Skip to content Skip to footer

Are Libertarians Right-Wing?

The short answer

No, libertarians are neither right-wing nor left-wing in the classic sense. Libertarianism operates on a political axis of its own, one that differs fundamentally from the traditional division into left and right. These categories are simply unsuited to capturing libertarian thought.

The problem with “left” and “right”

The terms “left” and “right” originally come from the French National Assembly of 1789. In the Constituent Assembly, the supporters of the monarchy sat to the right of the Assembly’s president, while the critics of the monarchy sat on the left. This seating arrangement developed into the classic distinction between revolutionary, republican forces (left) and conservative, pro-monarchy views (right).

This one-dimensional division may have made sense in the 18th and 19th centuries, when the central political conflict really did run between progressives and conservatives, between equality and hierarchy. But it no longer does justice to the political reality of the 21st century, and it does even less justice to libertarianism.

What is libertarianism?

Before we can explain why libertarians are neither left nor right, we have to understand what libertarianism actually means. Libertarianism is a political philosophy based on the following core principles:

1. The principle of self-ownership

Every person is the sole owner of his or her own body and has the sole right to decide over it. From this it follows that everyone has the right to dispose freely of his or her life, labor, and the fruits of that labor.

2. The non-aggression principle (NAP)

The central principle of libertarianism holds that the use or threat of force is permissible only in self-defense. Initiating physical force or fraud against persons or their rightfully acquired property is morally impermissible. This includes coercion by the state.

3. Property rights

Libertarians stress the fundamental importance of property rights, both in one’s own body and in material goods acquired through original appropriation, production, or voluntary contract.

4. Voluntariness and freedom of contract

In a libertarian society, all human interactions are based on voluntary consent. Coercion of any kind is rejected unless it is used to defend against aggression.

5. Skepticism toward state power

Libertarians are fundamentally skeptical of authority and state power. They differ only in the intensity of their opposition: from minarchists, who favor a minimal state, to anarcho-capitalists, who reject every form of state.

In short: Libertarianism means maximum individual liberty, as long as the rights of others are not violated. It is about freedom from coercion and force, not about using politics to impose particular models of society.

The Nolan Chart: a two-dimensional perspective

To understand why libertarianism does not fit on the left-right axis, we have to look at the Nolan Chart. It was developed in 1971 by David Nolan, a cofounder of the US Libertarian Party, and represents a fundamental alternative to the one-dimensional political spectrum.

The two axes of liberty

The Nolan Chart rests on the insight that there are two different dimensions of political liberty:

  • Economic freedom (horizontal): from a state-controlled planned economy to the free market
  • Personal/social freedom (vertical): from authoritarian control of private life to maximum personal self-determination

The four quadrants

This two-dimensional model yields four different political positions:

  1. Libertarianism (top): high economic AND high personal freedom
  2. Authoritarianism (bottom): low economic AND low personal freedom
  3. “Left” position (upper left): high personal freedom but low economic freedom (state intervention in the economy)
  4. “Right” position (lower right): high economic freedom but low personal freedom (social conservatism)

In this model it becomes immediately clear: libertarians share with the “left” the demand for social freedom (drug legalization, sexual self-determination, rejection of morality laws) and with the “right” the demand for economic freedom (free markets, low taxes, deregulation), but at the same time they reject what both have in common: the use of state coercion to impose their respective goals.

Libertarians, the left, and the right: the fundamental difference

The decisive point is this: Both “left” and “right” are politics, and politics means coercion.

As the Ludwig von Mises Institut Deutschland (Mises Institute Germany) aptly puts it: “Politics, whatever its orientation, starts from imagined collectives and enforces ideas through coercion against those people who would voluntarily act otherwise.”

What left-wing politics wants

  • Redistribution through taxes
  • Social justice through state intervention
  • Regulation of the economy
  • Collective solutions to social problems

What right-wing politics wants

  • Preservation of traditional values by law
  • National order and security
  • Moral rules for private life
  • A strong state for “law and order”

What libertarians want

  • No state imposition of models of society
  • Voluntary cooperation instead of coercion
  • Individual liberty in ALL areas
  • A minimal state or no state at all

The fundamental difference: the left and the right want to use the state to achieve their respective goals, whether social justice or traditional order. Libertarians reject the use of state coercion on principle. One cannot be for political coercion and for libertarianism at the same time. That position is incompatible with the non-aggression principle.

Are there “left-libertarians” and “right-libertarians”?

Yes and no. This is where it gets complicated, because the terms are used in different ways.

The academic usage

Political science literature does in fact distinguish between several libertarian currents:

Left-libertarians or social libertarians

  • Emphasize social equality and justice
  • Critical of large corporations and the concentration of economic power
  • Often hold Georgist positions on land use
  • Deny that self-ownership automatically implies absolute property rights in natural resources
  • Examples: Kevin Carson (mutualist), Hillel Steiner, Peter Vallentyne

Right-libertarians or libertarian capitalists

  • Emphasize absolute property rights and market freedom
  • See property rights as grounded in natural law
  • Range from minarchists (Robert Nozick) to anarcho-capitalists (Murray Rothbard)
  • Sometimes linked with cultural conservatism (paleolibertarianism)

“Neutral” or classical libertarians

  • Focus purely on the non-aggression principle
  • Take no position on cultural or lifestyle questions
  • Advocate a consistent minimal state or anarcho-capitalism
  • Examples: David Friedman, many in the Libertarian Party

The criticism of these terms

There is, however, also a fundamental criticism of using “left” and “right” in a libertarian context. This criticism argues:

“To interpret libertarianism in connection with left-wing or right-wing politics contradicts its very linchpin. Politics, whatever its orientation, starts from imagined collectives and enforces ideas through coercion against those people who would voluntarily act otherwise.”

