When Isabel Paterson retired, she could have drawn Social Security benefits. She refused them. She put her Social Security card in an envelope on which she wrote the words “Social Security Swindle.” The gesture suits a woman who had lived from her own work since the age of eighteen and who coined the line that your own paycheck is mother and father to you (your paycheck is your mother and your father).
Paterson is one of the three women whom the writer Jim Powell described as pioneers of the modern libertarian movement in America. In 1943 three books appeared that are still regarded as cornerstones of that movement: Ayn Rand’s novel The Fountainhead, Rose Wilder Lane’s The Discovery of Freedom, and Paterson’s The God of the Machine. Her biographer Stephen Cox described the difference this way: libertarian readers turned to Lane for feeling and to Paterson for intellectual challenge.
At a glance
- Life: January 22, 1886, on Manitoulin Island (Ontario, Canada), to January 10, 1961, in Montclair (New Jersey)
- Birth name: Isabel Mary Bowler
- Work: novelist, literary critic for the New York Herald Tribune (column “Turns With a Bookworm,” 1924 to 1949), political thinker
- Major work: The God of the Machine (1943)
- Novels (selection): The Shadow Riders (1916), The Magpie’s Nest (1917), The Golden Vanity (1934), If It Prove Fair Weather (1940)
- In one sentence: She described free society as a circuit of human energy that government can protect but cannot direct.
From the Ranch to the Newsroom
Isabel Bowler was born on an island in Lake Huron, one of nine children of a poor farming family that later moved to Michigan, Utah, and Alberta. She hardly attended school; she educated herself, with the Bible, Shakespeare, Dickens, and Dumas. At about eighteen she left home and worked as a waitress, stenographer, and bookkeeper.
In Spokane she became secretary to the publisher of the Inland Herald and soon wrote its editorials, later theater reviews in Vancouver. In 1910 she married Kenneth Birrell Paterson; the marriage soon broke up, but she kept the name. In 1912 she flew along as a passenger when the pilot Harry Bingham Brown set an altitude record, and she later called it the greatest experience of her life. Her first novels, The Shadow Riders and The Magpie’s Nest, appeared in 1916 and 1917.
After the First World War she went to New York. In the early 1920s she talked Burton Rascoe, the literary editor of the New York Tribune, into hiring her, and from 1924 on she wrote the column “Turns With a Bookworm” in the literary supplement of the Herald Tribune, signed with her initials, I.M.P. For a quarter of a century she used books as an occasion to write about politics as well. She defended American individualism and criticized first the interventions of Herbert Hoover, then Franklin D. Roosevelt’s New Deal. In 1928 she became an American citizen.
Society as an Electrical Circuit
The God of the Machine was published in May 1943 by Putnam in New York. For her political philosophy Paterson chose an image from the technology of her time: a society works like an electrical circuit. “In the social organization, man is the dynamo, in his productive capacity,” she writes (chapter IX, p. 82). Government, by contrast, is an “end-appliance” that consumes energy but generates none.
The further the division of labor, trade, money, and credit extend, the longer the circuit becomes, which Paterson calls the “long circuit.” Even the lone fur trapper on the frontier, as she shows with an example (chapter XVI, p. 167), is connected through trade with people he will never see. For such a circuit to hold across time and distance, contracts must be kept and property must be secure. Private property, she writes, “is the inductor which initiates the flow” (chapter VI, p. 62).
Her understanding of government follows from this image. In her words, “Government is an agent, not an entity” (p. 89), and it is necessary only to the extent that people do not of their own accord respect their agreements and the equal liberty of others. Paterson was therefore no anarchist. One chapter bears the title “The Fallacy of Anarchism”: self-government consists in keeping promises, and a government is instituted to enforce contracts voluntarily entered into. She gave the American Founders credit for having searched for the form of the smallest possible government.
She considered any plan that orders life from above hopeless, because the creative forces, as she writes, do not work on command (p. 89). The reviewer Marcus Witcher pointed out in Reason that she thereby anticipated ideas of Ludwig von Mises and Friedrich August von Hayek, whom hardly anyone in America knew at the time. Hayek’s The Road to Serfdom did not appear until the following year.
