Summary
The word “Nazi” is the cheapest insult in the German-speaking world: easily affordable, requiring no mental effort, available at any time. It once referred to members of one of the most murderous political movements in history. Today it refers to: everyone. Conservatives. Liberals. Libertarians. Dog owners who let their dog run off the leash. The neighbor who hums the national anthem too loudly. The inflation of the term has not made it stronger; it has hollowed it out. This article examines what happens to a word when it becomes an all-purpose weapon, and why libertarians in particular, of all people the most consistent opponents of state power, find themselves the favorite target of this bargain-bin insult.
The Threepenny Opera of Political Discourse
Bertolt Brecht wrote The Threepenny Opera as an opera for everyone. An opera meant to lure even beggars into the theater. No long run-up, no educated middle class required: in you go, Mack the Knife, done. The genius of the format lay in its accessibility.
The same principle underlies the modern threepenny insult. The word “Nazi” is the threepenny opera of political dispute: open to everyone, built for the masses, usable without any prior knowledge. You do not need an argument. You do not need any knowledge of history. You do not even need anger; a mild unease will do. One click, two syllables, and you have won the debate. Or at least ended it.
What Brecht certainly did not intend: that his concept of a democratized opera would one day be applied to the coarsening of political vocabulary.
What the Word Once Meant
“Nazi” is the colloquial short form of “National Socialist,” a member or sympathizer of the NSDAP (the National Socialist German Workers’ Party), the movement that between 1933 and 1945 turned Germany into a totalitarian dictatorship, unleashed a war of annihilation, and organized the industrial mass murder of millions of people. National Socialism was an ideology that fused the omnipotence of the state, racism, nationalism, and the cult of the leader into a monstrous whole.1
It is important to keep this definition in mind. It is about to become absurd.
Godwin’s Law and the Reductio ad Hitlerum
As early as 1951, the philosopher Leo Strauss formulated the concept of the reductio ad Hitlerum: a rhetorical fallacy in which a position is refuted by attributing it to Hitler or the National Socialists.2 Strauss was not amused. Hitler may have liked autobahns; that does not make autobahns fascist.
In 1990, Mike Godwin expanded this observation into his famous law: in any internet discussion that goes on long enough, someone will eventually be compared to Hitler or the Nazis.3 Godwin meant it as satire. The internet took it as an instruction.
What began as an internet phenomenon has long since made its way into mainstream discourse. Today you do not even need a long discussion. The Nazi comparison now arrives by reflex in the second tweet.
The Great Emptying
Language works through contrasts. A word has meaning because it distinguishes something from something else. “Hot” means something because it is not “cold.” “Murder” means something because it is not “accident.” “Nazi” meant something because it referred to a specific, historically unique form of political crime.
What happens when you apply a term to anything and everyone? It loses its contrast. It loses its meaning. And it loses its warning function, and that is the real damage.
If everyone is a Nazi, no one is one anymore. If the term applies as much to the talk-show guest who wants lower taxes as to someone with a genuine ideology of extermination, then society has switched off its semantic early-warning system. The threepenny insult disposes of two things at once: the opponent in the debate and historical memory.
The Oddity: The Libertarian as Nazi
This is where it gets really interesting, and really funny, if it were not so sad.
Libertarians are increasingly called “Nazis.” For what? For rejecting the state. For placing individual liberty above collective constraints. For regarding state redistribution as coercion. For advocating peace, open borders, and free trade.4
It is worth pausing here for a moment to recall the historical opposite: National Socialism was a deeply statist movement. It deified the state. It bound the individual completely to the collective. It took control of the economy, culture, science, the family, and thought. It recognized no privacy, no freedom of conscience, no property right that was allowed to stand against the will of the people.5
National Socialism was, in short, the antithesis of libertarianism.
Calling a libertarian a Nazi is about as logical as calling a vegan a meat-industry lobbyist or a pacifist a warmonger. It is not just wrong; it is precisely backward. But the threepenny insult does not care about logic. It can be had for pennies, not for arguments.
Liberty as Right-Wing Radicalism
The real intellectual punch line lies one level deeper. In current discourse, liberty itself, individual, personal, economic liberty, is considered suspect, far-right, a kind of cover for sinister intentions.
Whoever calls taxes coercion is a social Darwinist. Whoever defends free markets is protecting the rich. Whoever demands less government wants to abandon the weak. And whoever insists on property rights is, of course, well on the way to Auschwitz.
This chain of reasoning presupposes that state power is good per se and that any skepticism toward it stems from bad motives. It is a worldview in which the state forms the horizon of meaning for the good, a strange closeness to the political theology of the 20th century, which we had thought long overcome.
In The Road to Serfdom, Friedrich Hayek showed where the road leads when planning power and moral superiority lie in the same hands.6 The irony is that today it is precisely those who are Hayek’s successors who are denounced as forerunners of tyranny.
