Skip to content Skip to footer

Benjamin Franklin: Liberty from the Print Shop

In the fall of 1755, settlements on Pennsylvania’s frontier came under attack. After the raids in the Susquehanna valley, the colony’s elected legislature, the Assembly, wanted to grant money for defense and raise it through a tax that would also fall on the lands of the Penn family. The Penns owned the colony and appointed the governor, and on their instructions he blocked every tax bill that burdened their land. On November 11, the Assembly answered Governor Robert Hunter Morris with a message drafted by a committee whose principal author was presumably Benjamin Franklin. It contains the sentence: “Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.”

Today the sentence is often quoted in debates about surveillance, usually without its history. What it referred to was a concrete bargain: the proprietors held out the prospect of money for the frontier if the Assembly in return gave up its right to tax their land. Franklin was defending the self-government of an elected body against a proprietary family that ruled from afar.

At a glance

  • Life: January 17, 1706, in Boston, to April 17, 1790, in Philadelphia
  • Work: printer and publisher, natural philosopher, member of the Pennsylvania Assembly, agent for the colonies in London, envoy to France, delegate to the Constitutional Convention
  • Major works: Poor Richard’s Almanack (from 1732), “Apology for Printers” (1731), “The Way to Wealth” (1758), An Historical Review of the Constitution and Government of Pensylvania (1759), the Autobiography
  • Signed: the Declaration of Independence (1776), the treaties with France (1778), the Treaty of Paris (1783), the Constitution of the United States (1787)
  • In one sentence: A self-made man of the Enlightenment who defended free speech, encouraged citizens to help themselves, and distrusted power and money alike in government.

From Apprentice to Publisher

Franklin’s father, Josiah, was a soap boiler and candle maker in Boston and had seventeen children from two marriages. By his own account, Benjamin was the youngest son and the third-youngest child. He attended the Latin school for not quite a year, then a school for writing and arithmetic, and at ten his father took him into the shop. At twelve he was apprenticed to his older brother James, a printer, and from then on educated himself mainly by reading.

From 1721, James published the New-England Courant, a cheeky paper that picked fights with Boston’s powerful. The sixteen-year-old Benjamin secretly slipped it letters in the guise of an invented minister’s widow, Silence Dogood. When James spent about a month in jail in 1722 because the paper had criticized the authorities, a Dogood letter appeared shortly after his release that quoted at length from Cato’s Letters, the English polemical essays by John Trenchard and Thomas Gordon. The line often attributed to Franklin, that without freedom of thought there can be no wisdom, comes from this source, which Franklin passed on to his Boston readers.

In 1723 he broke his indenture and went to Philadelphia. After two years as a compositor in London (1724 to 1726), he set up as a printer with Hugh Meredith in 1728, took over the Pennsylvania Gazette in 1729, and from 1732 published Poor Richard’s Almanack. In 1748, at the age of 42, he was able to sell his printing business and devote himself to science and public life. His electrical experiments, among them the famous kite experiment of 1752, earned him the Royal Society’s Copley Medal in 1753.

When Truth and Error Have Fair Play

In 1731 Franklin had printed a handbill for a passage to Barbados whose mocking addition named clergymen and prostitutes in the same breath. Angry readers threatened to withdraw their business. Franklin replied in the Gazette of June 10, 1731, with his “Apology for Printers,” where apology carries its old sense of a defense. Printers, he wrote, are brought up in the belief that both sides should be heard when people differ in opinion, “and that when Truth and Error have fair Play, the former is always an overmatch for the latter.”

He showed the same generosity in matters of faith. As a young man he had become, as he confesses in the Autobiography, “a thorough Deist.” When a large meeting house was built in Philadelphia for the revivalist preacher George Whitefield, it was placed in the hands of trustees for the use of preachers of any denomination. Even a missionary sent by the Mufti of Constantinople, Franklin noted, would have found a pulpit there.

Citizens Who Help Themselves

The institutions he created with like-minded people had a lasting effect. In 1727 he and some friends founded the Junto, a discussion club for mutual improvement. From it the Library Company emerged in 1731: fifty members each paid forty shillings to join plus an annual fee, and used the money to buy books. Franklin later called it “the mother of all the North American subscription libraries.” The Union Fire Company, a volunteer fire brigade, followed in 1736, and later came the American Philosophical Society, an academy that became the University of Pennsylvania, and, with the physician Thomas Bond, the Pennsylvania Hospital. The library and the fire company were purely civic foundations; the academy and the hospital also received public funds.

