Summary
On October 28, 2026, Germany’s Federal Police arrested the physician and commentator Paul Brandenburg at Berlin’s BER airport. Since then he has been held in pretrial detention at Moabit prison in Berlin. Prosecutors are investigating six statements about Kai Wegner, the Governing Mayor of Berlin: four counts of insult under Section 185 and two counts of defaming a person in political life under Section 188 of the German Criminal Code (Strafgesetzbuch). The judiciary cites flight risk as the ground for detention. We do not defend what Brandenburg wrote about Wegner. We defend the principle that in a free country no one is locked up for words before a court has even ruled on those words.
What happened
According to consistent reports, Brandenburg was arrested at BER on the morning of October 28 as he arrived in Berlin with his ten-year-old child. That same day he was brought before a judge, who ordered pretrial detention. The Berlin public prosecutor’s office argues that there is a risk of flight because Brandenburg has no permanent residence in Germany and is evading prosecution. It also points to the minimum sentence under Section 188 and to prior convictions. Brandenburg has been living abroad for some time and describes himself as a “German in exile.”
His defense lawyers counter that Brandenburg comes to Berlin several times a month to spend time with his child, and that the authorities know this. According to them, at the detention review hearing before the Tiergarten District Court on November 6 they offered, among other things, reporting requirements and an electronic ankle monitor. The judge declined to suspend the arrest warrant. According to the defense, the next detention review is due in about two weeks.
According to press reports, several dozen further investigations are pending against Brandenburg, mostly over statements online. The same applies to all of them as to every accused person: he is innocent until a court rules otherwise in a final, binding judgment.
What we expressly do not defend
According to the defense, the statements relate to an artist who performed in July 2025 at a Berlin charity gala that Wegner also attended. According to press reports, this artist has been convicted of possessing child pornography. It is fair to ask a Governing Mayor which events he attends, which ones his Senate (Berlin’s state government) funds, and whether anyone looked closely enough. That is politics, and politics has to put up with criticism, including harsh and polemical criticism.
The prosecutors, however, accuse Brandenburg of having insinuated that Wegner endorses sexual offenses against minors. Whether that was a crime is for a court to decide. Regardless of that, one thing holds: insinuating that a person endorses the sexual abuse of children is neither criticism nor an argument. It is a denigration that explains nothing and convinces no one. Those who stand up for liberty should argue better than their opponents, not insult more loudly. We clearly distance ourselves from this. Kai Wegner has every right to defend himself against such accusations.
But defending oneself means contradicting, correcting the record, and if necessary suing for an injunction in civil court. It does not mean that the critic ends up in prison.
Why the detention crosses a line
Formally, Brandenburg is not in custody because of his words but because of flight risk. That is legally correct and still only half the truth. Pretrial detention is the most severe measure the state can impose on a person who has not yet been convicted. The German Code of Criminal Procedure therefore expressly requires that it be proportionate to the significance of the case and to the expected sentence. And it requires that an arrest warrant be suspended if milder measures suffice, such as reporting requirements.
What significance are we talking about here? Insults, for which courts normally impose a fine. And two counts under Section 188, which, however, carries a minimum sentence of six months. That is exactly what the prosecutors rely on. This reveals the real problem: it is a special provision for politicians that turns a dispute over words into something that looks like a prison matter in the first place.
The state could have charged Brandenburg, served the summons through his lawyers, scheduled a trial, and waited for a verdict. Instead, according to his defense, a father was led away at the airport in front of his child and has been sitting in a cell for almost two weeks. Whether the flight risk holds up legally is for the courts to determine. Politically and humanly, one thing is already clear: when a dispute over tweets ends in a prison cell, a line has been crossed.
A special law for the powerful
Section 188 punishes the insult and defamation of persons in political life more severely than that of an ordinary citizen. Since a reform in 2021, it expressly applies to all levels of politics down to local government and also covers simple insult. The condition is that the act is capable of making the public work of the person concerned considerably more difficult. So anyone who insults a mayor risks more than someone who insults their neighbor.
That is a remarkable reversal. The Federal Constitutional Court, Germany’s highest court, has stressed that freedom of expression grew precisely out of the particular need to protect criticism of those in power. Those who exercise power must put up with more than others, not less. Section 188 turns this idea on its head: it protects the powerful from citizens better than it protects citizens from one another.
The idea is old. In the German Empire it was called lèse-majesté. Remnants of it have survived in the Criminal Code, for example the special protection of the Federal President in Section 90. Section 103, which imposed special penalties for insulting foreign heads of state, was abolished by the Bundestag, Germany’s federal parliament, effective January 1, 2018, after the affair over Jan Böhmermann’s poem about the Turkish president. At the time, it was said that such a special law for heads of state was no longer appropriate for the times. A few years later, it was expanded for Germany’s own politicians.
Not an isolated case
The Brandenburg case does not stand alone. In November 2024, police searched the home of a pensioner from Lower Franconia in Bavaria who had shared an image mocking Robert Habeck as a “Schwachkopf” (“moron”). The search warrant was based solely on insult and Section 188. A suspicion of incitement to hatred (Volksverhetzung) over a different post only came up in the prosecutors’ public explanation. In April 2025, the Bamberg District Court sentenced David Bendels, editor-in-chief of the “Deutschland-Kurier,” to seven months in prison, suspended, over an image intended as satire about then Federal Interior Minister Nancy Faeser. The Bamberg Regional Court acquitted him in January 2026 on the grounds that the post was protected by freedom of expression.
