Skip to content Skip to footer

Friedrich Schiller: Freedom of the Mind

On September 22, 1782, a young regimental doctor secretly left Stuttgart. Friedrich Schiller was 22 years old and had written a play that had been greeted with enthusiasm in Mannheim. Because he had twice traveled to performances of Die Räuber (The Robbers) without permission, Duke Carl Eugen of Württemberg had put him under arrest for fourteen days and ordered him to give up poetry. Schiller chose poetry over the duke, and with his friend Andreas Streicher he went abroad, which in those days began as close as neighboring Mannheim.

This flight stands at the beginning of a body of work that keeps circling the same question: What may the authorities demand of a person, and where must they remain silent?

At a glance

  • Life: November 10, 1759, in Marbach am Neckar, to May 9, 1805, in Weimar
  • Work: Playwright, poet, historian, and philosopher; professor in Jena in 1789, in Weimar from 1799, close friend of Goethe
  • Major works: Die Räuber (The Robbers, 1781), Don Karlos (Don Carlos, 1787), Geschichte des Abfalls der vereinigten Niederlande (History of the Revolt of the Netherlands, 1788), Die Gesetzgebung des Lykurgus und Solon (The Legislation of Lycurgus and Solon, 1790), Über die ästhetische Erziehung des Menschen (On the Aesthetic Education of Man, 1795), Wilhelm Tell (William Tell, 1804)
  • Honors: French citizenship in 1792, nobility of the Holy Roman Empire in 1802
  • In one sentence: He regarded the state as a means and the free human being who cultivates himself as the end.

A pupil who wanted to belong to himself

Schiller did not enter the school that shaped him of his own free will. At the duke’s demand he had to join the Militär-Pflanzschule, a military academy that later became the Karlsschule, at the beginning of 1773, although his parents had intended him for the clergy. He studied first law, then medicine, graduated in 1780, and afterward served as a regimental doctor. On the side he wrote, and Die Räuber appeared anonymously in print in 1781 before its premiere in Mannheim on January 13, 1782.

After uncertain years of wandering, he was brought to Jena as a professor in 1789 through Goethe’s mediation, and his inaugural lecture drew so many listeners that it had to move to the largest hall of the university. When Schiller fell seriously ill with a lung disease in 1791, two Danish admirers, Duke Friedrich Christian of Augustenburg and Count Ernst Heinrich von Schimmelmann, granted him a pension of 1,000 thalers a year for three years. The money came from private hands, not from a state treasury, and it freed him for some years from having to earn a living, so that he could turn to philosophy.

Freedom of thought before the throne

Schiller put one of the best-known lines in the German literature of liberty into the mouth of a nobleman. In Don Karlos of 1787, the Marquis of Posa stands before King Philip II of Spain. He declines a post at court: “I cannot be the servant of a prince.” Then he demands the unheard-of: “but grant us liberty of thought.” (act 3, scene 10; English text from the translation by R. D. Boylan, Project Gutenberg).

The reasoning Posa gives shortly afterward is remarkable. Creation itself, he says, rests on freedom (“On freedom it is founded”), and the Creator would rather let evil rage than disturb freedom; he conceals himself “within / His own eternal laws.” The king, by contrast, who wants to steer everything, must tremble before every virtue. Posa is thus advising the ruler to follow the example of this restraint; one can read in it the idea of an order that rests on general laws and, within those laws, leaves people a free hand.

A peaceful people against the mightiest king

A year later Schiller turned to the same king as a historian. In Geschichte des Abfalls der vereinigten Niederlande von der spanischen Regierung he tells how the provinces by the sea held their own against Philip II. The introduction alone is a declaration of faith: “Great and reassuring is the thought that against the defiant presumptions of princely power there is, in the end, still a remedy, that its most calculated plans come to nothing against human freedom.”

What interests him is less martial heroism than the perseverance of ordinary people. The Dutch, he writes, had been “the most peaceable in this part of the world,” a nation of fishermen and herdsmen for whom “a free poverty” was “its highest good.” Precisely because ordinary citizens here withstood a world empire, he calls his book a “monument to civic strength.”

The state is never an end

This thinking found its clearest expression in an essay that appeared under Schiller’s name in 1790 in his journal Thalia and grew out of his lectures in Jena: Die Gesetzgebung des Lykurgus und Solon. The Allgemeine Deutsche Biographie, the older German national biography, attributed the part on Lycurgus in 1890 to his Stuttgart teacher Johann Jakob Heinrich Nast; more recent scholarship and the editions of his works treat the entire essay as Schiller’s text. In it Schiller compares Sparta with Athens and measures both constitutions against a standard that he names explicitly.

The decisive sentence reads: “The state itself is never an end; it is important only as a condition under which the end of humanity can be fulfilled, and this end of humanity is none other than the development of all the powers of man, progress.” Immediately before, he writes that everything may be sacrificed to the welfare of the state, “except that to which the state itself serves only as a means.”