Telling is how he dealt with his inventions. Governor Thomas offered him a patent for his fuel-saving fireplace stove. Franklin declined, following a principle that, as he writes, had always guided him: since we enjoy great advantages from the inventions of others, we should be glad to serve others with our own, and do so “freely and generously.”

His almanacs spread an ethic of self-reliance that he summed up in 1758 in “The Way to Wealth.” There people complain about the heavy taxes, and old Father Abraham replies that the government’s taxes could still be borne, but idleness taxes us twice as much, pride three times, and folly four times as much. For a time Franklin himself kept a record of thirteen virtues, and he admitted that he never reached perfection but became a better man for the attempt.

Laissez les faire

On economic questions, Franklin stood on the side of open trade. In 1766, writing as “Arator” in a London newspaper, he defended farmers against a ban on grain exports that forced them to sell more cheaply. The same text contains his well-known reflection on poor relief: “I am for doing good to the poor, but I differ in opinion of the means.” The best way to help the poor, he argued, is not to make them comfortable in poverty but to lead or drive them out of it. On his travels, he said, he had observed that the more public provision there was, the less the poor provided for themselves.

He held to this line into old age. When his English friend George Whatley suggested that an American negotiator would need patience to obtain a commercial treaty, Franklin replied in May 1787 that if the treaty did not benefit both sides, it simply should not be made: “Let the merchants on both sides treat with one another. Laissez les faire.” The often-quoted line that no nation was ever ruined by trade, on the other hand, should be handled with care. It appears in notes on Whatley’s Principles of Trade of 1774, which the editor Benjamin Vaughan included in 1806 only with the caveat that they were probably by Franklin or came close to his views.

Power, Money, and a Constitution with Faults

At the Albany Congress of 1754, he promoted a union of the colonies with a common council empowered to levy taxes. The colonial assemblies rejected it or did not take it up at all, and London did not pursue the plan further. In 1766 Franklin was examined by the British House of Commons on the Stamp Act, and in 1776 he sat on the committee that drafted the Declaration of Independence. In Paris he won France as an ally and, with John Adams and John Jay, negotiated the peace of 1783.

He took part in the Constitutional Convention of 1787 at the age of 81. On June 2 he had James Wilson read out a speech, one of his clearest statements on power. Two passions, Franklin said, have a great influence on human affairs: “ambition and avarice; the love of power, and the love of money.” Where an office of honor also promises profit, people will move heaven and earth to get it. He therefore proposed that the head of the executive should only be reimbursed for expenses and draw no salary. The Convention did not follow him; the Constitution provides compensation for the president. Yet the diagnosis reads like an early version of what economists later wrote about the incentives in politics.

On the last day he agreed to the Constitution “with all its faults.” It would likely be well administered for a course of years, he said, and could, like other forms before it, end in despotism only when the people had become so corrupted as to need despotic government.

The Late Fight Against Slavery

The truth about Franklin includes the fact that his household held enslaved people from 1735 to 1790, at least seven of whom are known by name, and that his Gazette printed sale notices and runaway advertisements. Under the influence of Quakers such as John Woolman and Anthony Benezet, and of London’s Somerset ruling of 1772, his thinking changed. From 1787 he was president of the Pennsylvania Abolition Society. On February 3, 1790, he signed in that capacity a petition from the society to Congress, his last public act. In March a committee replied that the Constitution barred any interference with the slave trade before 1808. When Congressman James Jackson of Georgia defended slavery in Congress, the eighty-four-year-old answered with a satire: under the name “Historicus,” he had an invented dignitary in Algiers, in the Federal Gazette of March 25, justify the enslavement of Christians with exactly the same arguments. A few weeks later, on April 17, 1790, he died in Philadelphia.

What friends of liberty can learn from him

The first lesson lies in his most famous sentence, read correctly. Liberty here meant, quite concretely, the right of a community to decide its own taxes.