Such acquittals show that the rule of law often corrects itself in the end. But they also show how much happens before that point: searches, summonses, legal fees, months of uncertainty. The proceedings themselves become the punishment. And everyone watching learns from it that it is better to stay silent.
What we know from dictatorships
A state that uses prison to shield its officials from mocking or hurtful words is something we know from countries we would not want to live in.
In Nazi Germany, the Treachery Act (Heimtückegesetz) of December 20, 1934, made “malicious” statements about leading figures of the state and of the Nazi Party (NSDAP) a crime. A political joke told over beers at the local pub could end before a special court and in prison. In East Germany (the GDR), the criminal code punished “incitement hostile to the state” and the “public disparagement” of state bodies and their representatives. Anyone who said or wrote the wrong sentence not infrequently ended up first in the Stasi remand prison at Hohenschönhausen and then in prison for years, for example in Bautzen. In the Soviet Union, “anti-Soviet agitation and propaganda” sent countless people to the camps.
Nor is this merely history today. In Turkey, tens of thousands of investigations for insulting the president have been opened under Article 299 of the penal code since 2014. Since 2019, Russia has punished “disrespect” for the state and its bodies, and since 2022 the “discrediting” of the army. In Belarus, insulting the president can bring a prison sentence of several years. In Thailand, a woman was sentenced in 2021 to 43 years in prison for posts about the royal family.
We do not equate Germany with these states. Here there are independent courts, lawyers, a free press, and detention reviews. But the comparison shows which direction a tool points in. Laws that give politicians special protection from words, and prison for statements, are the instruments of authoritarian states. We would expect something like this from Ankara, Moscow, or Minsk, not from Berlin.
What a free society should do instead
The answer to words is words. Anyone who is insulted can respond, and anyone who is defamed can seek an injunction and damages in civil court. That is enough to protect a person’s honor, and it applies to the mayor just as it does to the citizen.
Three demands follow from this:
- Section 188 should be abolished. Politicians do not need better protection of their honor than other people; they need thicker skin.
- There must be no pretrial detention for offenses that consist purely of speech. Where the state wants to ensure that an accused person can be reached, milder measures are available to it.
- Paul Brandenburg must be released under conditions and be able to defend himself in a fair trial, like anyone else.
You do not have to like Paul Brandenburg to demand this. You do not have to share his words, and we do not. Freedom of speech proves itself precisely where it protects people whose words we consider wrong, tasteless, or hurtful. Those who grant it only to the polite have already given it up.
This article is part of our series on thinkers, doers, and historical figures of liberty.
Sources
- Tagesspiegel: Internet-Hassprediger Paul Brandenburg am BER festgenommen, October 31, 2026 (in German), https://www.tagesspiegel.de/berlin/viele-verfahren-offen-internet-hassprediger-paul-brandenburg-am-ber-festgenommen–untersuchungshaft-16218874.html
- Berliner Zeitung: Paul Brandenburg am BER festgenommen: Was hinter dem umstrittenen Haftbefehl steckt, November 2, 2026 (in German), https://www.berliner-zeitung.de/article/paul-brandenburg-am-ber-festgenommen-was-hinter-dem-umstrittenen-haftbefehl-steckt-10548050
- Apollo News: Corona-Aktivist Paul Brandenburg verhaftet, weil er „flüchtig“ sei (with information from the Berlin public prosecutor’s office) (in German), https://apollo-news.net/beleidigung-von-kai-wegner-corona-aktivist-paul-brandenburg-verhaftet-weil-er-flchtig-sei/
- Tichys Einblick: Berlins Bürgermeister beleidigt? Publizist Paul Brandenburg in Haft, October 30, 2026 (in German), https://www.tichyseinblick.de/daili-es-sentials/brandenburg-u-haft-beleidigung-wegner/
- Norbert Häring: Paul Brandenburg bleibt in U-Haft (detention review, November 6, 2026) (in German), https://norberthaering.de/propaganda-zensur/brandenburg-in-haft/
- Tichys Einblick: TE exklusiv: Brandenburgs U-Haftverlängerung, wie begründet das die Richterin?, November 6, 2026 (in German), https://www.tichyseinblick.de/daili-es-sentials/te-exklusiv-brandenburgs-u-haftverlaengerung-wie-begruendet-das-die-richterin/
- German Criminal Code (Strafgesetzbuch), § 90 (Disparagement of the Federal President) (in German), https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/stgb/__90.html
- German Code of Criminal Procedure (Strafprozessordnung), §§ 112, 116 (in German): https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/stpo/__112.html
- German Criminal Code (Strafgesetzbuch), § 188 (in German): https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/stgb/__188.html
- LTO: LG Bamberg spricht David Bendels frei, January 14, 2026 (in German), https://www.lto.de/recht/nachrichten/n/11nbs1108js1131524-lg-bamberg-david-bendels-deutschland-kurier-nancy-faeser-meme-freispruch
- netzpolitik.org: Grundrechte-Report 2025, Habeck und die Hausdurchsuchung (in German), https://netzpolitik.org/2025/grundrechte-report-2025-habeck-und-die-hausdurchsuchung/
Featured image: AI illustration

