Skip to content Skip to footer

Harriet Martineau: Economics in Stories

Harriet Martineau

In July 1841, Prime Minister Lord Melbourne had a government pension of 150 pounds a year offered to an ailing writer. Harriet Martineau had been lying ill for more than a year in a lodging house in Tynemouth, in the north of England; she was short of money and dependent on help from relatives. Even so, she declined. As long as taxes were levied so unequally and Parliament had no say in the granting of pensions, she would sooner accept support from her parish if it came to that: this is how her biographer Florence Fenwick Miller renders the letter to the minister. Anyone who felt indebted to a writer, she added, should show it by working for better copyright arrangements.

Behind this answer lay a second thought: whoever takes money from a government feels obliged to it and is seen by the public as bound. For a woman who made her living from independent judgment on politics, that was out of the question. Two years later, friends raised 1,400 pounds for her, and this help she accepted.

At a glance

  • Life: June 12, 1802, in Norwich to June 27, 1876, in Ambleside (Lake District)
  • Work: Writer, journalist, and traveler; leader writer for the London Daily News from 1852 to 1866
  • Major works: Illustrations of Political Economy (1832 to 1834), Society in America (1837), How to Observe. Morals and Manners (1838), Autobiography (posthumous, 1877)
  • Causes: Free trade, abolition of slavery, women’s rights, limits on state paternalism
  • In one sentence: She brought classical political economy to readers who would never have opened a textbook.

A family without means

Martineau was the sixth of eight children of a textile manufacturer in Norwich. The family was of Huguenot descent and belonged to the Unitarians, a small Protestant denomination. While still a schoolgirl she began to lose her hearing, and later she communicated with the help of an ear trumpet. After her father’s death in 1826 she became engaged to a college friend of her brother James, but the young man fell seriously ill and died a few months later. She remained unmarried all her life.

In 1829 the bank that held the family fortune collapsed, and the family was left penniless. Martineau concluded that she would live by her pen, at first from reviews for the Monthly Repository, which earned her 15 pounds a year.

Adam Smith for everyone

In the preface to her first major project, she wrote that political economy deals with how the necessaries of daily life can best be obtained and enjoyed by all, and yet the great mass of people hardly study it. Smith’s Wealth of Nations, she said, was a great book, but it was not made to teach the science to the whole people. Her answer was a series of tales, in each of which one principle becomes visible through characters in action, with a brief summary of the principles at the end.

In February 1832 the publisher Charles Fox ventured a first printing of 1,500 copies. James Mill, the father of John Stuart Mill, had advised him against it and later admitted his mistake. By February 1834, 25 numbers had appeared, collected in nine volumes, and sales rose to about ten thousand copies, many times what ordinary novels achieved. Some critics even attributed the installments to Lord Brougham.

The stories begin with the simple things. Life in the Wilds is set in a settlement in southern Africa whose tools and stores have been destroyed in a raid; the survivors rediscover what the division of labor and exchange can achieve. In Brooke and Brooke Farm a common pasture goes to ruin because no one feels responsible for it, until it passes into private property and its former users are compensated. What economists later called the tragedy of the commons appears here as a village story.

Trade as a shared gain

In the final volume, The Moral of Many Fables (1834), Martineau summed up her teaching. Trade was valuable, she argued, because regular exchange extended the division of labor and saved capital, to the advantage of both sides. She called the old commercial treaties a “child’s-play of universal circumvention” and expected that “fewer examples will be henceforth seen of nations keeping themselves poor, lest their neighbouring customers should grow rich.”

For the great bazaar of the Anti-Corn Law League in 1845 she wrote the tale Dawn Island, whose proceeds went to the movement against the grain tariffs. Her biographer also reports that through her letters she helped reconcile Robert Peel and Richard Cobden personally.

No human being as property

In the 1833 number Demerara, and once more in the final volume, Martineau joined economics to a moral principle. Property rests on agreement; since the slave never consented to any such agreement, it follows that “man has no right to hold man in property.” Slave labor, moreover, wasted labor and capital and survived only thanks to government tariffs on the sugar of free competitors, which the British paid for at home. Free trade in sugar, she concluded, would drive out slavery altogether.