Status or Contract
Paterson read history as a contest between two orders. She took the pair of concepts from the English legal historian Henry Sumner Maine: in a society of status everyone has a fixed place and obeys; in a society of contract free people deal with one another. “In the Society of Status nobody has any rights,” she states flatly (p. 42). Fascism, National Socialism, and communism were for her, as Jim Powell sums it up, varieties of the same collectivism.
She is remarkably clear on the question of slavery, which she calls a monstrous combination of status and contract (p. 67). She devotes an entire chapter to it, “Slavery, the Fault in the Structure,” treating it as a flaw in the American Constitution, which thereby contained an irreconcilable contradiction (p. 135). Another chapter, “The Fatal Amendments,” condemns among others the amendment that permitted the federal income tax and the one that took the election of senators away from the state legislatures.
The Humanitarian with the Guillotine
The best-known chapter of the book is called “The Humanitarian with the Guillotine.” It opens with a sentence that is often quoted: “Most of the harm in the world is done by good people, and not by accident, lapse, or omission” (p. 235). It is, she continues, the result of their deliberate actions, long persevered in, which in their conviction serve high ideals.
Paterson is explicitly not attacking charity. She values the charity of the churches and religious orders because it is voluntary and is given from the surplus of production, for without production there would be nothing to distribute (p. 239). Her objection is to the person who makes helping others his purpose in life and claims the means of others for it. Whoever thinks this way needs the needy: his “ultimate good requires that others shall be in want” (p. 241). Whoever on this basis wants to decide for others what is good for them ends up resorting to coercion. “It is at this point,” she writes, “that the humanitarian sets up the guillotine” (p. 241).
School, Conscription, and Money
With the same consistency Paterson opposed compulsory government schooling. “A tax-supported, compulsory educational system is the complete model of the totalitarian state,” she writes in the chapter on education (p. 258). The sentence targets two features at once, tax funding and compulsion: the state determines what children learn, and everyone pays for it, whether they want its schools or not.
She rejected conscription just as firmly. The argument that it is fair because it falls on everyone equally would, in her words, also justify torture, provided it were applied evenly (p. 119, footnote). She devoted a chapter to money with the title “Why Real Money Is Indispensable.” According to Jim Powell, she also argued that the New Deal prolonged the Great Depression.
Mentor to a Generation
In the late 1930s Paterson gathered a circle of younger writers around her, among them Ayn Rand. Rand sat with her while she proofread the galleys of her column, and Paterson passed on to her books and knowledge of American history, economics, and political philosophy. Rand’s niece Mimi Sutton remembered Paterson as “the guru and teacher.” After The Fountainhead came out, Paterson promoted the novel in several columns, and Rand praised The God of the Machine in the highest terms.
The journalist John Chamberlain, too, found his way with her help from socialism to libertarian convictions, and Paterson brought him together with Leonard Read, the founder of the Foundation for Economic Education. In the 1940s she corresponded with the young Russell Kirk, in the 1950s with William F. Buckley, and for a time she wrote for his National Review herself.
Paterson was a combative woman, and some friendships did not survive it. She broke with Rose Wilder Lane in 1946. She did not share Lane’s idea of the brotherhood of all men; Stalin, she countered, was not her brother. She fell out with Rand in 1948, and one constant point of dispute between the two was religion. Paterson considered a reference to God necessary to ground natural rights, and wrote that the Christian idea had been necessary for the concept of liberty (p. 70). When National Review later panned Rand’s novel Atlas Shrugged, Paterson took issue with the review.
In 1949 she lost her column at the Herald Tribune, according to Powell because of her political views. After that she lived on a small pension and on savings she had invested in real estate, and she died on January 10, 1961, in Montclair, New Jersey, in the home of Muriel Hall.
