Skip to content Skip to footer

David Dürr: Law Without a Lawgiver

David Dürr, portrait photo

“It is not forbidden to kill someone because it is written in the state’s statute book; rather, it is written in the statute book because it is forbidden.” The sentence comes from an essay David Dürr published in February 2026 in the anthology Zurück zu „Wohlstand für alle“ in Deutschland (our translation: Back to “Prosperity for All” in Germany) of the Ludwig von Mises Institut Deutschland. It sounds plain, almost self-evident, and yet it carries an entire theory of law: laws are not made, they are found.

What makes this remarkable is who is saying it. Dürr knows the law from daily practice: for decades he has been an attorney and notary in Basel, he wrote the commentary on Swiss mortgage law in the Zurich Commentary (Zürcher Kommentar) on the Swiss Civil Code, and at the University of Zurich he taught private law and legal theory to generations of students. It is precisely this closeness to the law in force that led him to the conviction that good law does not need a state.

At a glance

  • Born: 1952, grew up in Basel
  • Work: Attorney and notary at SwissLegal Dürr + Partner in Basel; adjunct professor (Titularprofessor) at the University of Zurich from 1999, emeritus since 2017
  • Fields: Property law, especially mortgage law and condominium ownership, as well as legal theory
  • Network: Academic advisory board of the Ludwig von Mises Institut Deutschland; Murray Rothbard Memorial Lecture at the Mises Institute in 2019
  • Major works: Diskursives Recht (1994), Staats-Oper Schweiz (2011, expanded 2022), Das Wort zum Freitag. Anarchistische Kolumnen (2014), 2048. Schlussbericht (2024)
  • In one sentence: As a lawyer, he shows that law arises from conflicts and grows from the bottom up, and that a state which is both lawgiver and judge in its own cause stands in the way of that law.

A lawyer with a simple question

David Dürr studied law in Basel and Geneva, received his doctorate in 1977, and passed the bar exam that same year and the notary exam in 1978. After a year of study at Harvard Law School, which he completed in 1979 with a Master of Laws, he started out as an attorney in Zurich; since 1980 he has been a partner in Basel, since 1995 at SwissLegal Dürr + Partner. Until 2002 he also presided over a military court of appeals.

In 1993 he completed his habilitation (the postdoctoral qualification for teaching at a university) at the Faculty of Law of the University of Zurich, and in 1999 he became an adjunct professor. He taught property law as well as legal theory, and from 2006 he offered seminars together with the constitutional law scholar Andreas Kley and the legal historian Andreas Thier that combined legal theory with constitutional law, legal history, and anarchy. He has been emeritus since 2017. He still practices as an attorney and notary (as of November 2026).

As he recounted in Auburn in 2019, his thinking began with a question his studies had not answered: What actually is law? Only at Harvard, comparing European statutory law with the common law based on precedent, did he come closer to the answer.

The conflict creates its own law

He worked out the answer in his habilitation thesis Diskursives Recht (our translation: Discursive Law), published in 1994. On this view, law does not depend on judges, authorities, or lawgivers. It provides answers even where no statute and no precedent exists, and its real source is the conflict that sparks it. In his Rothbard lecture of 2019 he summed it up this way: “the conflict creates its own legal solution.”

From the conflict itself, Dürr derives the principles that underpin every legal order. Because in a dispute only the points on which the parties collide count, neither is worth more than the other; that is equality before the law. Whoever consents to an infringement has no claim to complain, which the Romans called volenti non fit iniuria. And whoever already has something, his body, his belongings, the land he stands on, holds a stronger position than someone who comes later. From this follow property and the prohibition on harming others.

Dürr also bases this view on history. For centuries, Roman private law was largely judge-made law, and even Emperor Justinian’s Corpus Iuris Civilis was at its core a collection of case decisions and legal doctrines. The great codifications of private law in the 19th century owed their strength, he writes in 2026, to content that was “not ordered by politicians” but researched and written down by legal historians. State legislation is therefore either unnecessary or wrong, for a law that truly holds needs no help, any more than gravity has to be commanded or enforced.