How seriously she meant it became clear in America, where she traveled from 1834 to 1836. She arrived in Boston on the day in October 1835 when a mob broke up a meeting of the Boston Female Anti-Slavery Society and nearly killed William Lloyd Garrison in the open street. A month later she went to the next meeting all the same, was unexpectedly asked to say a few words, and, as the official report put it, declared her full sympathy with the society’s principles “with great dignity and simplicity of manner.” The consequences were serious: newspapers in the South called her a foreign incendiary, and she canceled a trip down the Ohio after being warned of a plan to hang her in Louisville.

During the American Civil War she wrote so persistently for the Union cause in the Daily News that the politician William Edward Forster said, as her biographer Fenwick Miller quotes him, “it was Harriet Martineau alone who was keeping English public opinion about America on the right side through the press.”

The consent of the governed

In Society in America (1837), Martineau took the republic at its word. The chapter on the political non-existence of women opens with the principle of the Declaration of Independence that governments derive their just powers from the consent of the governed. How, she asked, could it be reconciled with this that governments tax women, dispose of their property upon marriage, and punish them, without any woman ever having consented to a single law? “The case is so plain,” she wrote, “that I might close it here.”

She lived what she demanded: unmarried, economically independent, with a public voice of her own. In 1856 she signed the petition organized by Barbara Leigh Smith for the property rights of married women. In old age she opposed the Contagious Diseases Acts, which allowed police and doctors in port and garrison towns to have women forcibly examined and detained. In 1869 she wrote against them in the Daily News, and at the turn of the year 1869/70 her name stood beneath the women’s protest that the same paper printed.

Knowing a society by its institutions

The American journey also produced a small book on method, How to Observe. Morals and Manners (1838). Its central rule reads: “The grand secret of wise inquiry into Morals and Manners is to begin with the study of THINGS, using the DISCOURSE OF PERSONS as a commentary upon them.” By things she means institutions and records such as registers, buildings, and epitaphs, in which the actions of many people leave their trace.

In the chapter on the idea of liberty she writes that “blind, ignorant obedience to any ruling power which the subjects had no hand in constituting” is “the feudal temper,” whether the subservience is yielded to the owner of an estate or to “the sovereign of the country, represented by his police or soldiery.”

Beware of well-meant laws

Martineau remained wary of government direction. In 1855 she wrote an essay against what she called meddling legislation in the factories. The Westminster Review rejected it because it attacked the supporters of the Factory Acts too openly, among them Charles Dickens and his magazine Household Words. It appeared as a pamphlet under the title The Factory Controversy and influenced the debate on a bill. Shortly afterward she warned in another essay that the attempt to prevent personal vices by law meant falling back behind the principles of 1688.

Not all of her positions have held up as well. In 1833 and 1834 she wrote tales for Lord Brougham in support of the Poor Law reform, which introduced a central commission and deterrent workhouses, and in the number Weal and Woe in Garveloch she defended the population theory of Malthus, which drew fierce attacks on her. The Poor Law reform itself fell into disrepute as early as the 1840s because of conditions in some workhouses.

A life by her own pen

In 1845 she bought land in Ambleside in the Lake District and built a house to her own design, The Knoll, where she lived for thirty years. She translated and condensed the six volumes of Auguste Comte’s Cours de philosophie positive into two volumes so clear that Comte recommended her version to his students instead of his original. From 1852 to 1866 she wrote more than 1,600 leading articles for the Daily News. In 1873 Gladstone offered her a pension, and she declined this one too, for the old reasons and because she did not want to expose the Queen and the prime minister to the charge of favoring an unbeliever. She died on June 27, 1876, in her house in Ambleside.

What friends of liberty can learn from her

Martineau showed that good arguments need storytellers. The reasons for the division of labor, free trade, and secure property had long been set out by Adam Smith, but only stories about settlers, farmers, and plantation workers brought them to life for a broad audience. Anyone who makes the case for liberty today will find in her a model of arguing through concrete people and concrete consequences.

She also shows how closely economic and personal freedom are linked. The same principle that justifies free exchange forbids holding a human being as property, and the same demand for the consent of the governed that America raised against the king applied, in her view, to women as well. The economists David Levy and Sandra Peart therefore see in her one of the great advocates of the natural equality on which classical liberalism rests: there are no people who are superior by nature and entitled to rule over the rest.

