority (1867/1870). Reprint: Ludwig von Mises Institute, Auburn 2008.

9 Friedrich August von Hayek: The Use of Knowledge in Society. In: American Economic Review, 35 (4), 1945, pp. 519–530.

10 See Institut für Demoskopie Allensbach / Media Tenor: Freiheitsindex 2023 (in German): only 40 percent of Germans believe one can express one’s political opinion freely, while 44 percent think it is better to be careful, the lowest value since the question was first asked in 1953; and Emily Ekins: Poll: 62% of Americans Say They Have Political Views They’re Afraid to Share, Cato Institute / YouGov, 2020.

11 See Gabriel Kolko: The Triumph of Conservatism. Free Press, New York 1963. Kolko, himself a historian of the left, showed that large corporations often actively supported state regulation in order to eliminate competition.

12 David Beito: From Mutual Aid to the Welfare State: Fraternal Societies and Social Services, 1890–1967. University of North Carolina Press, Chapel Hill 2000.

Featured image: Symbolic image (AI illustration)

Leave a Comment

Popular:

Tip: press / or Ctrl+K to open search from any page.