The Function of the Threepenny Insult
The threepenny insult should not be underestimated. It is cheap, but not accidental. It serves a function.
First: It replaces the argument. Once you have called your opponent a Nazi, you no longer have to engage with his ideas. The insult is a shortcut across the terrain of thought.
Second: It signals belonging. In certain circles, the ability to identify others as Nazis is a status signal. You show which side you are on, the right one, of course.
Third: It wears people down. Anyone who is constantly accused of the worst withdraws. The threepenny insult is also an instrument of exhaustion. It poisons the atmosphere until factual discussion becomes impossible, which is probably the real goal.
What We Lose
This is not just about libertarian sensitivities. It is about the state of public conversation as a whole.
A society that has inflated its gravest accusation loses the ability to name real threats. If the word “Nazi” applies to anyone who wants to lower the value-added tax, then there is no word left for someone who seriously holds a racial ideology. The warning system has been switched off.
Beyond that, society loses the possibility of genuine debate. Libertarian ideas have an intellectual tradition that runs from Bastiat through Mises to Hayek and Rothbard. This tradition deserves refutation, not insults. Anyone who dismisses it with a threepenny insult only shows that he does not know it.
Counterarguments
“But some libertarian positions are objectively harmful, and you have to call that by its name.”
Anyone who considers a position harmful should explain why it is harmful, not search for an association that saves the mental effort. That an idea can lead to unintended consequences is an argument. That its advocate is reminiscent of a historical criminal movement that explicitly rejected this idea is not.
“The term ‘Nazi’ isn’t really meant seriously, it’s rhetoric.”
This is the most honest counterargument. Yes, much of it is rhetorical escalation, not a literal classification. The problem: language shapes perception. Anyone who regularly places people close to a criminal ideology, even if only rhetorically, creates associations and thereby makes genuine dialogue impossible. “I didn’t mean it that way” is no excuse for the damage the choice of words does.
“But there really are libertarian currents that overlap with far-right groups.”
That is true, and it is a legitimate observation that deserves nuanced analysis.7 There are border-crossers and co-opters in every political movement, including libertarianism. Naming and criticizing these borderline cases makes sense. But using them as grounds to criminalize libertarianism as a whole is as apt as judging socialism as a whole by the Gulag guards, a comparison no one who carries a threepenny insult in his pocket would dare to draw.
Conclusion: Three Pennies for a Hallelujah
The threepenny insult “Nazi” is affordable, ubiquitous, and ineffective, except as a debate killer. It harasses people who, out of serious philosophical conviction, want to limit or abolish state power. It does not honor the memory of the actual victims of National Socialism. And it leaves those who use it intellectually poorer than they were when they entered the conversation.
Bertolt Brecht, the father of the real Threepenny Opera, was a clever man. He knew that art should be accessible. He also knew that cheap theater is ultimately worthless. The threepenny insult, two syllables, zero content, maximum damage, is the cheapest theater political discourse has to offer.
And Mack the Knife, the hero of the Threepenny Opera, would probably be offended to be associated with something so shabby.
Footnotes
- On the ideological structure of National Socialism, see Ian Kershaw, Hitler 1889–1936, Stuttgart 1998 (in German; in English as Hitler 1889–1936: Hubris, London 1998); and Richard J. Evans, Das Dritte Reich, 3 vols., Munich 2004–2009 (in German; in English as The Coming of the Third Reich, The Third Reich in Power, and The Third Reich at War, 2003–2008).
- Leo Strauss, Natural Right and History, Chicago 1953, pp. 42–43. Strauss’s concept of the reductio ad Hitlerum describes the fallacy of refuting a thesis by linking it to Hitler or the National Socialists.
- Mike Godwin first formulated his law in 1990 in a Usenet discussion; later published as: Mike Godwin, “Meme, Counter-meme,” Wired, October 1994.
- On the foundations of libertarian philosophy, see Murray N. Rothbard, For a New Liberty: The Libertarian Manifesto, New York 1973; and Friedrich A. Hayek, Die Verfassung der Freiheit, Tübingen 1991 (in German; in English as The Constitution of Liberty, Chicago 1960).
- On the economic policy of the Third Reich, see Adam Tooze, Ökonomie der Zerstörung. Die Geschichte der Wirtschaft im Nationalsozialismus, Munich 2007 (in German; in English as The Wages of Destruction: The Making and Breaking of the Nazi Economy, London 2006).
- Friedrich A. Hayek, Der Weg zur Knechtschaft [1944], Munich 2004 (in German; in English as The Road to Serfdom, London 1944).
- See Brian Doherty, Radicals for Capitalism, New York 2007, ch. 12, as well as the debate over the “paleolibertarian strategy” of the 1990s.