And finally there is her life itself. A nearly deaf woman without fortune and without a husband became, in nineteenth-century England, one of the most widely read writers on public affairs in her country, and she preserved her independence by turning down a government pension more than once, the first time in the middle of her own financial hardship. Anyone who reads one of her short tales today will quickly understand why so many readers waited for the next number.

Further reading

  • Harriet Martineau: Illustrations of Political Economy, 9 volumes, Charles Fox, London 1832 to 1834 (freely available at Project Gutenberg)
  • Harriet Martineau: Society in America, Saunders and Otley, London 1837
  • David M. Levy and Sandra J. Peart: “Harriet Martineau,” in: The Essential Women of Liberty, Fraser Institute, Vancouver 2023
  • Florence Fenwick Miller: Harriet Martineau, Roberts Brothers, Boston 1887 (first published 1884)

This article is part of our series on thinkers, doers, and historical figures of liberty.

Sources

  • Martineau, Harriet: Illustrations of Political Economy, 9 vols., Charles Fox, London 1832–1834; including Life in the Wilds, Brooke and Brooke Farm, Demerara, Weal and Woe in Garveloch, and The Moral of Many Fables (vol. IX, 1834), https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/76102
  • Martineau, Harriet: Poor Laws and Paupers Illustrated, Charles Fox, London 1833–1834.
  • Martineau, Harriet: Society in America, 2 vols., Saunders and Otley, New York/London 1837, https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/52621 and https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/52685
  • Martineau, Harriet: How to Observe. Morals and Manners, Charles Knight, London 1838, https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/33944
  • Martineau, Harriet: Dawn Island. A Tale, 1845 (for the bazaar of the Anti-Corn Law League).
  • Martineau, Harriet (trans.): The Positive Philosophy of Auguste Comte, 2 vols., John Chapman, London 1853.
  • Martineau, Harriet: The Factory Controversy. A Warning against Meddling Legislation, 1855 (published, according to the Birmingham archive catalog, by the National Association of Factory Occupiers).
  • Martineau, Harriet: Autobiography, with Memorials by Maria Weston Chapman, Smith, Elder & Co., London 1877.
  • Stephen, Leslie: “Martineau, Harriet,” in: Dictionary of National Biography, vol. 36, London 1893, https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Dictionary_of_National_Biography,_1885-1900/Martineau,_Harriet
  • Fenwick Miller, Florence: Harriet Martineau (Eminent Women Series), Roberts Brothers, Boston 1887 (Copyright 1884), https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/36965
  • Levy, David M.; Peart, Sandra J.: “Harriet Martineau (1802–1876),” in: The Essential Women of Liberty, Fraser Institute, Vancouver 2023, pp. 17–29, https://www.essentialscholars.org/sites/default/files/2023-01/essential-women-of-liberty-ch2-harriet-martineau.pdf
  • Logan, Deborah Anna: The Hour and the Woman. Harriet Martineau’s “Somewhat Remarkable” Life, Northern Illinois University Press, DeKalb 2002.
  • Hill, Michael R.; Hoecker-Drysdale, Susan (eds.): Harriet Martineau. Theoretical and Methodological Perspectives, Routledge, New York 2001.
  • Reading Garrison’s Letters: “Harriet Martineau, and Moses Brown” (letter from W. L. Garrison, November 27, 1835), https://www.readinggarrisonsletters.com/?p=63
  • Dickens Journals Online: Harriet Martineau (author page) and “Our Wicked Mis-statements” (Household Words, 1856), https://djo.org.uk/indexes/authors/harriet-martineau.html
  • Wikipedia (en): Harriet Martineau, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harriet_Martineau (checked for dates, the 1856 petition, and print runs)
  • Wikipedia (en): Poor Law Amendment Act 1834, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poor_Law_Amendment_Act_1834
  • Wikipedia (en): Ladies National Association for the Repeal of the Contagious Diseases Acts, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ladies_National_Association_for_the_Repeal_of_the_Contagious_Diseases_Acts
  • Spartacus Educational: Harriet Martineau, https://spartacus-educational.com/Wmartineau.htm

Featured image: Harriet Martineau (AI illustration)

Leave a Comment

Popular:

Tip: press / or Ctrl+K to open search from any page.