What friends of liberty can learn from her
Paterson’s image of the circuit draws attention to a fact that is easily forgotten in political debate: prosperity arises where people work, invent, and trade, and every rule that interrupts this flow has costs, even if they are not visible right away. Government can protect the circuit by securing contracts and property, but it cannot add any energy that someone has not first generated.
Her warning about the humanitarian with the guillotine is aimed at a temptation every age knows. For her, helping others explicitly remains a virtue, but she insists on asking with whose means and by what right the help is given. Anyone who asks this question becomes wary of many well-meant programs that are planned over the heads of the very people they are meant to serve.
Finally, her life shows that liberty does not require an academic career. A woman who had barely any schooling as a child read her way through history from Rome to the present and wrote a book that still challenges serious thinkers today.
A Forgotten Mother
That Isabel Paterson is less well known than Ayn Rand is partly due to her book. The God of the Machine is dense, idiosyncratic, and full of technical imagery, and it sold far worse than The Fountainhead. Those who make the effort will find in it a coherent view of liberty and property, written at a time when almost everyone was putting their faith in planning. The Mises Institute now makes the book freely available to read, and Stephen Cox has devoted a thorough biography to her, The Woman and the Dynamo. Her greatest influence may have come through the conversations and letters with which she got others thinking, from Ayn Rand to John Chamberlain.
Further reading
- Isabel Paterson: The God of the Machine, G. P. Putnam’s Sons, New York 1943 (available online from the Mises Institute)
- Stephen Cox: The Woman and the Dynamo: Isabel Paterson and the Idea of America, Transaction Publishers, New Brunswick 2004
- Timothy Sandefur: Freedom’s Furies: How Isabel Paterson, Rose Wilder Lane, and Ayn Rand Found Liberty in an Age of Darkness, Cato Institute, Washington 2022
This article is part of our series on thinkers, doers, and historical figures of liberty.
Sources
- Paterson, Isabel: The God of the Machine, G. P. Putnam’s Sons, New York 1943; facsimile at the Ludwig von Mises Institute, https://cdn.mises.org/God%20of%20the%20Machine_2.pdf (catalog: https://mises.org/library/god-machine). Passages cited include ch. VI (p. 62), VIII (pp. 71 f.), IX (pp. 82, 89), XII (p. 119, footnote), XIII (p. 135), XV (pp. 157 ff.), XX (pp. 235–241), XXI (p. 258).
- Paterson, Isabel: column “Turns With a Bookworm,” New York Herald Tribune, literary supplement Books, 1924–1949.
- Isabel M. Paterson Papers, Herbert Hoover Presidential Library, West Branch (Iowa), finding aid: https://hoover.archives.gov/research/manuscript-collections/paterson
- Cox, Stephen: The Woman and the Dynamo: Isabel Paterson and the Idea of America, Transaction Publishers, New Brunswick 2004 (consulted via French’s review and Wikipedia).
- French, Douglas E.: “Isabel Paterson’s Place in History,” Mises Daily, June 20, 2011, https://mises.org/library/isabel-patersons-place-history
- Powell, Jim: “Rose Wilder Lane, Isabel Paterson, and Ayn Rand: Three Women Who Inspired the Modern Libertarian Movement,” Foundation for Economic Education, May 1, 1996, https://fee.org/articles/rose-wilder-lane-isabel-paterson-and-ayn-rand-three-women-who-inspired-the-modern-libertarian-movement
- Witcher, Marcus: “The Founding Mothers of Libertarianism” (review of Timothy Sandefur, Freedom’s Furies), Reason, February 11, 2023, https://reason.com/2023/02/11/the-founding-mothers-of-libertarianism/
- Sandefur, Timothy: Freedom’s Furies: How Isabel Paterson, Rose Wilder Lane, and Ayn Rand Found Liberty in an Age of Darkness, Cato Institute, Washington 2022, https://www.cato.org/books/freedoms-furies
- Acton Institute: “Isabel Paterson (1886–1961),” Religion & Liberty, vol. 25, no. 2, 2015, https://acton.org/isabel-paterson-1886-1961
- Wikipedia (en): Isabel Paterson, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isabel_Paterson (starting point only)

