Skip to content Skip to footer

Sophocles: Antigone and the Unwritten Law

Sophocles

Outside the walls of Thebes lies a dead man, and no one may bury him. Polynices has fallen fighting against his own city, in single combat with his brother Eteocles, and the new ruler, Creon, has decreed that his body be left to the dogs and the birds. Whoever defies the order is to die. Polynices’ sister Antigone scatters earth over the dead man anyway, is caught, and is brought before Creon.

What she says there ranks among the most consequential lines in world literature. Creon’s decree, she tells him, is not strong enough to override the unwritten statutes of the gods. The scene was written by a man who served his city in high office for decades. That he of all people put these words in Antigone’s mouth gives them a weight of their own.

At a glance

  • Life: born around 497/496 BC in Colonus near Athens, died in the winter of 406/405 BC
  • Work: tragic poet in Athens; also treasurer of the Delian League’s common fund (443/442), general alongside Pericles (441/440), and from 413 probably one of the ten probouloi
  • Works: according to ancient tradition about 120 plays, seven of which survive complete, among them Antigone, Oedipus the King, Electra, and Oedipus at Colonus
  • Successes: 24 victories in 30 competitions, never placing lower than second
  • In one sentence: With Antigone he gave shape to the question of whether there is a law above the ruler’s command by which that command must be measured.

A poet in the service of his city

Sophocles, son of Sophilus, grew up in the deme of Colonus just outside Athens. His life spanned almost the entire great century of his city, and he combined writing poetry with a long series of public offices.

In Athens, tragedies were performed at the festivals of Dionysus, in competitions organized by the polis itself. Sophocles competed there thirty times, won 24 times, and never placed lower than second. Ancient sources put his output at between 118 and 130 plays; seven survive. He is also credited with an innovation in staging: he introduced a third actor, so that more characters could speak with one another at the same time.

He also took on public duties. A partially restored inscription lists Sophocles of Colonus for the year 443/442 BC among the Hellenotamiai, the treasurers who managed the contributions of the allies in the Delian League. In 441/440 BC the Athenians elected him one of the ten strategoi, or generals, and he campaigned alongside Pericles against Samos, which had broken away. After the disaster of the Sicilian Expedition in 413 BC, he was, as most scholars assume, one of the ten probouloi, a special commission meant to guide Athens through the crisis. In 411 BC these probouloi took part in the coup that brought the oligarchy of the Four Hundred to power for several months. Aristotle reports that Sophocles, asked whether he had agreed to this, admitted that he had and said, in essence, that there had been nothing better.

The author of Antigone, then, was a respected citizen who knew the burdens of the commonwealth and helped carry them. That makes it all the more remarkable how seriously he brought the limits of the state’s commands to the stage.

A decree and a sister

No one knows exactly when Antigone was first performed. It is often dated to around 442 BC, while some scholars lean toward around 450. An ancient plot summary claims that the play’s success earned Sophocles his election as a general, but that is now considered doubtful.

After the war between the brothers over Thebes, Creon declares the attacker Polynices an enemy of the city who is to be denied burial. Antigone sees this as an outrage against the gods and against her duty as a sister, and while Ismene shrinks from resisting, she acts alone. When Creon confronts her, she denies nothing and explains why she does not feel bound by his ban.

In R. C. Jebb’s English translation, the core of her answer (ll. 453–457) reads: “… nor deemed I that thy decrees were of such force, that a mortal could override the unwritten and unfailing statutes of heaven. For their life is not of to-day or yesterday, but from all time, and no man knows when they were first put forth.”

These lines have to be read in their own world. Antigone is not speaking of the rights of the individual but of sacred ordinances that impose on the living their duties toward the dead. Her standard is the gods and the family. Even so, this sentence contains an idea that reaches beyond Greek religion: there are commands that are not valid because someone has issued them, and a ruler cannot abolish them merely because he has the power to do so.