On this view, terms like “left-libertarian” are oxymorons, contradictions in terms. Anyone who wants to combine libertarian principles with political coercion (whether for social justice or for traditional values) is no longer a libertarian.

The meaningful distinction

It makes more sense to draw the following distinctions within libertarianism:

  1. Differences in the theory of property: Which goods can legitimately become private property? Does that also apply to land and natural resources?
  2. Differences in justification: Natural law (Rothbard, Rand) or consequentialist (Friedman, Hayek)?
  3. Differences in the theory of the state: Anarcho-capitalism, minarchism, or classical liberalism?
  4. Cultural preferences: Which ways of life does one prefer personally (not politically!)?

These differences concern theoretical questions within libertarian philosophy, not membership in “left-wing” or “right-wing” political movements.

Why are libertarians often called “right-wing”?

Despite all this, libertarians are frequently classified in the media and in public perception as “right-wing” or even “far-right.” Why?

Superficial similarities

There are in fact points where libertarian positions overlap with conservative or “right-wing” positions:

  • Rejection of redistribution and the welfare state
  • The demand for low taxes
  • Criticism of bureaucracy and regulation
  • Emphasis on personal responsibility
  • Skepticism toward government social programs

These overlaps lead to libertarians often being placed in the “right-wing” camp, but that is a fundamental misjudgment.

Decisive differences from the “right”

Libertarians differ from right-wing conservatives on fundamental points:

  • Militarism: Libertarians reject an interventionist foreign policy and imperialism
  • Nationalism: Libertarians favor open borders and freedom of movement
  • Authoritarianism: Libertarians reject “law and order” politics and the police state
  • Morality laws: Libertarians call for the legalization of drugs, prostitution, etc.
  • Sexual freedom: Libertarians support the rights of LGBTQ+ people
  • Religious laws: Libertarians reject state enforcement of religious norms

A conservative wants to enforce traditional values by law. A libertarian may personally hold conservative values but rejects their enforcement by the state.

Problematic cases at the margins

The confusion is compounded by so-called “paleolibertarianism,” represented for example by Lew Rockwell and, in part, by Murray Rothbard in his later years. This current combines libertarian economic policy with cultural conservatism. Critics argue that this is a contradiction in terms: one cannot be for maximum personal freedom and for conservative social norms at the same time.

Even more problematic are people who call themselves “libertarian” but hold racist or authoritarian positions (such as Janusz Korwin-Mikke in Poland). In the view of many libertarian theorists, they are simply not libertarians, since their positions fundamentally contradict the non-aggression principle.

Exploitation by the media

Another reason for the misclassification is deliberate or unconscious media bias. As the Mises Institute Germany argues, there are two possible explanations for the frequent use of terms like “right-libertarian”:

  1. Ignorance: A lack of economic education and of understanding of libertarian philosophy
  2. Political exploitation: By associating libertarianism with the “right” or the “far right,” the aim is to discredit the libertarian movement

The better alternative: the authoritarian-libertarian axis

The German political scientist Gero Neugebauer recognizes that in modern society “the decisive political constellation of conflict does not run between right and left, but between a social-libertarian and a neoliberal-authoritarian conception of politics.”

In other words, the real political conflict of our time is not between “left” and “right,” but between:

  • Libertarian values: individual liberty, self-determination, rejection of coercion
  • Authoritarian values: state control, collective constraints, security over liberty

From a libertarian point of view, the traditional “left” and “right” have more in common than divides them: both want to use the state to impose their vision of society. Both accept coercion as a legitimate means of politics. The only difference lies in which goals they want to pursue with state force.

Murray Rothbard is credited with the view that libertarians generally see more similarities than differences between the left and the right, and in the extreme case between communists and fascists: namely their fundamental authoritarianism, their belief in the legitimacy of state coercion.

Conclusion: beyond left and right

The question “Are libertarians right-wing?” rests on a category error. It tries to force a philosophy that explicitly positions itself beyond the left-right dichotomy into precisely that scheme.

Libertarians are neither left nor right. They hold a distinct, independent position based on two fundamental principles:

  1. Maximum individual liberty in all areas of life
  2. Rejection of coercion except in self-defense

This position means that libertarians:

  • Agree with the “left” on social freedom, civil rights, and anti-imperialism
  • Agree with the “right” on economic freedom, property rights, and criticism of taxation
  • Are in conflict with BOTH when it comes to the legitimacy of state coercion

The US Libertarian Party is described as seeing itself as standing beyond the political right-left scheme. And that is exactly where libertarianism belongs: as an independent political philosophy that cannot be judged by the categories of the 18th century.

Anyone who wants to understand libertarianism has to stop thinking in the categories of “left” and “right.” Instead, one should ask: Does this position rely on voluntariness or on coercion? On individual liberty or on collective control? On spontaneous order or on political planning?

The answers to these questions define libertarianism, not its position on an outdated, one-dimensional political scale.


Further reading

  • David Nolan: “Classifying and Analyzing Politico-Economic Systems” (1971)
  • Murray Rothbard: “For a New Liberty: The Libertarian Manifesto” (1973)
  • Robert Nozick: “Anarchy, State, and Utopia” (1974)
  • Friedrich A. von Hayek: “The Constitution of Liberty” (1960)
  • John Tomasi & Matt Zwolinski: “The Individualists: Radicals, Reactionaries, and the Struggle for the Soul of Libertarianism” (2023)

Leave a Comment

Popular:

Tip: press / or Ctrl+K to open search from any page.