In Sparta, Schiller shows what happens when this order is reversed. The state took children from their parents and became, as he writes, “the father of his child.” The helots who worked the land were “regarded as equal to cattle,” and the law code itself, he says, preached the principle “of regarding human beings as means and not as ends.” Solon, by contrast, he praises (to paraphrase him) for respecting human nature and letting the state serve the human being.

Schiller was not alone with these questions. In 1792 his friend Wilhelm von Humboldt, in close exchange with him, wrote Ideen zu einem Versuch, die Grenzen der Wirksamkeit des Staats zu bestimmen (in English, The Limits of State Action); parts of it appeared in Schiller’s Neue Thalia, the whole book only in 1851. And how strongly Schiller’s pages on Sparta resonated became clear a good 150 years later: in the summer of 1942 the first leaflet of the White Rose, a student resistance group in Munich, quoted them at length, including the sentence about the state that is never an end.

Force annuls the human being

What limits the state, for Schiller, is the dignity of the individual, and he defines that dignity through the will. His essay Über das Erhabene (On the Sublime) opens with a line he borrows from Lessing’s Nathan: “No one has to have to” (“Kein Mensch muß müssen”). Schiller takes it further: “All other things must; man is the being that wills. For this very reason nothing is so unworthy of man as to suffer force, for force annuls him.”

In this view coercion is wrong because it extinguishes the human being as an acting being. The same conviction carries the poem Die Worte des Glaubens (The Words of Faith) of 1797, whose lines are often quoted in shortened form. The original reads: “Man is created free, is free, / Even were he born in chains.”

Beauty as a school of freedom

Schiller followed the course of the French Revolution with concern. In 1792 France granted him citizenship, together with other men who had rendered great service to the cause of liberty; the diploma reached him only in 1798. In that same year, 1792, he was considering a plan to write a defense of Louis XVI.

His real answer to the Revolution is the letters Über die ästhetische Erziehung des Menschen, which grew out of letters to his patron Augustenburg and appeared in 1795 in the journal Die Horen. In the fifth letter he describes the historical moment in which it seemed possible “to honor man at length as an end, and to make true freedom the basis of political union.” But the opportunity, he says, was wasted: “The moral possibility is wanting,” and the generous moment found a generation unable to receive it.

From this follows his program. A free order cannot be decreed; it needs people who know how to handle freedom, and according to Schiller this ability grows above all through engagement with the beautiful. In the second letter he writes that one must take the path through the aesthetic “because it is through beauty that we arrive at freedom.” The fifteenth contains the famous sentence that man “only plays when in the full meaning of the word he is a man, and he is only completely a man when he plays,” where play means the activity in which sensuous nature and reason come together without coercion.

Schiller also saw the dark sides of the modern world. In the sixth letter he laments that man, “eternally chained down to a little fragment of the whole,” forms only “a kind of fragment,” and he describes the state as an ingenious piece of clockwork. The lament applies to the specialization of labor as much as to the mechanical administrative state. Schiller worried that a person who tends only one part no longer develops the whole of his powers. As a counter-image, in the last, the 27th letter, he sketches an “aesthetic state” of free association whose fundamental law reads: “To give freedom through freedom is the fundamental law of this realm.”

Tell and the eternal rights

His last completed drama returns to politics. In Wilhelm Tell of 1804, men from Schwyz, Uri, and Unterwalden meet at night on the Rütli meadow to ally themselves against the arbitrary rule of the Habsburg bailiffs. Stauffacher justifies their right in lines that are still among the most quoted in the play: “Yes! there’s a limit to the despot’s power! / When the oppress’d for justice looks in vain,” he says. Then the oppressed man appeals to heaven and brings down “his everlasting rights, / Which there abide, inalienably his.”

What stands out is how measured this uprising remains. The Swiss Confederates appeal to their property, “By the possession of a thousand years / The soil is ours,” and to inherited law. Walther Fürst makes it explicit that they want “to keep our ancient rights inviolate,” and that “lawless innovation” is not their aim; whoever owes dues to a lord should go on paying them. Resistance here is self-defense against injustice, not a blueprint for a new society.

What friends of liberty can learn from him

Schiller was not an economist, and you will not find a theory of the market in his work. With great force of language he set down that the state serves the human being and not the other way around, and he demonstrated this idea with the example of Sparta so vividly that anyone can understand it.

Just as valuable is his distrust of the idea that liberty can be produced by one great upheaval. For him, freedom needs people who cultivate themselves and sharpen their judgment, and no lawgiver can do this work for them. Added to this is his trust in the ordinary citizen: his heroes of Dutch history are fishermen and herdsmen, his Swiss Confederates are farmers. His own life fits the picture: the young man whose sovereign forbade him to write poetry chose to accept uncertainty rather than obey.

A poet for free citizens

Schiller’s concept of freedom joins two things that are often treated separately today: outward freedom from coercion and the inner ability to make something of that freedom. The first he defends against princes, bailiffs, and the all-powerful state of Sparta. The second he demands of every individual. Anyone who reads Posa’s plea for freedom of thought today may wonder which powers have since taken the place of the Spanish king, and whether they themselves would be ready to make that plea as politely and as steadfastly.