Creon has his reasons

It speaks well of Sophocles that he does not portray Creon as a mere tyrant. The new ruler has taken over a city that has just escaped an attack, and he wants to restore order. “Whomsoever the city may appoint, that man must be obeyed, in little things and great, in just things and unjust,” he says (ll. 666–667, trans. R. C. Jebb). And further, in Hölderlin’s German version, rendered here into English: “For to be without a master, there is no greater evil.” (l. 672)

Those who bear responsibility for the whole tend to regard exceptions as dangerous, and fear of the collapse of order is not a dishonorable motive. Hegel, who considered Antigone one of the most excellent works of art of all, therefore read it as a clash between two legitimate powers, the family and the state, both of which become one-sided. Sophocles forces his audience to weigh the reasons of both sides before passing judgment.

The city does not belong to one man

Perhaps the most modern scene in the tragedy is the conversation between Creon and his son Haemon, who is engaged to Antigone. Haemon begins politely and reports what people in the city say when the ruler is not listening: all of Thebes, he says, mourns the girl who is to die for an honorable deed (ll. 692–695). No one dares to say this to Creon’s face.

Then he reaches for an image from nature: trees that bend beside a raging torrent keep their branches, while the rigid ones are uprooted (ll. 712–714). It is no disgrace, he says, even for a wise man to keep learning a great deal (ll. 710–711).

When Creon indignantly asks whether the city is to tell him how to rule (l. 734), the exchange comes to a head. “That is no city, which belongs to one man,” Haemon replies (l. 737). Creon asks back: “Is not the city held to be the ruler’s?” (l. 738) Haemon’s answer: “Thou wouldst make a good monarch of a desert.” (l. 739; ll. 737–739 trans. R. C. Jebb)

These lines contain a small lesson about political power. The polis is a community of citizens, not the property of its ruler, and whoever stops listening to anyone no longer learns what people think, because they keep silent out of fear.

Man and his limits

Even before Antigone is caught, the chorus of Theban elders sings an ode that begins, in R. C. Jebb’s translation: “Wonders are many, and none is more wonderful than man” (ll. 332f.). Hölderlin’s German version opens with the word “Ungeheuer” (monstrous), and the Greek word means both the wondrous and the uncanny. The chorus lists what man has conquered for himself, from the sea and the field to language, thought, and the institutions of cities.

The ode ends with a distinction (ll. 368–375). Whoever honors the laws of the land and the sworn justice of the gods stands high in his city; whoever turns to wrongdoing is without a city. As the play unfolds, it becomes clear that this standard also applies to the one who makes the city’s laws.

Creon learns this too late. Only when the seer Tiresias warns him does he give in, and by then Antigone has already hanged herself in her rock tomb. Haemon kills himself beside her, and Creon’s wife Eurydice follows him in death, so that the ruler who would tolerate no contradiction ends up having lost both son and wife.

What later generations made of it

Aristotle already took up Antigone’s words. In his Rhetoric he distinguishes the particular law that each people gives itself from a universal law that accords with nature and holds everywhere (I 13, 1373b). As an example he cites Antigone, who declares that it is just to bury her brother even though it is forbidden, and he quotes her lines about the statutes that are not of today or yesterday. In the same breath he mentions the orator Alcidamas, who, according to an ancient commentary, taught that God had left all men free and that nature had made no one a slave.

Some historians of philosophy see Aristotle as a starting point of the natural law tradition, to which John Locke is later counted as well, the classical liberal thinker who grounded life, liberty, and property as rights that precede any government. Sophocles himself would not have thought in such terms. But he created a character through whom the question of a right above the law could be posed vividly, long before there was a theory for it.

The stage, too, never let go of the story. Bertolt Brecht adapted Hölderlin’s translation and premiered his version in 1948 in Chur, Switzerland, and Jean Anouilh’s Antigone was first performed in February 1944 in occupied Paris. In times when obedience was costly and dissent dangerous, people recognized their own situation in this story.

What friends of liberty can learn from him

The first insight concerns the difference between command and right. A command is not valid merely because the powerful have proclaimed it; it must be measured against something older than they are. Antigone found this standard in the gods, later generations sought it in human nature and human dignity, but the question she puts to Creon is asked anew in every generation.

The second insight comes from Haemon. A city that belongs to a single man is no city, and a government that listens to no one ends up ruling over silence. Anyone who thinks about free speech and the accountability of those who govern will find in Sophocles an early dramatic version of these ideas.

Finally, it matters who asked these questions. That a man who himself managed public funds, was elected general, and sat on a crisis commission took the limits of an edict of power so seriously, while still granting the ruler his reasons, lends his tragedy credibility.