Judge in its own cause

By his own account, Dürr became an anarchist in a second step, when he applied the principles he had found to the state itself. In private law, parties with equal rights call on a neutral judge. In administrative law, by contrast, the state is a party, sets the applicable rules itself, provides the court, and enforces the judgment. For a bank sued over poor asset management, this would be unthinkable; in administrative law it is everyday practice.

Nor is he convinced by the separation of powers as a remedy. The legislature, the executive, and the judiciary, he argues, are three branches of the same tree, all on the same payroll and paid from the same taxes. And what the state collects as taxes against the will of those who pay would be punished as theft if a citizen did it. The state thus grants itself privileges that it denies to everyone else, and in doing so violates the very principle of equality before the law that it invokes.

Dürr’s reading of the Radbruch formula of 1946 is especially striking. After the experience of National Socialism, Gustav Radbruch wanted to deny validity to statutes whose conflict with justice reaches an “intolerable degree.” Dürr draws attention to the first half of the sentence, according to which state law keeps its precedence even when its content is unjust. That, he says, is about as convincing as making the fox the guardian of order in the henhouse and granting the hens a right to resist only once he starts eating them.

How much democracy there is in democracy

Dürr has run the numbers on the obvious objection that state laws are, after all, democratically legitimized, using the example of Switzerland, the country with probably the most developed direct democracy. In his 2019 lecture he showed that at the federal level only 0.8 percent of enactments are adopted directly by the people, around a quarter by parliament, and just under three quarters by the government and its administration. Taking into account voter turnout, approval rates, and the fact that each member of parliament represents around 30,000 people, his calculation leaves a democracy rate of just 0.09 percent.

For Germany, his 2026 essay reaches a similar finding: around 75 percent of federal rules are issued as executive ordinances without parliament ever seeing them, and more than 90 percent of federal statutes are initiated and drafted by the government, so that in his judgment the deliberation in parliament is mainly ritual in character.

Law from the bottom up

What takes the place of the lawgiver? Dürr’s answer is a law that grows from the bottom up and that, with the American legal scholar Tom W. Bell, one can call polycentric law, because it has many sources and no monopolist. Conflicts are settled by those whose interests are affected, with the help of conciliators, mediators, or arbitrators whom they choose themselves. In his view, independent associations such as labor unions or patient organizations represent weaker parties more resolutely than a state that always has to spare the other side as well.

He lists the advantages soberly. Such law acts only where there really is a conflict and does not invent problems to keep authorities busy. It seeks a settlement instead of letting one side win, and it compensates the party that has to give way. Its conciliators must be impartial, because otherwise neither side would accept them, and they have no monopoly, so the most capable come to the fore. Dürr’s conclusion is modest and all the more convincing for it: such orders “do not create paradise, but they avoid the hell that states bring upon us time and again.”

His experience as a practitioner feeds directly into this. In a 2025 article in the professional journal perspektive mediation, he takes issue with the habit of treating mediation as a merely “alternative” form of conflict resolution in which the final word still rests with the state. His thesis is right there in the title, Mediation, ein Naturgesetz (our translation: Mediation, a Law of Nature), and the abstract puts it briefly: “Mediation deserves precedence.”

The path he proposes is moderate as well. He considers de-statization through popular initiatives or by electing suitable members of parliament hopeless, because political systems do not abolish themselves. Instead he relies on a change in thinking like the one the churches went through after secularization: they continue to exist and give many people support, but they bind only those who want to belong to them. “Yes, let us leave the state just as it is, but let us declare membership in it voluntary,” he writes. Those who want regulation keep it, and those who want to take their lives into their own hands may do so.

Switzerland as a case study

For Dürr, his own country is illustrative material and the object of affectionate satire. With Staats-Oper Schweiz. Wenige Stars, viele Staatisten (our translation, roughly: State Opera Switzerland: Few Stars, Many Statists) he published a political satire in 2011, which appeared in a second edition “with a COVID epilogue” in 2022. In 2014 came Das Wort zum Freitag, a selection of his anarchist columns from the Basler Zeitung. From 2017, his articles also appeared under the series title “Bürgerlicher Anarchismus” (our translation: Bourgeois Anarchism) in the German magazine eigentümlich frei.