Just as instructive is his trust in the open contest of opinions: whoever believes that truth wins out in fair play has no need of censorship. And his life shows how much voluntary cooperation can achieve. The library and the fire company came into being because citizens joined forces without waiting for a decree, and his warning against the union of power and money in government has lost none of its edge. That he changed his stance on slavery and spoke out against it publicly in old age also belongs to this picture.

If You Can Keep It

After the Convention ended, a woman is said to have asked Franklin what the delegates had created, a monarchy or a republic. His answer survives only in the notes of the delegate James McHenry, so the anecdote should be read with caution: a republic, if you can keep it. That no constitution secures liberty on its own, Franklin had said himself in his closing speech. It depends on citizens who read, argue, save, join together, and do not let themselves be bought out of their essential rights for a little temporary safety.

Further reading

  • Benjamin Franklin: The Autobiography of Benjamin Franklin, freely available at Project Gutenberg
  • Benjamin Franklin: “Apology for Printers,” Pennsylvania Gazette, June 10, 1731, in: The Papers of Benjamin Franklin, Founders Online
  • Benjamin Franklin: “The Way to Wealth” (1758), in: The Complete Works in Philosophy, Politics and Morals, vol. 3, London 1806
  • Walter Isaacson: Benjamin Franklin. An American Life, Simon & Schuster, New York 2003

This article is part of our series on thinkers, doers, and historical figures of liberty.

Sources

  • Franklin, Benjamin: “Apology for Printers,” Pennsylvania Gazette, June 10, 1731; Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Franklin/01-01-02-0061 (full text also at https://www.southerncrossreview.org/29/franklin.htm)
  • Pennsylvania Assembly (committee including Benjamin Franklin): Reply to the Governor, November 11, 1755, in: Votes and Proceedings of the House of Representatives 1755–1756; Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Franklin/01-06-02-0107
  • Franklin, Benjamin: An Historical Review of the Constitution and Government of Pensylvania, Griffiths, London 1759 (motto on the title page)
  • Franklin, Benjamin (“Arator”): “On the Price of Corn, and Management of the Poor,” London Chronicle, November 27–29, 1766; Founders Online, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Franklin/01-13-02-0194
  • Franklin, Benjamin: “The Way to Wealth” (1758), letter to George Whatley of May 18, 1787, “On the Slave Trade” (Historicus, March 23, 1790), in: The Complete Works in Philosophy, Politics and Morals of the late Dr. Benjamin Franklin, ed. by Benjamin Vaughan, 3 vols., London 1806; Project Gutenberg nos. 48136 to 48138, https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/48137
  • Franklin, Benjamin: The Autobiography of Benjamin Franklin, Project Gutenberg no. 148 (with chronology), https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/148
  • Madison, James: Notes of Debates in the Federal Convention of 1787, sessions of June 2 and September 17, 1787, Avalon Project, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_602.asp and https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/debates_917.asp
  • Constitution of the United States, Art. II, Section 1, National Archives, https://www.archives.gov/founding-docs/constitution-transcript
  • Isaacson, Walter: Benjamin Franklin. An American Life, Simon & Schuster, New York 2003
  • Wittes, Benjamin: “What Ben Franklin Really Said,” Lawfare, https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/what-ben-franklin-really-said
  • Massachusetts Historical Society: Object of the Month, August 2014 (New-England Courant, Silence Dogood), https://www.masshist.org/object-of-the-month/august-2014
  • Office of the Historian, U.S. Department of State: Albany Plan of Union, 1754, https://history.state.gov/milestones/1750-1775/albany-plan ; Treaty of Paris, 1783, https://history.state.gov/milestones/1776-1783/treaty
  • Benjamin Franklin House, London: “Benjamin Franklin and Slavery,” https://benjaminfranklinhouse.org/education/benjamin-franklin-and-slavery/
  • Law & Liberty: “Free Speech and the Rights of Printers,” https://lawliberty.org/?p=45871
  • Wikiquote: Benjamin Franklin (variants and misattributions), https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Benjamin_Franklin
  • Wist Quotations: “Those who would give up essential Liberty …,” https://wist.info/franklin-benjamin/1514

Leave a Comment

Popular:

Tip: press / or Ctrl+K to open search from any page.