Further reading

  • Friedrich Schiller: Die Gesetzgebung des Lykurgus und Solon (1790), freely available at Projekt Gutenberg (in German)
  • Friedrich Schiller: Über die ästhetische Erziehung des Menschen in einer Reihe von Briefen (1795), Reclam, Stuttgart (in German); in English: On the Aesthetic Education of Man, ed. and translated by Elizabeth M. Wilkinson and L. A. Willoughby, Clarendon Press, Oxford 1967
  • Wilhelm von Humboldt: Ideen zu einem Versuch, die Grenzen der Wirksamkeit des Staats zu bestimmen (1792, printed 1851), Reclam, Stuttgart (in German); in English: The Limits of State Action, ed. J. W. Burrow, Cambridge University Press
  • Rüdiger Safranski: Friedrich Schiller oder Die Erfindung des Deutschen Idealismus, Hanser, Munich 2004 (in German)

This article is part of our series on thinkers, doers, and historical figures of liberty.

Sources

  • Schiller, Friedrich: Don Karlos, Infant von Spanien (1787), act 3, scene 10; text from Projekt Gutenberg (in German), https://projekt-gutenberg.org/authors/friedrich-schiller/books/friedrich-schiller-don-carlos-infant-von-spanien; English text: Don Carlos, translated by R. D. Boylan, Project Gutenberg, https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/6789
  • Schiller, Friedrich: Geschichte des Abfalls der vereinigten Niederlande von der spanischen Regierung (1788), introduction; Projekt Gutenberg (in German), https://projekt-gutenberg.org/authors/friedrich-schiller/books/geschichte-des-abfalls-der-vereinigten-niederlande/chapter/3
  • Schiller, Friedrich: Die Gesetzgebung des Lykurgus und Solon, in: Thalia, vol. 3, no. 11, Göschen, Leipzig 1790, pp. 30–82; Projekt Gutenberg (in German), https://projekt-gutenberg.org/authors/friedrich-schiller/books/friedrich-schiller-die-gesetzgebung-des-lykurgus-und-solon; Wikisource (in German), https://de.wikisource.org/wiki/Die_Gesetzgebung_des_Lykurgus_und_Solon
  • Schiller, Friedrich: Über die ästhetische Erziehung des Menschen in einer Reihe von Briefen (1795, Die Horen), letters 2, 5, 6, 15, and 27; Projekt Gutenberg (in German), https://projekt-gutenberg.org/authors/friedrich-schiller/books/friedrich-schiller-ueber-die-aesthetische-erziehung-des-menschen; English text: Letters on the Aesthetical Education of Man, in: Aesthetical Essays of Friedrich Schiller, Project Gutenberg, https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/6798
  • Schiller, Friedrich: Die Worte des Glaubens (1797) and Das Lied von der Glocke (1799), in: Gedichte; Projekt Gutenberg (in German), https://projekt-gutenberg.org/authors/friedrich-schiller/books/gedichte
  • Schiller, Friedrich: Über das Erhabene (1801); Projekt Gutenberg (in German), https://projekt-gutenberg.org/authors/friedrich-schiller/books/friedrich-schiller-ueber-das-erhabene
  • Schiller, Friedrich: Wilhelm Tell (1804), act 1, scene 3, and act 2, scene 2; Projekt Gutenberg (in German), https://projekt-gutenberg.org/authors/friedrich-schiller/books/friedrich-schiller-wilhelm-tell; English text: William Tell, translated by Theodore Martin, Project Gutenberg, https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/2782
  • Humboldt, Wilhelm von: Ideen zu einem Versuch, die Grenzen der Wirksamkeit des Staats zu bestimmen (1792), Trewendt, Breslau 1851; Reclam, Stuttgart (in German)
  • White Rose: first leaflet (1942); Projekt Gutenberg (in German), https://www.projekt-gutenberg.org/weissros/flugblae/chap001.html
  • Oellers, Norbert: article “Schiller, Friedrich von,” in: Neue Deutsche Biographie 22 (2005); Fischer, Hermann: article “Schiller, Friedrich,” in: Allgemeine Deutsche Biographie (1890); both at https://www.deutsche-biographie.de/sfz45355.html (in German)
  • Petersen, Jens: Friedrich Schiller über die Gesetzgebung des Lykurgus und Solon, in: Petersen, Studien zur juristischen Ideengeschichte, Universitätsverlag Potsdam 2023, pp. 131–147, https://publishup.uni-potsdam.de/files/60429/petersen_S131-147.pdf (in German)
  • Alt, Peter-André: Schiller. Leben – Werk – Zeit, 2 vols., C.H. Beck, Munich 2000 (in German)
  • Safranski, Rüdiger: Friedrich Schiller oder Die Erfindung des Deutschen Idealismus, Hanser, Munich 2004 (in German)
  • Wikipedia (in German): Friedrich Schiller, https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedrich_Schiller (life, ennoblement)
  • Mises Wire: Wilhelm von Humboldt’s Demarcation of the Limits of State Activity, https://mises.org/wire/wilhelm-von-humboldts-demarcation-limits-state-activity

Leave a Comment

Popular:

Tip: press / or Ctrl+K to open search from any page.