He ventures furthest in 2048. Schlussbericht (our translation: 2048: Final Report) of 2024. In it, on the two hundredth anniversary of the Swiss federal state, a fictional “Federal Office for the Winding Up of the Swiss Confederation” presents its final report. Education, law, health care, retirement provision, and security are organized privately and in a decentralized way, and disputes are resolved by arbitration tribunals and mediators. In December 2024 the Schweizer Monat wrote that this vision is thought-provoking.

In 2017 he spoke at the annual conference of the Ludwig von Mises Institut Deutschland on “Die viel zu große Schweiz” (our translation: Switzerland, Far Too Big), and in March 2019 he gave the Murray Rothbard Memorial Lecture at the Mises Institute’s Austrian Economics Research Conference in Auburn. In it he recounted that he came across Rothbard’s 1975 essay Society Without a State only when he was already a convinced anarchist, and that he recognized in it his own legal reflections. By his own account, he is bound by friendship to Hans-Hermann Hoppe, whose argumentation ethics he sees as closely related to his own approach.

The question of the lawgiver

Dürr’s most important contribution concerns the question that ends many debates about less government: Who will make the laws then? Dürr shows from history and from the logic of law that the question is wrongly posed. The fundamental rules of living together, from equality before the law to freedom of contract to the protection of property, are older than any lawgiver and hold even without one.

Just as instructive is his view of public law. Instead of arguing about individual regulations, Dürr directs attention to the structure behind them, in which one party at the same time sets the rules, pays the judges, and enforces the judgments, and with this view one reads every new ordinance differently.

Finally, the tone is convincing. Dürr argues without resentment, with wit and with the composure of a practitioner who, in dispute settlement and mediation, sees firsthand how people settle their disputes when they are allowed to. His proposal of voluntary exit takes nothing away from anyone who wants to stay with the state.

The court as lawgiver

The Swiss Civil Code contains, in its very first article, a sentence that Dürr explained in the Zurich Commentary in 1996. If the court finds no provision in the statute, it is to decide in accordance with customary law and, in the absence of customary law, “in accordance with the rule that it would make as legislator” (wording of the official English version). Here the lawgiver itself concedes that the law reaches further than its written provisions and that an independent judge can find it in the individual case. David Dürr has thought this idea through to the end. Whether one follows him all the way to a legal order without the state or only part of the way, after reading him it is hard to go on regarding the state as the only source of law.

Further reading

  • David Dürr: “Renaturierung des Rechts. Gesetze müssen nicht gegeben werden, Gesetze gibt es” (in German), in: Ludwig von Mises Institut Deutschland (ed.), Zurück zu „Wohlstand für alle“ in Deutschland, 2026 (free PDF)
  • David Dürr: “The Inescapability of Law, and of Mises, Rothbard, and Hoppe,” Journal of Libertarian Studies 23 (2019), pp. 161–170
  • David Dürr: 2048. Schlussbericht, Mobus, Stein 2024 (in German)
  • David Dürr: Staats-Oper Schweiz. Wenige Stars, viele Staatisten, 2nd edition, Mobus, Frick 2022 (in German)

This article is part of our series on thinkers, doers, and historical figures of liberty.