A standard above the edict of power

Sophocles was no philosopher of liberty, and Antigone is no political program. It is a play about duty, grief, and stubbornness, rooted in the religion and family life of a Greek city of the fifth century BC. And yet this poet, who served Athens in high office, left posterity a scene in which a young woman tells the ruler that his word is not the last. Anyone who asks today what the state’s commands must be measured against is still standing before Creon’s palace, listening to Antigone.

Further reading

  • Sophocles: Antigone, translated by Friedrich Hölderlin (1804), freely available at Projekt Gutenberg (in German)
  • Sophocles: Antigone, translated by Kurt Steinmann, Reclam, Stuttgart 2013 (in German)
  • Aristotle: Rhetoric, translated by Gernot Krapinger, Reclam, Stuttgart 1999 (in German; on Antigone: Book I, ch. 13)
  • George Steiner: Die Antigonen. Geschichte und Gegenwart eines Mythos, Hanser, Munich 1988 (in German; English original: Antigones, Oxford 1984)

This article is part of our series on thinkers, doers, and historical figures of liberty.

Sources

  • Sophocles: Antigone, Greek text, ed. Richard C. Jebb, Cambridge 1891, online at Perseus: https://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus:text:1999.01.0185 (line numbering); English quotations from the translation by R. C. Jebb (Cambridge 1891; reprinted in Tragedies of Sophocles, Cambridge 1917): https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Tragedies_of_Sophocles_(Jebb_1917)/Antigone
  • Sophocles: Antigone, translated by Friedrich Hölderlin (1804), Projekt Gutenberg (in German): https://projekt-gutenberg.org/authors/sophokles/books/antigone/chapter/3 and https://projekt-gutenberg.org/authors/sophokles/books/antigone/chapter/4
  • Sophocles: Antigone, translated by Kurt Steinmann, Reclam, Stuttgart 2013 (in German)
  • Aristotle: Rhetoric I 13, 1373b and III 18, 1419a; English translation by J. H. Freese, Perseus: https://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus:text:1999.01.0060; German translation by Gernot Krapinger, Reclam, Stuttgart 1999 (in German)
  • Inscriptiones Graecae I³ 269, line 36 (= T 18 Radt), Sophocles as Hellenotamias in 443/442 BC: https://livingpoets.awh.durham.ac.uk/w/index.php/Inscriptiones_Graecae_I,_269.36
  • Hegel, G. W. F.: Vorlesungen über die Ästhetik III (Werke 15), Suhrkamp, Frankfurt am Main 1970, p. 550 (in German)
  • Locke, John: Second Treatise of Government (1689), §§ 4–6 and § 123
  • Wikipedia (en): Sophocles, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sophocles (starting point; references there to Sommerstein 2002, Lloyd-Jones 1994, Scullion 2002, Suda)
  • Livius.org: Sophocles, https://www.livius.org/articles/person/sophocles
  • Wikipedia (en): Proboulos, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proboulos (with reference to Hugh Bowden, Classical Athens and the Delphic Oracle, Cambridge 2005)
  • Greek, Roman and Byzantine Studies: article on Sophocles’ generalship and the dating of Antigone, https://grbs.library.duke.edu/index.php/grbs/article/download/4561/5491/15381
  • Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: The Natural Law Tradition in Ethics, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/natural-law-ethics/
  • Hegel’s interpretation of Antigone, reference for the passage in the Aesthetics (in German): https://journals.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/index.php/wja/article/view/27222/20912
  • Brecht, Die Antigone des Sophokles (Chur 1948): https://en.wikipedia.com/wiki/Antigone_(Brecht); Tulane Drama Review, “Tragedy with a Purpose: Bertolt Brecht’s Antigone,” https://cambridge.org/core/journals/tulane-drama-review/article/tragedy-with-a-purpose-bertolt-brechts-antigone/FD36588FFFA3DC03769CB4FE8E2E2ACB
  • Steiner, George: Die Antigonen. Geschichte und Gegenwart eines Mythos, Hanser, Munich 1988 (in German; English original: Antigones, Oxford 1984)

Featured image: Sophocles (AI illustration)

Leave a Comment

Popular:

Tip: press / or Ctrl+K to open search from any page.