Sources

  • Dürr, David: Diskursives Recht. Zur theoretischen Grundlegung rechtlicher Einflussnahme auf überindividuelle Konflikte, habilitation thesis, Schulthess, Zurich 1994 (in German).
  • Dürr, David: Zürcher Kommentar, Art. 1 and 4 ZGB (Swiss Civil Code), 3rd edition, Zurich 1996 (in German).
  • Dürr, David: Kleines Wohnungseigentum. Ein neuer Vorschlag zur Eigentumsstreuung, Bundesamt für Wohnungswesen (Federal Housing Office), Grenchen/Bern 1999 (in German).
  • Dürr, David: “Entstaatlichung der Rechtsordnung. Ein Modell ohne staatliches Rechtssetzungs- und Gewaltmonopol,” in: Festgabe zum Schweizerischen Juristentag 2006, Zurich 2006, pp. 397 ff. (in German).
  • Dürr, David: Zürcher Kommentar zum Grundpfandrecht, 2nd edition, part 1, Zurich 2009; part 2 (with Daniel Zollinger), Zurich 2013 (in German).
  • Dürr, David: Staats-Oper Schweiz. Wenige Stars, viele Staatisten, Bern 2011; 2nd edition with COVID epilogue, Mobus, Frick 2022 (in German).
  • Dürr, David; Kaufmann, Thomas: Der neue Register-Schuldbrief und weitere Neuerungen des Grundpfandrechts, Stämpfli, Bern 2012 (in German).
  • Dürr, David: Das Wort zum Freitag. Anarchistische Kolumnen, Münster Verlag, Basel 2014 (in German).
  • Dürr, David: “The Inescapability of Law, and of Mises, Rothbard, and Hoppe” (Murray Rothbard Memorial Lecture, March 23, 2019), Journal of Libertarian Studies 23 (2019), pp. 161–170, https://jls.mises.org/article/11110
  • Dürr, David: 2048. Schlussbericht, Mobus, Stein 2024 (in German).
  • Dürr, David: “Mediation, ein Naturgesetz” (in German), perspektive mediation 22 (2025), no. 3, pp. 176–180, https://doi.org/10.33196/pm202503017601
  • Dürr, David: “Renaturierung des Rechts. Gesetze müssen nicht gegeben werden, Gesetze gibt es” (in German), in: Ludwig von Mises Institut Deutschland (ed.), Zurück zu „Wohlstand für alle“ in Deutschland, February 2026, pp. 65–82, https://www.misesde.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/zurueck-zu-wohlstand-fuer-alle.pdf
  • Dürr, David: “Encountering Rothbard: Property Rights as the Key to Anarchy,” in: Stephan Kinsella, Hans-Hermann Hoppe (eds.), Rothbard at 100, Papinian Press / Property and Freedom Society, Houston 2026, https://propertyandfreedom.org/books/rothbard-100/durr-encountering-rothbard-property-rights-as-the-key-to-anarchy/
  • University of Zurich: CV and list of publications of David Dürr, as of February 2022 (in German), https://www.ius.uzh.ch/de/staff/adjunct-professors/tit-duerr/david-duerr.html
  • Swiss Civil Code, Art. 1, SR 210 (in German), https://www.fedlex.admin.ch/eli/cc/24/233_245_233/de
  • SwissLegal: profile of Prof. Dr. iur. David Dürr, LL.M. (in German), https://www.swisslegal.ch/de/spezialisten/david-duerr-8.html (accessed November 9, 2026)
  • Canton of Basel-Stadt: register of attorneys, as of June 30, 2026 (in German), https://media.bs.ch/original_file/b1d8f62f821d1a4ed225ea392fe16dd33fb05184/anwaltsregister-30-06-26.pdf
  • German National Library / Deutsche Digitale Bibliothek: authority record for David Dürr (GND 172885531), https://www.deutsche-digitale-bibliothek.de/person/gnd/172885531
  • Mises Institute: profile of David Dürr, https://mises.org/profile/david-durr
  • Ludwig von Mises Institut Deutschland: author profile of David Dürr, https://www.misesde.org/2011/09/durr-david/ ; lecture “Die viel zu große Schweiz,” October 21, 2017 (in German), https://www.misesde.org/2017/11/professor-david-durr-%e2%80%9edie-viel-zu-grose-schweiz-und-was-dagegen-zu-tun-ware%e2%80%9c/
  • Duong, Yen: “Vater Dürr, der feine Anarchist” (in German), TagesWoche, July 25, 2013, https://tageswoche.ch/politik/vater-duerr-der-feine-anarchist/
  • Straumann, Michael: “Anarchistisches Utopia” (in German), Schweizer Monat, December 2, 2024, https://www.schweizermonat.ch/anarchistisches-utopia/
  • Property and Freedom Podcast PFP300: David Dürr, “A Brief History of Swiss Anarchism” (PFS 2025), https://propertyandfreedom.org/as_paf_podcast/pfp300-durr-brief-history-swiss-anarchism-pfs-2025/
  • eigentümlich frei: series “Bürgerlicher Anarchismus” (in German), https://ef-magazin.de/dossier/Anarchismus/
  • Bell, Tom W.: “Polycentric Law,” Humane Studies Review 7 (1991/92), no. 1

Featured image: Background edited

Leave a Comment

Popular:

Tip: press / or Ctrl+K to open search from any page.